Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Y&R: July 2014 Discussion Thread

Featured Replies

  • Replies 359
  • Views 47.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member

KSJ looks younger than 48. This entire discussion is ridiculous anyway. If women in their 40s were called "old" over and over on this board, there'd be screaming, and for good reason.

If they cast Amelia Heinle or Michelle Stafford as Bianca on AMC I'd be saying the same thing. Bianca's around the same age range as Billy Abbott.

Can you see this dude having bedded Chloe? Or hanging out with J.T. and Mac?

  • Member

KSJ looks younger than 48. This entire discussion is ridiculous anyway. If women in their 40s were called "old" over and over on this board, there'd be screaming, and for good reason.

It is ridiculous beyond belief that some of you are active as if actors in their 40s are frickin ancient. Discussing this guy's age ad nauseum is too much. It's not like he's being paired with some teenager.

It happens all the time. I've given up pointing out that most of the women on these shows look way better than average for their age.

  • Member

If they cast Amelia Heinle or Michelle Stafford as Bianca on AMC I'd be saying the same thing. Bianca's around the same age range as Billy Abbott.

Can you see this dude having bedded Chloe? Or hanging out with J.T. and Mac?

Exactly. They're throwing out his entire history on the back of one storyline and one pairing that was marked by age/maturity differences from the start. It makes no sense, but that is because we all know the real reason this happen.

  • Member

If they cast Amelia Heinle or Michelle Stafford as Bianca on AMC I'd be saying the same thing. Bianca's around the same age range as Billy Abbott.

Can you see this dude having bedded Chloe? Or hanging out with J.T. and Mac?

Easily and the same for Mac. Actually, it would have been harder to imagine the last Mac with DT Billy.

As I said before, I agree with Rhinohide that they have made a conscious decision to mature Billy. Sure, they did that because they couldn't get Billy Miller back, but so what? They've also made a conscious decision to go younger with the Phyllis recast.

I think this show has made it very clear that they don't feel the need to be consistent with age and they don't care about "age appropriate" relationships either. I guess I'm lucky that all three Billy actors have worked for me. I like watching women hook up with guys who are 20+ years older than them a lot less, but too bad for me. Y&R clearly does not have a problem with it and the Jack/Kelly/GTPhyllis triangle that is clearly coming, shows they are going to keep it up.

Edited by Juliajms

  • Member

Again I say, how was DT's Billy this go around immature and not age appropriate?

Who said he wasn't age appropriate? "Matured" is a nice was of saying they've aged the character, which they did. Just like they've been aging and de-aging characters for decades. Not sure why that's confusing in this particular case. I liked DT, I thought he was just fine in general and with Victoria.

I blame the backlash on the fact that they didn't rest the character for a few months before changing actors, but there isn't a whole lot any of us can do about that now. I also thought TPTB should have given DT more time, but they didn't. They have very clearly decided to go in a different direction with the character. Again, nothing that hasn't happened many times in the past. Hell, nothing that isn't happening with other characters on this very show, right now.

  • Member

I think the main problem that some people have with BJ is that he looks older than 40 and he ages the character of Billy to be up to par with his sisters. Here's a list of some actors who were born the same year as BJ:

Jim Parsons

Omar Epps

Michael Ealy

Mario Lopez

Paul Walker (RIP)

Greg Vaughan

Adrien Brody

Brian Austin Green

Eddie Cibrian

Adam Scott

Jorge Garcia

Colin Egglesfield

Seth Macfarlane

Neil Patrick Harris

Boris Kodjoe

Nick Lachey

Seth Meyers

Carson Daly

Parry Shen

  • Member

If they cast Amelia Heinle or Michelle Stafford as Bianca on AMC I'd be saying the same thing. Bianca's around the same age range as Billy Abbott.

Can you see this dude having bedded Chloe? Or hanging out with J.T. and Mac?

Chloe is gone. J.T. is gone. Mac is gone.

  • Member

Who said he wasn't age appropriate? "Matured" is a nice was of saying they've aged the character, which they did. Just like they've been aging and de-aging characters for decades. Not sure why that's confusing in this particular case. I liked DT, I thought he was just fine in general and with Victoria.

I blame the backlash on the fact that they didn't rest the character for a few months before changing actors, but there isn't a whole lot any of us can do about that now. I also thought TPTB should have given DT more time, but they didn't. They have very clearly decided to go in a different direction with the character. Again, nothing that hasn't happened many times in the past. Hell, nothing that isn't happening with other characters on this very show, right now.

Jiliajms, great posts on this topic. Finally, a sense of reason.

Who said he wasn't age appropriate? "Matured" is a nice was of saying they've aged the character, which they did. Just like they've been aging and de-aging characters for decades. Not sure why that's confusing in this particular case. I liked DT, I thought he was just fine in general and with Victoria.

I blame the backlash on the fact that they didn't rest the character for a few months before changing actors, but there isn't a whole lot any of us can do about that now. I also thought TPTB should have given DT more time, but they didn't. They have very clearly decided to go in a different direction with the character. Again, nothing that hasn't happened many times in the past. Hell, nothing that isn't happening with other characters on this very show, right now.

Jiliajms, great posts on this topic. Finally, a sense of reason.

I think the main problem that some people have with BJ is that he looks older than 40 and he ages the character of Billy to be up to par with his sisters. Here's a list of some actors who were born the same year as BJ:

Jim Parsons

Omar Epps

Michael Ealy

Mario Lopez

Paul Walker (RIP)

Greg Vaughan

Adrien Brody

Brian Austin Green

Eddie Cibrian

Adam Scott

Jorge Garcia

Colin Egglesfield

Seth Macfarlane

Neil Patrick Harris

Boris Kodjoe

Nick Lachey

Seth Meyers

Carson Daly

Parry Shen

Not sure what these guys have to do with anything.

Who said he wasn't age appropriate? "Matured" is a nice was of saying they've aged the character, which they did. Just like they've been aging and de-aging characters for decades. Not sure why that's confusing in this particular case. I liked DT, I thought he was just fine in general and with Victoria.

I blame the backlash on the fact that they didn't rest the character for a few months before changing actors, but there isn't a whole lot any of us can do about that now. I also thought TPTB should have given DT more time, but they didn't. They have very clearly decided to go in a different direction with the character. Again, nothing that hasn't happened many times in the past. Hell, nothing that isn't happening with other characters on this very show, right now.

Jiliajms, great posts on this topic. Finally, a sense of reason.

I think the main problem that some people have with BJ is that he looks older than 40 and he ages the character of Billy to be up to par with his sisters. Here's a list of some actors who were born the same year as BJ:

Jim Parsons

Omar Epps

Michael Ealy

Mario Lopez

Paul Walker (RIP)

Greg Vaughan

Adrien Brody

Brian Austin Green

Eddie Cibrian

Adam Scott

Jorge Garcia

Colin Egglesfield

Seth Macfarlane

Neil Patrick Harris

Boris Kodjoe

Nick Lachey

Seth Meyers

Carson Daly

Parry Shen

Not sure what these guys have to do with anything.

Who said he wasn't age appropriate? "Matured" is a nice was of saying they've aged the character, which they did. Just like they've been aging and de-aging characters for decades. Not sure why that's confusing in this particular case. I liked DT, I thought he was just fine in general and with Victoria.

I blame the backlash on the fact that they didn't rest the character for a few months before changing actors, but there isn't a whole lot any of us can do about that now. I also thought TPTB should have given DT more time, but they didn't. They have very clearly decided to go in a different direction with the character. Again, nothing that hasn't happened many times in the past. Hell, nothing that isn't happening with other characters on this very show, right now.

Jiliajms, great posts on this topic. Finally, a sense of reason.

I think the main problem that some people have with BJ is that he looks older than 40 and he ages the character of Billy to be up to par with his sisters. Here's a list of some actors who were born the same year as BJ:

Jim Parsons

Omar Epps

Michael Ealy

Mario Lopez

Paul Walker (RIP)

Greg Vaughan

Adrien Brody

Brian Austin Green

Eddie Cibrian

Adam Scott

Jorge Garcia

Colin Egglesfield

Seth Macfarlane

Neil Patrick Harris

Boris Kodjoe

Nick Lachey

Seth Meyers

Carson Daly

Parry Shen

Not sure what these guys have to do with anything.

  • Member

KSJ looks younger than 48. This entire discussion is ridiculous anyway. If women in their 40s were called "old" over and over on this board, there'd be screaming, and for good reason.

It is ridiculous beyond belief that some of you are active as if actors in their 40s are frickin ancient. Discussing this guy's age ad nauseum is too much. It's not like he's being paired with some teenager.

KSJ looks EVERY BIT of 48. What does 48 look like if not him? Its not like that's old anyway. But my point was that Billy is not a contemporary of Neil. So he should not look Neil's age. 48 is young. Just not young enough to be Billy Abbot.

  • Member

I guess 40s are the new 80s on this board. I agree with everyone I think Cady is miscast as Kelly she doesn't work. Cynthia was much better in the role

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.