Jump to content

Y&R August 2020 Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I think the comment about ATWT and GL serving us better soap than today’s shows as they were cancelled is appropriate.  You add AMC and OLTL to that, and all four were better written and produced than the four on the air now.  Yes, we had complaints because back then that was as bad as it gets.  Well now we know, it can get worse, it has gotten worse, and I can’t blame anyone for tuning out when the shows aren’t doing anything but basic keep the lights on material.

 

If you are enjoying the show, good for you. I loved these soaps.  Not just a couple, or a character or actor, but the genre of daytime soap operas.  They are all but dead now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 189
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Members

I saw that episode too, and I thought the Kevin/Esther scenes were really good, as were the Jack/Victor scenes. The problem I'm still seeing with the show is that there's no forward narrative momentum--almost nothing in a given episode makes me excitedly think, "I wonder what will happen next!" From the two episodes I've seen this week, the only scenes that got me remotely curious to watch more were the ones where Phyllis and Amanda pull some dinosaur fossils out of a cardboard box--and in that case, I only wanted to see more because the storyline seemed so bonkers. But I guess bonkers is better than boring!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Watched today’s episode and wasn’t offended at all although the Kansas/Cliff retcon is still dumb. At least Sharon Case and Mark Grossman can hold their own weight, otherwise yeah the show definitely needs momentum and a hook. It reminds me of the Passanate/Altman days when there wasn’t much going on at all. 
 

Jill’s text to Jack was cute. Too bad we don’t have Jill. 
 

I miss the classics, I better check out what’s new in that Vault

Please register in order to view this content

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Chelsea, Esther, and Phyllis came off as so hyper. The energy is weird, like the actors are trying to fill the cold empty soundstage and it's coming off try hard. 

 

I do like the fact they're cutting away right before kisses and love scenes instead of using mannequins!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Scott also revealed in the book that by the time her memoir was published, she would have already quietly had her first plastic surgery procedure, never having tried even Botox or fillers before.

 

Okay Melody, let's ignore that nose.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Is it bad I wish MTS had become Marcia Brady, after learning she lost the role to McCormack?? Maybe it’s for the best as none of the actors have ever escaped the eternal type cast stigma of being a Brady.

Edited by YRfan23
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Awwwww Brad. I know I shouldn't, but I feel bad for him 

      Please register in order to view this content

      And yeah, agreed that Dante having animosity towards Gio is very forced and contrived. And it also has me concerned that it means the reveal won't be happening anytime soon.
    • God, I love that woman. Another amazing interview!!
    • We can only guestimate based on other characters. Chelsea was said to be 23 in the first episodee and based on Marttin wanting to run for President in the next election, he's about 30/31. Eva and and Kat are somewhere between that  so Id say closer to 25 or 26
    • no argument here! and as she was singing, i kept wondering how many verses ‘amazing grace’ had. looked it up: 13 — 13! — and i think she must have sung  every one. 
    • Yasss, ANITA!!! GET HER!!!   Awww at Smitty calming Martin down.   'Oh, you're the one leaving.' That face like stone. Go 'head, Nicole.    Eva vs Kat...the gift that keeps giving.    
    • I have to admit I still have a nagging complaint about timelines - Why aren't we allowed to know how long Ted and Nicole have been married or how old Kat and Eva are? Or for that matter, when Anita last released an album? BTG is a new show with no SORAS or timewarping. MVJ and Guza are working from a fresh bible. There is no need to be so coy about ages and anniversaries, especially when most of the storylines are driven by past events.
    • It was an extremely rare interview even then - I was shocked when I read it (as mentioned I'd forgotten just how far in she went). You could see how hurt and annoyed she was. I'm surprised he thought she came up with the baby story herself. She and Charles Keating did a good job with the material but it was absolute hokum. Even if they loved Carl and Rachel (and clearly they did), I don't see them coming up with stuff that, frankly, read like Geocities fan fic. Malone was clearly hobbled by NBC and P&G, but re-using so many of his old stories and his soap bible instead of actually coming up with material suited to the characters or show did not help. It was also fascinating reading her comments about Rachel being in her, fighting back against the writing, and how she had to try to mediate. Reminds me of Marie Masters talking about how hard it was to say goodbye to Susan when she'd been with her for 40 years. That subject is always compelling, that duality. And it reminds me of Eddie Drueding's comments a year or two earlier about Rachel losing her drive. Clearly Victoria saw her the same way.
    • Seeing this trash get good ratings says nothing good about daytime audiences. It's embarrassing.
    • Cat does feel committed to being a goofball (the other term has been reconsidered in recent years).  I wonder, given her brother Aaron, if Cat was less attractive prior to the surgery?  Remember the 1973 movie The Girl Most Likely to?  My fanfic for the moment is Cat commenting on how people treat her differently now that she is gorgeous.  One assumes that pre-surgery, Cat never had two men fighting over her for a date.  So, it might be fun to see that side of the story.
    • It's probably one of the only conflicts the story will have, aside from Dante being upset with Lulu when the truth comes out. They really needed someone else who actually knows Gio is Dante and Brook Lyn's son and kept quiet.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy