Everything posted by Khan
- GH: Classic Thread
-
One Life to Live Tribute Thread
That isn't a bad idea, @Vee. It's certainly better than bringing her back as Herb's wife, lol. For sure, @Vee, I couldn't see Karen remaining with Steve forever. Eventually, Steve would've become as "domesticated" as Larry, if not as affluent, and part of Karen's problem was that she just wasn't cut out for that kind of life. She would've been compelled to leave at some point, breaking Steve's heart like she did Larry's.
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
-
One Life to Live Tribute Thread
I'm all for gags, but I think any gag you write into a story should make sense. Herb Callison and Karen Wolek returning to Llanview as a married couple did not make sense - and not just because of what happened on the witness stand either! JL's run on OLTL was so perfect that it's difficult to imagine any return scenario meeting everybody's expectations. Also, there was so much cast turnover in the years following her departure that I don't think her return would have made much of an impact. Didn't they want him performing at the Nurses' Ball with Rick Springfield, too? Or did I misread that? Again, in order for the gag to work, it can't violate logic for the sake of the gag. Now, I did (and still do) wish GH would bring back Blackie/Stamos, but I would have him now as the director of a community center, where he could work with at-risk kids.
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
- One Life to Live Tribute Thread
- One Life to Live Tribute Thread
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
-
General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
I don't understand why Ned is all in a huff about people believing he's the one who turned in Drew and Carly. If I were Ned, I'd be more like, "Well, whether I turned them in or I didn't, Drew and Carly were idiots to think they could get away with keeping their relationship under wraps, so whatever happens to them, they had it coming! Now, what's for lunch?"
-
One Life to Live Tribute Thread
Frankly, @John, I wish Dorian had reunited with Herb Callison instead. Anthony Call and Robin Strasser were just so good together, lol. I can see why. Natalie would not have lasted for very long had she been Ben and Gina's daughter. I don't think I would have minded Natalie being Clint and Viki's daughter had the show kept the story simple, emphasized the emotional beats over the shocking twists and trusted the audience more. It's all the attempts to have Jessica be a Buchanan after all that lost me.
-
One Life to Live Tribute Thread
I think Natalie was created with Tina (and Tina and Viki's relationship) in mind. Even after she got pregnant by Will, Jessica was Viki's "perfect" daughter - likely because, as @Vee said, Erin Torpey was too intelligent to portray Jessica as a stereotypical damsel in distress. Jessica wasn't "messy" enough to keep herself and Viki in angst...but Natalie could've been. I think we were going to learn that Jessica's biological parents were Roxy and Mitch. I think the revelation would have caused a temporary rift between Jessica and Viki, as Jessica struggled with a sudden loss of identity. "If I'm not Clint and Viki's daughter," she'd be asking, "then who am I?". I think Mitch was brought back (even though we saw him die on-screen) so that he could be there as Jessica learned the truth; and I think Jessica would have reached out to him and to Roxy (as Viki looked on in dismay) in an attempt to replace the ties she believed she had lost with the parents who had raised her. But, once Jessica realized that her biological parents were no damn good, Roxy and Mitch would have been disposed of, and Jessica and Viki would have tearfully reunited. Jessica still wouldn't be a "real" Buchanan anymore, but Viki (and Clint) would have "adopted" her; and Natalie would always be torn between her sense of devotion toward her adoptive sister and her fears that her biological parents preferred Jessica over their own child. Some of that actually played out, of course, but I think the key fact in the story - that Alison Perkins switched Jessica and Natalie at birth - was changed early on, because the EP and HW's were more concerned with surprising the audience than with just trusting that they would hang on to see how it all played out.
- One Life to Live Tribute Thread
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
-
One Life to Live Tribute Thread
I agree. In a way, they reminded me of Judith Light and Brynn Thayer, with Melissa Archer as the Karen, and Erin Torpey as the Jenny. Respectfully, though, I have to disagree with you once more, @Vee, about the Jessica/Natalie switcheroo, lol. I still believe Gary Tomlin intended all along for Natalie to be Clint and Viki's one and only daughter and that he and Broderick/Whitesell changed their minds only because the audience was already ahead of them.
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
-
The Doctors Discussion Thread
We need an UM thread on this board, lol.
- Y&R: Old Articles
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread
- One Life to Live Tribute Thread
-
The Doctors Discussion Thread
I agree. I emailed PlutoTV recently and asked them to consider adding "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous," "Solid Gold," "Soul Train" and the Ed McMahon version of "Star Search" to their lineup. Again, music clearances might be an issue, but at least three of those four shows should be part of the Paramount/Viacom library.
-
The Doctors Discussion Thread
Fortunately, DAYS is good to go until 2034.
-
Dallas Discussion Thread
The revival series really needed a Peter Dunne.
- General Hospital: May 2023 Discussion Thread