Jump to content

GH: February 2015 Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 964
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Real people would not make the leap from "this man in front of me has amnesia" to "the only way my husband who is dead wouldn't come home would be if he had amnesia and this man in front of me has amnesia, therefore this man must be my husband"

There was a lot to crititiicize about yesterday but not having Sam figure this out isn't one of them. Jason is dead, the always to be believed Robin said so. You could trot out 40 amnesia victims and Sam would have no reason to suspect any of them were Jason. The only angle she might pursue is a need to talk to Robin face to face for closure.

As for the episode, I had to FF the entire thing almost. Children in danger? They must have focus groups showing people love Spencer or something. I think he is fine to come in once in a while and be precocious and a plot point, but this thing with Emma and Cameron is such a waste of time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Exactly! I actually liked Spencer and thought he was adorable when Nik first returned and they only trotted the kid out for holidays and events like Laura's wedding or the occasional plot point. But this sh-t with him (and the others) being on all the time and having his own story and love triangle? Hell no!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
I get what you're saying. And I'm not saying Sam should make the leap the way you stated. I just think there should be a shadow of a doubt that Jason is dead. Which could lead her to have suspicions about Jake. I think Jason even went through amnesia when he was with Sam.

She had decided, long before she heard from Robin via Patrick that Jason was dead. But Robin was at Creighton Clark, a Cassadine facility. Helena Cassadine was dead, now she's not. Lots of people in PC come back from the dead, are the citizens not aware of that? Sam knows that she can't trust Faison or the Cassadines to tell the truth.

The puzzle pieces are all there. Helena's involvement/Danny's affection toward Jake/the dragon/the ring/the previous brain surgery/the previous amnesia/Jake's unwillingness to hurt Sam/his visions of being with her. We know that eventually she will find out that Jake is Jason, but the way the writers have gone about this story is ridiculous. It would have been better for Sam to have no contact with Jake, no conversation with him about her life, and let the reveal be a true and utter shock. I feel like this way dumbs down the story and characters,

In order to pass this off they have to make Patrick an a-hole that doesn't care about Robin and her whereabouts. They skirt the issue of Emma and Robin's lack of a relationship. They make Robin a victim, and a heartless person for not telling anyone about Jason for so long. Emma seems to have amnesia and forgotten she has a mother. Sam, the private investigator, does nothing to find out every little thing she can about the love of her life's supposed second real death. Everyone is unquestioning of why Helena is back from the dead, so they all look dumb. Then the writers toss Carly and Liz into the Jake story to misdirect the viewer from all the things I listed. They should have just recast Robin instead of this Rube Goldberg story.

It looks as though Jake is the new Fluke with a dragged out story and I have to wonder if the writers even know what they're going to do with Jason once he knows who he is. Whether GH makes it another year or not, I'm not sure I can.

Weird double post, edited.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I imagine this will be dragged out until KMc returns. There is just no way how they can have Jason regain his memory but not race off to free Robin. If Robin is not on the show he can't do that, so therefore he can't get his memory back just yet. Whenever KMc announces she is coming back the Jason story will pick up. Also, Helena needs to return with Lulu's baby.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

You can do the occasional story with a kid. Robin and Mikey Webber both had decent airtime. It's just the stories RC tells with these kids are ridiculous. I guess it is cute to play them as mini adults, I don't know, but he seems to think so. They could have used Spencer more effectively by having him trail Luke and get caught and traumatized with the skeleton, thereby pitting Nik against Helena's plans. There are ways to use kids, just not this way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Robin got to witness her mother being kidnapped and Filomena being killed and was in shock for awhile, it was a great way to give her a little mini story while not letting her dominate.

I keep thinking about that famous Monty quote about the number of kids and child actors on the show. It might be time for a bus accident.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

*sigh* The news broke in again. But I guess in the long run it doesn't matter. I liked Maxie today, kicking Spinelli out. I was glad Diane got threatened by Luke, but if that was me I would't represent him. Stupid that Luke threatens a cop in front of another cop. That alone would keep him from posting bail. When Nic went to see Spencer I kept saying to myself, "pull the plug, pull the plug."

And I remember reading that bus accident thing by Monty too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Thanks @Paul Raven  That Pat story sounds like a lot of trash. Not sure why there was a rut of middle-aged female patients scheming to get men on soaps at this time. I guess at least Pat didn't have Diana raped, like on The Doctors.  Did Leslie stay in that penthouse?  I sometimes forget what a cheesy introduction Monica had to the show. Mr and Mrs Intern indeed.
    • GH 1976 Pt 3  Peter’s new patient, sculptress Patricia Lambert, begins to accept that her suicide attempt was due to her believing herself unlovable. When Peter tries to help her see that she can find love, she replies that the only man who could love her is her psychiatrist. Peter has warned his wife, Diana, to avoid involvement with Pat, but since Pat has done a sculpture of Diana’s daughter Martha, she feels she must show appreciation. Pat pumps Diana about her personal life, and Diana allows that she and Peter have been through hell, but they came through still loving each other and have a happy marriage. When a local newspaper dredges up the murder of Phil Brewer, Diana is upset that the pain isn’t behind them yet. Phil fathered Martha, by rape, and Peter and Diana hope the child won’t have to know. Pat,  with an artist’s eye, notices the resemblance between the newspaper picture of Phil and Martha, and decides to see what she can dig up, to see how good the Taylors’ marriage really is. Pat uses Beth as an unknowing pawn in her attempt to hurt Diana, by asking Beth to pose for her, then stealing Peter’s gold penknife and leaving it where Beth will find it. Beth, now suspicious of all men, rushes off to tell Diana. Diana assures Beth that she’s wrong, but asks to borrow Peter’s knife. He replies that he lost it. Her anger surprises Peter. Deciding she  has given Beth enough time, Pat manages to return the knife to Peter’s office unseen, and pretends to find it on the floor. When Diana admits why she was so angry, Peter asks Pat if she borrowed it. But she’s ready for this; she has purchased an identical knife, right down to the monogrammed initials, and explains that it’s a gift for a Peter Talbot. Then she hysterically cries that perhaps she should slash her throat with it instead, and dramatically runs from his office. As Pat had hoped, Peter blames Diana for lack of faith. He is interrupted by Pat’s carefully timed phoned-in suicide threat. Guilt-ridden, Peter rushes to her assistance.  Seeing her through this, Peter decides there is too much personal involvement in this case and tells Pat he'll have to turn her case over to another therapist, for her own good as well as the good of his marriage. But Pat is not letting him go that easily, and manages to interrupt a celebration between Peter and Diana (they are toasting their solution to the Pat problem) with yet another suicide declaration. Despite Diana’s insistence this is another trick, Peter rushes to Pat. But Diana follows, and walks in to find Pat trying to seduce Peter. She angrily denounces Pat as Peter orders her to leave. He then tells Pat that many patients fall in love with their doctors but he can’t treat her any longer. Peter considers Diana’s following him to Pat’s a shocking exhibition of lack of trust, and tells Leslie he’s available to be psychiatric consultant for her free clinic. When she reminds him that this work, together with his regular practice, will leave him almost no free time, he makes it clear that that’s just what  he wants. To help her over the loss of her daughter, Cam presents Leslie with the penthouse apartment in the exclusive new Top of the Towers residence skyscraper and plans a trip to Europe. But after a period of happiness and good health at home, Laura seems to be suffering asthmatic attacks, and Barbara finally calls Leslie, saying it might be best for Laura if visits from Leslie become a regular part of Laura’s routine. Cam returns from a business trip to find Leslie once more immersed in Laura’s life, and is furious when she informs him she can’t make the international-merger celebration in Hong Kong, where she is to be guest of honor, because Laura has a school play that day. He angrily tells her he can’t, as she suggests, change the date, and he leaves for another business trip in a fury. When Leslie calls to tell him she has reconsidered and will be with him in Hong Kong, she’s unaware that her call has found him in bed with his secretary—a long-standing and frequent situation. But when Cam returns from New York, Leslie tells him she has changed her mind again; she can’t disappoint Laura. The final blow to Cam is when Leslie greets his news about a secluded mountain retreat with the rejoinder that Laura will spend the summer there with  them. Cam, who purchased the place so he and Leslie could spend weekends there alone, decides to get Laura out of their lives once and for all. Audrey has recovered from her suicide attempt physically but not emotionally. Realizing that she needs to come to terms with her sense of failure, she decides to take a short vacation alone. Tommy, upset by the separation from Jim, takes the news of her plans badly, claiming that first she got rid of the only father he’s ever known and now she’s walking out on him. Steve tells Jessie he can’t tell Audrey he loves her at this time, as she would assume that it was pity he felt. Audrey’s vacation serves its purpose when she realizes she has fallen into the trap of self-pity. She arranges to return immediately and take over as superintendent of student nurses. Steve Hardy is pleased to welcome Drs. Jeff and Monica Webber to the General Hospital staff as the first appointees to the newly created “Mr. and Mrs. Intern team.” Steve can see that Jeff is tense and upset every time Steve mentions Rick, Jeff’s brother, who was reported killed in a plane crash in Africa last year. Rick and Monica had been in love, but shortly after Rick’s reported death, she married Jeff. Nobody knows that Rick, part of a medical-mission team, has been kept prisoner by Lamundan revolutionaries for the past ten months, following the crash near the guerrilla headquarters. Jeff’s angry accusation of Dr. Rex Pearson for making passes at Monica is the first of many indications that the Webber marriage isn’t perfect. Jeff makes a fast enemy when Pearson’s needling him about a prescription error and Monica result in Jeff’s flooring Rex with one swing. Terri Arnett, Jeff’s widowed sister, opens a nightclub, Terri’s Place, in Port Charles, with financial backing from Cam. She and Leslie have become good friends. Terri is overcome on being notified that Rick is alive; he was found and freed by government troops when they overran the revolutionaries’ headquarters. Monica’s happiness at the news is clouded by her  apprehension about the lie she told Jeff following the news of Rick’s death. Rick had written her saying it was all over, she should find someone else. When Me the report came, Monica read the letter to Jeff, substituting a marriage commitment for his good-bye. Monica desperately arranges to meet Rick en route, to beg his silence. She doesn’t know, of course, that Rick wrote this letter to free her because his mission was long and dangerous, or that it was only the memory of her that kept him alive during the months of captivity. Monica, having told Jeff she is going to St. Louis to see a friend, meets Rick in New York, where he’s changing planes, and painfully explains the situation. Rick conceals the fact that he still loves her and was - coming home to marry her, and assures her that Jeff and Terri will not learn the truth from him. But Jeff quickly learns that Monica was in New York to meet Rick’s plane, and he takes his bitterness out on his brother. Rick is very upset by this but can’t go back on his promise to Monica and explain. Steve, an old family friend, offers Rick an appointment as a senior staff doctor, but Rick, now not knowing what his life will be, since his plans have all been destroyed, is reluctant to commit himself.
    • I am so over these reboots that on the one hand, want to trade off the nostalgia for the original and then change everything anyway. So those who liked the original will most likely be disappointed in the changes and it doesn't mean anything to newer viewers who have no connection. Maybe if they do have some knowledge of the original they will be turned off, thinking that it's some irrelevant old person's show. Anyone who watched and liked 7th Heaven would be way out of the desired demo by now.
    • I think that kind of thinking gives the writers a free pass. OK let's have Fred murder someone but not face any real consequences because Mary loves him. Maybe she'll be angry for a few weeks and Bill will swear to avenge the death but that will blow  over then we can just go on. The idea that a bit of self loathing and rejection is punishment enough is ridiculous. Especially when these type of characters never reform. It allows the writers to go for shock value over and over.instead of crafting storylines that really delve into a dark/ villianous character. Not many people IRL can get away with multiple crimes and still be apart of a community.
    • I guess Wayne felt it was now or never. He'd made a splash at Days and probably hoped that would lead to a primetime series. If he signed for another 3 years at Days then the momentum would be lost and he's probably have to stay in soaps like so many others. And in the back of his mind there was the knowledge he could probably get a role on SB or GH if he didn't luck out in primetime or Days didn't want him back. As it turned out he returned to Dynasty and got a couple of primetime gigs before agreeing to go back to Days.
    • Please register in order to view this content

      I got to agree. The show was a mess.  The stories that are not working were the ones featured in today's episode. That was a red flag indicating how bad the episode was going to be.
    • Thanks as always @alwaysAMC The remote was panned in the soap press at the time, especially Philip wandering around in the costume as well as some of the comedy.  I have to admit it didn't bother me, even though I knew how ludicrous the idea was of the Spauldings having a wedding at a theme park. I thought there were some fun moments and I did like the scene where Lucy got to cry and grieve over what Brent had done to her.  I think I was just glad to get away from the stories in Springfield, which were bad and getting worse.  There are a number of attempts at revamping the opening music in 1996. I'll be interested in what you think of them. I remember being glad they updated the photos but also noticing how cheap they looked. The show did need a new opening. Sadly, Rauch would instead just not even have an opening for over 5 years.
    • BTG: - Shelley Curtis first listed as Director on May 19   Another FOJulie director. 
    • It’s been awhile since I’ve seen a good soap cat fight so this was highly satisfying. Loved the Drew/Curtis scenes. Drew may not end up murdered but someone is going to try and kill him and it feels like it’s going to be much sooner than later. Who thought Dante ranting and raving for weeks on end would be good writing just to create angst between him and Gio. I really don’t think you needed to make Dante this fuc.king annoying.
    • I get what you're saying, in that this is what allows you to accept what you are watching, and that works for you. But for me, changing the traits of a character that much with a recast and new writing, then they are no longer the same character.  I am unable to accept that a villain is now just a nice dude because the show wants me to, I just cannot.  If they want a grey character, then they should write off the villain and *create* a new character who is grey.  I'll never accept that Sonny Corinthos is a nice guy, despite what GH wants me to think.  Same goes for the villains on DAYS. It's frustrating for me, and not enjoyable.  It occurs to me that I watch soaps to be entertained, and the current show is just making me angry and irritated. It's not fun for me.  I want to honor Drake to see John's story conclude, but there isn't much of interest to me anymore at all, so I'll probably stop following the show in a few weeks.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy