God. This is so bad that even Cynthia Cidre would be welcomed!

Not by me! I've said it before and I'll say it again: at this point, I'd rather see Y&R cancelled.

Why are we going off topic again? Whatever Ron and Frank are doing at GH has nothing to do with Pratr period. Pratt is a horrible choice for y and r. Extremely destructive person and ego. Even Lucci came out and said he was horrible. He writes plot points in the worst way. The stuart murder thing was horrific and Erica and Ryan as a couple. Thank god Lorraine came snd saved the day. She was great for amc but frons dumped her for Donna snd David. I don't get why Lorraine wasn't asked as she was perfect outside choice for the show. She has all the classic writing and resume to make it work.

Kahn/Jonathan don't read this!!!

I don't care what what LaLucci said. It is her opinion! I have watched soaps for as long as she has starred on AMC, and I maintain if GH can be decimated on a daily basis by 2 hacks and the show is considered revitalized, Chucky going to YR should be no problem for the same folks who are against him but champion Craptini. GH is a daily horror show and Craptini are the wrong duo for it, but that has not stopped it from "thriving". Chucky will do the same for YR! Be positive. Soaps need our support so give yours to Chucky, right?

Edited September 19, 201411 yr by ChitHappens

Not by me! I've said it before and I'll say it again: at this point, I'd rather see Y&R cancelled.

LOL While my brain shares this opinion & understands it, I'm not quite sure I can take the end just yet.

I guess I'll use this time to prepare for it.

Andrea, did you like GH from 2002-2006? That was Pratt with Guza

Edited September 19, 201411 yr by cassadine1991

I'm not familiar with Pratt, but I'm sorry, NOTHING and I mean NOTHING is worse than Craptini!

I'm not so sure about that. "Cartini" is worse because it's a two-headed monster of FV and RC but if we're just matching up writers, Pratt and Carlivati are pretty much equal. It's basically an argument between projectile vomiting vs. explosive diarrhea.

They both have the same deep-seated disrespect for the audience, genre and especially the basic tenets of storytelling. If you want to see the damage Pratt is capable of even outside of a soap context, I'd recommend watching the show "Twisted." I binge-watched it one week and you could immediately see his influence when he took over as headwriter. He turns everything into "Melrose Place."

I don't care what what LaLucci said. It is her opinion! I have watched soaps for as long as she has starred on AMC, and I maintain if GH can be decimated on a daily basis by 2 hacks and the show is considered revitalized, Chucky going to YR should be no problem for the same folks who are against him but champion Craptini. GH is a daily horror show and Craptini are the wrong duo for it, but that has not stopped it from "thriving". Chucky will do the same for YR! Be positive. Soaps need our support so give yours to Chucky, right?

LMAO!!!! I guess Genoa City has been a little low on rape by insemination and villains in cryogenic chambers.

First orders of business: Sheila.

I'm not so sure about that. "Cartini" is worse because it's a two-headed monster of FV and RC but if we're just matching up writers, Pratt and Carlivati are pretty much equal. It's basically an argument between projectile vomiting vs. explosive diarrhea.

They both have the same deep-seated disrespect for the audience, genre and especially the basic tenets of storytelling. If you want to see the damage Pratt is capable of even outside of a soap context, I'd recommend watching the show "Twisted." I binge-watched it one week and you could immediately see his influence when he took over as headwriter. He turns everything into "Melrose Place."

Even "Sunset Beach" and "Santa Barbara"?

LOL While my brain shares this opinion & understands it, I'm not quite sure I can take the end just yet.

I guess I'll use this time to prepare for it.

But why would we cry if any of the remaining 4 were gone? They are all very bad. It's not like the loss of Another World or any other good soap. The loss of current YR or GH would be the equivalent to the loss of Passions!

The final 4 should be showing why Soaps should still be on the air. Not one of the current soaps is remotely proving this!

Edited September 19, 201411 yr by ChitHappens

But why would we cry if any of the remaining 4 were gone? They are all very bad. It's not like the loss of Another World or any other good soap. The loss of current YR or GH would be the equivalent of the loss of Passions!

The final 4 should be showing why Soaps should still be on the air. Not one of the current soaps is remotely proving this!

I can't speak for anyone else but Y&R is still my show and still my favorite. I may not be able to watch it anymore but that doesn't mean I don't still hate--HATE--what has been happening to it... and the worse is yet to come. It doesn't matter what condition it is. I have loved it for decades and it's devastating to me.

Andrea, did you like GH from 2002-2006? That was Pratt with Guza

Yes!

I can't speak for anyone else but Y&R is still my show and still my favorite. I may not be able to watch it anymore but that doesn't mean I don't still hate--HATE--what has been happening to it... and the worse is yet to come. It doesn't matter what condition it is. I have loved it for decades and it's devastating to me.

I understand. That is GH for me. I'm going down with my ship, but I will certainly be tying bricks to Craptini's ankles!

Edited September 19, 201411 yr by ChitHappens

I understand. That is GH for me. I'm going down with my ship, but I will certainly be trying bricks to Craptini's ankles!

Ha! It's really painful to see it happening.

What does Ron and Frank anything to do with y and r? They are viewed as a success by ratings and the media. U loathe them and the prexy of abc has said they will be there a long time. Pratt was a horrific failure for amc. He IMO is the one who got the show cancelled by abc. It never recovered and all the actors stated how bad he was. I don't think I ever saw lucci complain except when it came to him. Pratt has much bigger ego as he was a co exec producer and head writer for meleose and just did lying game. Let's also remember he was an exec producer on desperate housewives. He's one of the few daytime writers who has branched into prime time and has success. He has zero history with y and r. Why wasn't Kay Alden called in as an exec consultant? Let's just say I am worried for y and r. I think since Jill won those Emmys she's got power.

Edited September 19, 201411 yr by JONNYSBRO

Then Pratt should be fine because GH offers this very same thing and is thriving - no?

It is amazing how no matter what the topic you seek to turn it into a discussion about Ron Carlivati. I imagine if I said to you "wow, looks like it might rain" you might reply "does it matter? Craptini rain on GH and it survives"

And no, they did not do any of the things I mentioned...not even close, and not once.

It is amazing how no matter what the topic you seek to turn it into a discussion about Ron Carlivati. I imagine if I said to you "wow, looks like it might rain" you might reply "does it matter? Craptini rain on GH and it survives"

And no, they did not do any of the things I mentioned...not even close, and not once.

You're exaggerating, but if it makes you feel good, carry on.

My point was that YOU expressed why Pratt will be bad for YR, yet you champion that foul duo decimating GH. YR will be fine under Pratt if he brings to the table what Craptini has brought to GH!

You're exaggerating, but if it makes you feel good, carry on.

My point was that YOU expressed why Pratt will be bad for YR, yet you champion that foul duo decimating GH. YR will be fine under Pratt if he brings to the table what Craptini has brought to GH!

I will champion anyone who is not Guza and Pratt and anyone who doesn't fetishize the mob and feature Steve Burton daily. I also don't believe I exaggerated anything and in fact all those things I mentioned actually happened on GH and AMC and happened under Pratt. Your obsession prevents you from discussing any topic anywhere without bring it back to "FrankenRon" or whatever you are calling them. Let the people who want to discuss Pratt discuss Pratt without listening to these off topic rants which they could find on every page of the GH thread for the last 14 months probably.