Jump to content

Y&R Malcolm Winters

Recommended Posts

  • Members

With the news that Olivia is returning to the show and the ongoing discussion re Victoria Rowell's(Dru) coming back,my thoughts turned to Malcolm.


Should Malcolm be recast?.He is Neil's brother , Olivia's ex and Lily's father.

Shemar is firmly entrenched in primetime and even when Criminal Minds is cancelled down the road,he is unlikely to return.

Is the role one of those that couldn't be replaced or is Malcolm too important to be offscreen?Or do you think the character is not needed?

Any ideas who could take over?

One suggestion - Terrell Tilford (ex David GL,currently on DOOL from time to time)

Your thoughts please!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Shermar was hot and very identified in the role of Malcolm. Anybody recast in the role would find it difficult to live up to the role. And the physical aspect would be the very first thing people would be comparing.

I say bring back the Barber sisters but then bring an AA male who is not a Winters man. The jumping between the Barbers and winters became scarily reminiscent of B&B after a while. I personally would love some dynamic Alpha male (a little like Ji Min Kim in personality) who, say, Olivia really likes but Dru despises.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Community Posts

    • Welcome back, Tripp 

      Please register in order to view this content

      I’m glad Tripp is back in Salem and I like that he’s planning on being more assertive. He doesn’t deserve to get hurt again. Though I wouldn’t be surprised if some people in the Soap Universe are gonna be mad about his lines today Hopefully, we get some scenes of Johnny/Tripp and Wendy/Chanel. There haven’t been that many lately and this storyline definitely needs them. I think weaving Talia into it would be a good idea as well. She needs a new man now that the Colin storyline is over.  Rafe is still dumb. There really are no security cameras at that hospital that could have shown that Colin didn’t take Abe?? Speaking of Abe, his storyline is total ff material. James Reynolds deserves so much better than this. 
    • I've been rewatching early SATC (am mid-season 2), and am enjoying the mid-90s indie film vibe of the show at that time. It was a bit tougher and grittier but it also showed some of the growing wealth of the city at that time. SATC was always about pecking order and jostling for a better position, but on the romantic frontlines. I also enjoyed the Bad Dating SLs LOL. I understand why it went the fairytale-ish route. Part of this mirrored the evolution of the city itself, as Manhattan became more moneyed and, dare I say, unaffordable. It was a glamorous city that many aspired to live in and conquer against the odds. Part of it was also, as the show progressed, our own growing investment in the main cast and their SLs. Hence less standalone episodes and more a continuing soapy story of romantic relationships. IMO, this was a fairly organic evolution.
    • Lanier is fine but I miss Hunter King as well. A lot of the material AL is struggling with currently HK would’ve had an easier time playing, she could knock out those bratty whiny freakout moments with little effort. AL’s Summer should be written as icier and more indignant.
    • Seeing Harris Faulkner trend the last few nights for shameless propaganda on Faux News, I watched a clip or two, and she is better at selling it than Tucker, Hannity, Watters, and so on. Yet she's never going to be accepted by that fanbase, for two reasons. 
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy