WHO WOULD YOU CHOOSE AS DONNA LOGAN?

Jennifer Gaeris! Real question, who would you choose for Beth and Katie Logan? Plus that brother? I think the Logan's need a revival and they could bring back the class conflict.

I'd pick Marj Dusay for Beth.

Im going to sound redundant(becuz I already said this in another post LOL)

But Ive actually wanted this to happen for about 3 years...I think Erin Hershey Presley would make a GReAAAAAAAAAAT Katie Logan...Someone young with sweetness and spunk!

Love Kayla

Wouldn't she be too young to play Katie? I know Katie was on the show when it began and it looked like she was at least 18. I know the actress who plays her appeared as recently as 2004, so they could always bring her back.

Taking into consideration that the other 3 Logan children were played by performers born in either 1962 or 1965, then yes Erin Presley is way too young.

These are some of my choices for them:

Storm:

Matthew Ashford

Michael Corbett

Mark Derwin

James Goodwin

Michael T. Weiss

Donna:

Teresa Blake

Tracy E. Bregman (might be too confusing though)

Beth Chamberlain

Cali Timmins

Kristina Wagner

Susan Walters

Krista Tesreau

Katie:

Paige Turco

Jennifer Ashe

Sandra Ferguson

Tari Signor

Noelle Beck

Lauralee Bell

Jane Krakowski

Charlotte Ross

I don't remember a lot about Katie for some reason. But it seems like she always felt inferior to Brooke and Donna - so some of those might not be right for her but there is a variety there.

I don't remember a lot about Katie for some reason. But it seems like she always felt inferior to Brooke and Donna - so some of those might not be right for her but there is a variety there.

When I saw the first five episodes of B&B(c/o WOST), Katie felt inferior to them because she had a really bad acne problem.

It wouldn't make sense to make Katie the same age as her portrayer, Nancy Sloan, seeing as though they have de-aged Donna with Jennifer Gareis.

Erin Hershey Presley would make a great Katie Logan, but I'd pick someone a little more homespun and not so glamorous. I'd like to see Melissa Hayden play Katie.

As far as Storm goes, Winsor Harmon would have made a good Storm recast.

Jennifer Gareis is good, Brad just should have used her backstory instead of making up one from thin air.

And Chris, for some reason I can't picture Marj Dusay playing someone that owns/formerly owned and operated a catering business. I see Marj Dusay playing Stephanie's sister. What about Jamie Lyn Bauer as Beth Logan?

I would love Erin Hershey Presley back on the soaps. I miss her not being in daytime....she's a great talent that is sorely missed.

So far I must say I'd leftt Donna in San Francisco.

Jennifer Gareis is okay but the writing is doing nothing for me and the main problem is: Brooke's a fighter - a lone one.

This is when the character works best. And when the whole revolves around one woman already why do you need more people to serve her as props? The Logan's were always dull as dishwater and at practically no point compelling.

Laura Wright or Melissa Reeves would be great as Donna, I think. They have that more 'normal' look as opposed to Gareis, who has a resemblance to Big Brother 7 UK contestant Lea. (That's not good).