Going back to Miami Vice being the new hotness, I compiled how the episodes of 1985/86 compared in the ratings vs. the primetime soaps, sophomore slaughterer, sophomore surprise, and rookie breakout.
September 27, 1985: Prodigal Son (season 2 premiere; 2 hours), rating 23.2, 8th for the week. Finished ahead of Knots Landing (September 26: The Longest Day (season 7 premiere), rating 21.9 (season high), 13th) and The Golden Girls (September 28: Rose the Prude (episode 3), rating 19.0, 20th). The Cosby Show (September 26: First Day of School (season 2 premiere), rating 31.6) was #1, Dynasty (September 25: The Aftermath (season 5 premiere), rating 28.1 (series high)) was 3rd; Murder, She Wrote (September 29: Widow, Weep for Me (season 2 premiere), rating 24.4) was 6th, and Dallas (September 27: The Family Ewing (Part 1 of season 9 premiere)/Rock Bottom (Part 2 of season 9 premiere), rating 23.9) was 7th. No Falcon Crest on September 27.
October 4, 1985: Whatever Works, rating 21.0, 16th for the week. Finished ahead of Falcon Crest (October 4: The Phoenix (season 5 premiere), rating 19.3, 21st). The Cosby Show (October 3: The Juicer, rating 30.9) was #1, Dallas (October 4: Those Eyes, rating 23.8) was 3rd; Murder, She Wrote (October 6: Joshua Peabody Died Here…Possibly, rating 23.5) was 4th, Dynasty (October 2: The Homecoming, rating 23.4) was 5th, The Golden Girls (October 5: Transplant (episode 4), rating 21.8) was 12th, and Knots Landing (October 3: Here in My Arms, rating 21.7) was 13th.
October 11, 1985: Pre-empted for American League Championship Series.
October 18, 1985: Out Where the Buses Don’t Run, rating 19.9, 18th for the week. Finished ahead of The Golden Girls (October 19: The Triangle (episode 5), rating 18.6, 25th) and Falcon Crest (October 20: Blood Brothers, rating 17.8, 28th). The Cosby Show (October 17: Cliff in Love, rating 31.1) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (October 20: School for Scandal, rating 23.8) was 3rd, Dallas (October 18: Saving Grace, rating 22.3) was 9th, Dynasty (October 16: The Man, rating 20.6) was 15th, and Knots Landing (October 17: The Christening, rating 20.2) was 17th.
October 25, 1985: The Dutch Oven, rating 19.8, 15th for the week. Finished ahead of Knots Landing (October 24: A Little Assistance, rating 18.9, 18th), The Golden Girls (October 26: On Golden Girls (episode 6), rating 18.6, 20th), and Falcon Crest (October 25: Echoes, rating 17.9, 23rd). The Cosby Show (October 24: Theo and the Older Woman, rating 29.0) was 2nd, Dallas (October 25: Mothers, rating 22.7) was 8th, and Murder, She Wrote (October 27: Sing a Song of Murder, rating 21.1) was 10th. No Dynasty on October 23.
November 1, 1985: Buddies, rating 20.6, 11th for the week. Finished ahead of The Golden Girls (November 2: The Competition (episode 7), rating 19.6, 15th), Falcon Crest (November 1: Ingress and Egress, rating 19.2, 18th), and Knots Landing (October 31: A Question of Trust, rating 18.5, 21st). The Cosby Show (October 31: Halloween, rating 30.1) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (November 3: Reflections of the Mind, rating 26.2) was 3rd, Dallas (November 1: The Wind of Change, rating 23.5) was 7th, and Dynasty (October 30: The Gown, rating 22.0) was 9th.
November 8, 1985: Junk Love, rating 22.0, 12th for the week. Finished ahead of The Golden Girls (November 9: Break-In (episode 8), rating 19.0, 20th), Falcon Crest (November 8: Sharps and Flats, rating 17.8, 23rd), and Knots Landing (November 7: Awakenings, rating 16.0, 30th). The Cosby Show (November 7: Rudy Suits Up, rating 31.9) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (November 10: A Lady in the Lake, rating 26.9) was 5th, and Dallas (November 8: Quandary, rating 22.7) was 11th. No Dynasty on November 6.
November 15, 1985: Tale of the Goat, rating 22.1, 10th for the week. Finished ahead of Knots Landing (November 14: Pictures at a Wedding, rating 21.3, 13th) and Falcon Crest (November 15: Changing Partners, rating 18.9, 23rd). The Cosby Show (November 14: Denise Drives, rating 31.7) was #1, Dynasty (November 13: The Titans, rating 24.2) was 5th, The Golden Girls (November 16: Blanche and the Younger Man (episode 9), rating 23.2) was 7th, and Dallas (November 15: Close Encounters, rating 23.1) was 9th. No Murder, She Wrote on November 17.
November 22, 1985: Bushido, rating 23.7, 5th for the week. Finished ahead of The Golden Girls (November 23: Heart Attack (episode 10), rating 23.6, 6th), Dynasty (November 20: The Decision, rating 22.4, 8th), Dallas (November 22: Suffer the Little Children, rating 22.0, 10th), Knots Landing (November 21: Until Parted by Death, rating 19.9, 18th), and Falcon Crest (November 22: Storm Warning, rating 19.5, 19th). The Cosby Show (November 21: Clair’s Sister, rating 35.3) was #1 and Murder, She Wrote (November 24: Dead Heat, rating 25.0) was 3rd. This episode was the only new episode this season to finish in the Top 5.
November 29, 1985: Bought and Paid For, rating 24.3 (series high), 6th for the week. Finished ahead of The Golden Girls (November 30: The Return of Dorothy’s Ex (episode 11), rating 23.2, 7th), Dallas (November 29: The Prize, rating 21.4, 11th), Dynasty (November 27: The Proposal, rating 20.6, 13th), and Falcon Crest (November 29: The Naked Truth, rating 17.4, 26th). Murder, She Wrote (December 1: Jessica Behind Bars, rating 26.4) was 4th. The Cosby Show was a repeat on November 28. No Knots Landing on November 28.
December 6, 1985: Back in the World, rating 23.2, 6th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (December 6: En Passant, rating 22.0, 7th), Dynasty (December 4: The Close Call, rating 21.8, 8th), The Golden Girls (December 7: The Custody Battle (episode 12), rating 20.3, 13th), Knots Landing (December 5: Rise and Fall, rating 19.3, 15th), and Falcon Crest (December 6: Inconceivable Affairs, rating 18.6, 17th). The Cosby Show (December 5: Clair’s Toe, rating 36.2) was #1. No Murder, She Wrote on December 8.
December 13, 1985: Phil the Shill, rating 23.9, 7th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (December 13: Goodbye, Farewell, and Amen; rating 22.6, 9th), The Golden Girls (December 14: A Little Romance (episode 13), rating 21.9, 10th), Dynasty (December 11: The Quarrels, rating 21.4, 12th), Knots Landing (December 12: To Sing His Praise, rating 20.4, 15th), and Falcon Crest (December 13: Strange Bedfellows, rating 19.7 (season high), 16th). The Cosby Show (December 12: Denise’s Friend, rating 35.4) was #1 and Murder, She Wrote (December 15: Sticks & Stones, rating 26.5) was 3rd.
December 20, 1985: Repeat of Milk Run (episode 12, original broadcast January 4, 1985).
December 27, 1985: Repeat of Evan (episode 21, original broadcast May 3, 1985).
January 3, 1986: Repeat of Out Where the Buses Don't Run.
January 10, 1986: Definitely Miami, rating 24.0, 8th for the week. Tied with The Golden Girls (January 11: In a Bed of Rose’s (episode 15), rating 24.0). Finished ahead of Dallas (January 10: Twenty Four Hours, rating 22.1, 12th), Knots Landing (January 9: Web of Lies, rating 21.5, 16th), Dynasty (January 8: Suspicions, rating 21.1, 18th), and Falcon Crest (January 10: Conundrum, rating 18.3, 21st). The Cosby Show (January 9: The Auction, rating 35.9) was #1 and Murder, She Wrote (January 12: Trial by Error, rating 28.5 (season high) ) was 3rd.
January 17, 1986: Yankee Dollar, rating 22.2, 10th for the week. Finished ahead of Knots Landing (January 16: The Confession, rating 20.7, 16th), Dynasty (January 15: The Alarm, rating 20.4, 17th), and Falcon Crest (January 17: Checkmate, rating 19.1, 21st). The Cosby Show (January 16: Vanessa’s Bad Grade, rating 38.5) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (January 19: Keep the Home Fries Burning, rating 28.1) was 3rd, The Golden Girls (January 18: The Truth Will Out (episode 16), rating 24.2) was 7th, and Dallas (January 17: The Deadly Game, rating 23.2) was 8th.
January 24, 1986: One-Way Ticket, rating 24.1, 6th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (January 24: Blame it on Bogota, rating 22.0, 11th), Knots Landing (January 23: Altercations, rating 20.6, 20th), and Falcon Crest (January 24: Collison Course, rating 18.5, 24th). Dynasty (January 22: The Vigil, rating 24.2) was 5th. The Cosby Show was a repeat on January 23. The Golden Girls was a repeat on January 25. Murder, She Wrote was a repeat on January 26.
January 31, 1986: Little Miss Dangerous, rating 21.4, 11th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (January 31: Shadow Games, rating 20.9, 13th), Knots Landing (January 30: Friendly Enemies, rating 19.4, 18th), and Falcon Crest (January 31: Shattered Dreams, rating 18.0, 26th). The Cosby Show (January 30: Theo and Cockroach, rating 36.0) was #1, The Cosby Show special episode (February 2: The Dentist, rating 27.6) was 3rd, Dynasty (January 29: The Accident, rating 23.9) was 4th, and The Golden Girls (February 1: Nice and Easy (episode 17), rating 22.8) was 10th. No Murder, She Wrote on February 2.
February 7, 1986: Repeat of Buddies.
February 14, 1986: Florence Italy, rating 21.8, 9th for the week. Finished ahead of The Golden Girls (February 15: Second Motherhood (episode 19), rating 21.7, 10th), Dallas (February 14: Dire Straits, rating 21.0, 12th), Knots Landing (February 13: A Very Special Gift, rating 20.3, 15th), and Falcon Crest (February 14: Finders and Losers, rating 17.4, 26th). The Cosby Show (February 13: Play it Again, Russell; rating 35.2) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (February 16: Murder in the Electric Cathedral, rating 26.5) was 3rd, and Dynasty (February 12: The Divorce, rating 22.5) was 6th.
February 21, 1986: French Twist, rating 23.3, 7th for the week. Finished ahead of Dynasty (February 19: The Dismissal, rating 22.6, 9th), Dallas (February 21: Overture, rating 20.8, 15th), Knots Landing (February 20: Irrevocably Yours, rating 18.6, 21st), and Falcon Crest (February 21: Flesh and Blood, rating 16.8, 33rd). The Cosby Show (February 20: A Touch of Wonder, rating 36.4) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (February 23: One Good Bid Deserves a Murder, rating 26.4) was 3rd, and The Golden Girls (February 22: Adult Education (episode 20), rating 25.2 (season high)) was 5th.
February 28, 1986: Repeat of Bushido.
March 7, 1986: The Fix, rating 21.1, 10th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (March 7: Masquerade, rating 20.9, 13th), Knots Landing (March 6: High School Confidential, rating 18.4, 23rd), and Falcon Crest (March 7: Hidden Meanings, rating 16.8, 28th). Murder, She Wrote (March 9: If a Body Meet a Body, rating 26.4) was 3rd, The Golden Girls (March 8: Job Hunting (episode 22), rating 22.3) was 6th, and Dynasty (March 5: Masquerade, rating 22.0) was 7th. The Cosby Show was a repeat on March 6.
March 14, 1986: Payback, rating 21.2, 10th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (March 14: Just Deserts, rating 19.9, 14th), Knots Landing (March 13: Distant Rumblings, rating 17.8, 21st), and Falcon Crest (March 14: In Absentia, rating 16.5, 27th). The Cosby Show (March 13: Close to Home, rating 34.8) was #1 and Dynasty (March 12: The Subpoenas, rating 22.6) was 6th. The Golden Girls was a repeat on March 15. No Murder, She Wrote on March 16.
March 21, 1986: Repeat of The Dutch Oven.
March 28, 1986: Pre-empted for The Sound of Music.
April 4, 1986: Free Verse, rating 21.0, 13th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (April 4: J.R.’s Rising, rating 19.8, 16th), Knots Landing (April 3: The Legacy, rating 18.5, 18th), and Falcon Crest (April 4: Unholy Alliance, rating 17.2, 24th). The Cosby Show (April 3: Theo’s Holiday, rating 34.3) was #1; Murder, She Wrote (April 6: Menace, Anyone?; rating 25.7) was 3rd, and Dynasty (April 2: The Vote, rating 21.1) was 11th. The Golden Girls was a repeat on April 5.
April 11, 1986: Repeat of Bought and Paid For.
April 18, 1986: Repeat of Back in the World.
April 25, 1986: Repeat of Tale of the Goat.
May 2, 1986: Trust Fund Pirates, rating 19.2, 13th for the week. Finished ahead of Knots Landing (May 1: His Brother’s Keeper, rating 18.6, 17th) and Falcon Crest (May 2: Cease and Desist, rating 16.9, 23rd). The Golden Girls (May 3: Big Daddy (episode 24), rating 21.7) was 5th, Dallas (May 2: Thrice in a Lifetime, rating 19.7) was 11th, and Dynasty (April 30: The Rescue, rating 19.5) was 12th. The Cosby Show was a repeat on May 1. Murder, She Wrote was a repeat on May 4.
May 9, 1986: Sons and Lovers (season 2 finale), rating 18.8, 14th for the week. Finished ahead of Dallas (May 9: Hello-Goodbye-Hello, rating 18.6, 15th), Falcon Crest (May 9: Consumed, rating 16.5, 20th), and Knots Landing (May 8: Thicker than Water, rating 14.0, 27th). The Cosby Show (May 8: Off to the Races, rating 28.3) was #1 and The Golden Girls (May 10: The Way We Met (season 1 finale), rating 19.9) was 11th. No Dynasty on May 7. Murder, She Wrote was a repeat on May 11.
On a win-loss basis, Miami Vice new episode results vs. each show were
Falcon Crest 21-0
Knots Landing 19-2
Dallas 13-9
The Golden Girls new episodes 10-8, plus 1 tie
Dynasty 7-12
Murder, She Wrote new episodes 0-15
The Cosby Show new episodes 0-19
The final ratings were 1. The Cosby Show; 3. Murder, She Wrote; 6. Dallas, 7. Dynasty, 7. The Golden Girls, 9. Miami Vice, 17. Knots Landing, 24. Falcon Crest
Although Miami Vice finished behind Dallas in the final ratings, I think NBC took notice of the win-loss result and that could have been a factor in the move to Friday 9 pm the following season.