For example, Phyliss clearly appeared to be Y&R's new Sheila. Obsessed redhead, drugs and rapes popular man, uses his baby as a weapon to keep him and break up his existing marriage. Near mirror images.

Morgan Dewitt on B&B also seemed to be another Sheila fill in with similar tropes. 

Some have argued that Sam was GH's new Brenda. Tamara Braun's Carly even said so in an elevator scene to Sam. I don't see it because Sam is a much calmer less expressive charachter.

Edited November 25, 20232 yr by Planet Soap

B&B Taylor pretty much replaced Caroline.

 

On AMC,didn't Erica grow close to Myrtle after Mona died? I guess literally and figuratively, Myrtle became the stable mother figure Erica turned to.

On SFT, Jo fostered a teen boy Bruce who grew into adulthood throughout the 70's. In a sense he took the place of Jo's son Duncan who was killed off as an infant in the 50's and would have been that age by the 70's.

I've often thought that the failure of establishing a female Quartermaine through Dawn Winthrop led to the creation of Emily.  Dawn was recast four times, and her origin story was a mess, but a female Quatermaine in that generation had a lot of story potential.  So, Emily filled that void.

12 minutes ago, j swift said:

I've often thought that the failure of establishing a female Quartermaine through Dawn Winthrop led to the creation of Emily.  Dawn was recast four times, and her origin story was a mess, but a female Quatermaine in that generation had a lot of story potential.  So, Emily filled that void.

I agree with this. I also don't think that a replacement character has to necessarily come immediately after who they're succeeding. For example, Megan Hathaway and Renee on Days (both surprise DiMera daughters).

What's interesting is when the replacement doesn't catch on, and the OG comes back. On GH, Tracy-Alexandra-Tracy.

On ATWT, after Doug Marland shifted Lily out of being a central heroine due to Martha Byrne's exit from the role, he introduced Rosanna, a dreary heiress who saw the Snyder farm as her true home and got involved with a studly farm boy.

On AW, as Iris was leaving Bay City, Miranda Bishop was introduced, in a naked attempt to recreate the socialite scheming to break up Mac and Rachel. 

On GL, Lucy Cooper was such a blatant attempt to recreate Harley that she was brought in the very same episode where Harley left. This was not a good introduction choice (for me and I'm guessing for many other fans), to say the least. 

Edited November 25, 20232 yr by DRW50

B&B: Tricia Quick as a replacement for Taylor in 2002. Tricia was also a psychiatrist, looked a lot like Taylor, and had brief flings with both Ridge and Thorne. After 4 months, she was dropped to recurring and soon left the canvas.

4 hours ago, Planet Soap said:

Some have argued that Sam was GH's new Brenda. Tamara Braun's Carly even said so in an elevator scene to Sam. I don't see it because Sam is a much calmer less expressive charachter.

I feel like Hannah was more of an attempt at a Brenda replacement.

21 minutes ago, Huntress said:

B&B: Tricia Quick as a replacement for Taylor in 2002. Tricia was also a psychiatrist, looked a lot like Taylor, and had brief flings with both Ridge and Thorne. After 4 months, she was dropped to recurring and soon left the canvas.

Literally never heard of Tricia until now. To my understanding, Hunter Tylo asked to be written out of the series because she felt Taylor was played out.  That would be comical if the show just got someone exactly like her character to fill that void, defeating the purpose of killing Taylor. 

Obvious exapme but Mariah is Y&R's mea culpa for killing Cassie. Her death was a short sighted stunt move to shock the viewers, but it did not serve the show in any way.

Edited November 26, 20232 yr by Planet Soap

1 hour ago, Planet Soap said:

Obvious exapme but Mariah is Y&R's mea culpa for killing Cassie. Her death was a short sighted stunt move to shock the viewers, but it did not serve the show in any way.

Y&R Hillary/Amanda may also apply here.

On 11/25/2023 at 5:22 PM, DRW50 said:

I feel like Hannah was more of an attempt at a Brenda replacement.

I tend to agree with this.   There have been obviously quite a few Brenda replacement attempts, but Hannah was probably the most blatant.  It was even part of her story that she looked so much like Brenda and that was the reason she was chosen to infiltrate Sonny's organization.

I don't argue that early Sam was a Brenda rip off down to the looks and pairings, but I don't think they are alike at all now and haven't been for years and years. 

When Tom Eplin got shifted over to ATWT, he quickly took the place of Tom Wiggin's Kirk as Lucinda's sounding board/go to executive. Kirk was probably already on borrowed time, but it still rankled.

I'm sure Days would have kept Shane around in 1984, but I don't know if they would have gone the path they did had Wayne Northrop not decided to leave.

Jada Hunter is the a Lani Replacement on Days

 

On 12/11/2023 at 3:53 AM, P.J. said:

When Tom Eplin got shifted over to ATWT, he quickly took the place of Tom Wiggin's Kirk as Lucinda's sounding board/go to executive. Kirk was probably already on borrowed time, but it still rankled.

Wasn't Kirk already off? He and Samantha disappeared in August 1998 and Jake didn't appear in Oakdale until mid 1999.