Sherry Stringfield? I know she was up for Quinn on B&B so she may still be open to another soap gig.

Kelly Sullivan is loved by JFP she cast her as Kate before she was let go. Kelly got great buzz on GH and an Emmy nod. I honestly think they should ask Gina tognoni she's 40 and could be a good Phyllis.

Sherry Stringfield or even Elizabeth Keifer. Beth Chamberlin

First of all, if you are throwing out a name of anyone under the age of 45, my answer is NO.

Sherry Stringfield turns 47 this June

Elizabeth Keifer is 52

Beth Chamberlin is 50

Michelle Stafford is 48

Edited May 7, 201411 yr by John

KMH should ONLY be Phyllis if she promises to act with layers again (like when Emily was married to Hal).

If Sherry Stringfield ever came to Y&R, I'd want her to play someone new and fresh and with no pre-existing ties to the canvas.

Uhm no to Kelley Hensley, she's on par with Kelly Sullivan, she'd gnaw up the scenery

If Kim Zimmer was ten years younger, she could have a shot. She & Michelle Stafford could have played sisters.

Sherry Stringfield would absolutely be a good choice if she's willing. Beth Chamberlin might have made a good Diane, but not Phyllis. Can't believe Crystal Chappell hasn't been brought up yet!

No on crystal Chappell. Don't see it. I think the most they are willing to go age wise is 40. I think she audition many actresses before selecting the actress.

Oh I totally forgot about Jamie Lunar. She'd be good. But I still want Megan Ward or Robin Christopher first.

I picture Sarah Brown being Victoria

I hear Michael Hogan is pushing for Kelly Sullivan!

Honestly, I couldn't count on Jamie Luner to play Phyllis as anything other than a calculating, manipulative bitch. Not that Michelle Stafford's take on the role was any more layered emotionally, but I'm just tired of seeing characters who are one-note with absolutely no depth.

I'm so used to Jamie "Queen of the Lifetime teen movies" Luner playing a nosy ass bitch. She stays playing the nosy mom or teacher or guidance counselor.

Kelly Sullivan is loved by JFP she cast her as Kate before she was let go. Kelly got great buzz on GH and an Emmy nod. I honestly think they should ask Gina tognoni she's 40 and could be a good Phyllis.

How is she loved by JFP when she wasn't even there for the majority of her run?

Ok, I was thinking Jamie Luner but I could get behind Robin Christopher... I really could.