The initial frame for the Lily / Garth based on the Love bible as @EricMontreal22 has pointed out. I admire how Nixon lays the groundwork for the story in research and sets herself up for an out (incest can just be psychological and not physical) if the network balks. Though, if I recall correctly, she still has Garth's physical assault of Lily act as the preceding incident for the murder. And, while Nixon does state that Garth dies in the fall, she sets up the revelation that June is the killer for July/August, 1984, as the cliffhanger for the Olympic break. Instead, the Olympic cliffhangers were Jack's motorcycle crash (shot on location I believe) and the revelation that Jonathan and Edy were husband and wife.
I am curious when the multiple personalities angle was added as that isn't at all discussed in the bible. I thought the Curtis / Trista angle was a smart move to build conflict between Curtis / Jack, but that slowly evaporates over time. Some of the stuff involving Jack and Lily on the run and the murder trial seemed like a deviation of Nixon's original All My Children plans for Phil and Tara, which had Phil on trial for Nick Davis' murder. Though Dane Hammond seems to be a Marland version of Nick Davis.
As we have discussed in the past, Marland was telling an incest story on A New Day in Eden around the time he would have been joining Nixon on pre-production. The scripts I have are from late in the shows run (the final 14 or so installments out of the 66). By that point, the incest story is going pretty strong. It is presented more as a mystery as Logan Clayborn has arrived in town after being outcast with his mother (I think her name was Shirley) many years earlier. Logan had tracked down the man his father, prominent attorney Emmett Clayborn, had claimed had had an affair with Shirley, and the man (I want to say his name was Ham) had informed Logan that he had never slept with Shirley. Emmett despised Logan and, when Logan got closer to the truth, Emmett violated his daughter, Logan's sister Cynthia (played by future Lily Slater Britt Helfer) before fleeing Eden himself. In the rape scene, Cynthia is dragged off screen by Emmett wearing her nursing uniform and, when the scene picks up she is now wearing just her robe.
Logan never discovered the truth, but, in the finale, Logan ended up in a locked room at the Clayborn mansion. The suggestion is that the person with the gun was Emmett, but it is never stated directly. In the meantime, the show was drawing Cynthia Clayborn closer to Jack Wagner's Clint Masterson. Clint was the source of romantic tension between Miranda Stevens and Pam Evans, who had the poolside lesbian encounter. I don't know how ladies' man Clint would have handled a potentially frigid Cynthia.
In terms of Loving, I imagine some of this played out as the mystery of why Garth and Lily were so close. I also think that we would have seen some of that potential tension over Lily's feelings about her sexuality after the trial had she continued. I believe that the implication was Curtis and Trista/Lily went to bed. It would have been quite a source of tension if Curtis had slept with Lily and Lily struggled to be intimate with Jack. I also imagine some pushback on Lily's part when Jack started to explore his family origins given how horrible hers were.
I also wish that they had revisited the Slater mansion. It seemed to be a decent size home and I imagine it would have been a hard sell with it being the site of a murder. I always wanted someone with ambitions to buy the house (like Rita Mae) looking to elevate themselves in society while completely ignoring the spectre of Garth's life and death.
By
dc11786 ·
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.