Jump to content

Y&R: November 2013 Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I don't always bring up MS when talking about SC but I did in this particular instance because SOD or SID or one of the soap news blogs implied that MS complained about the hit-and-run-comes-back-to-haunt-Phyllis SL because she felt it made Phyllis look bad. I disagree wholeheartedly with that statement in that I thought Phyllis and MS were pretty compelling to watch in that particular SL. It was after they quickly wrapped that up that Phyllis was switched into backburner heaven with Jack and held his hand while he got over the prescription-pill addiction shakes (not that bad a story, all things considered).

SC isn't Susan Flannery but she has done stellar work in turning all the [!@#$%^&*] she's been given the past few years into sugar. I wouldn't wish begging Victor and then Adam for some love and having them jeer in her face on any working actress.

As for Victor not knowing about Sharon's bi-polarity, he knew EXACTLY what he was dealing with though he may not have known the precise medical term. Sharon had been in jail and through the mill and was at the end of her mental tether when he swooped in on his grandson's mother. Who he only "romanced" to stick it to Adam and make Nikki jealous, it turns out. What a winner. Victor gets no pass from me on that score.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 427
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Sharon had long been out of jail and had just dumped Adam, she was independent and working when she got involved with Victor and she pursued him just as he pursued her. Yes, he was sticvking it to Nikki and she was sticking it to Adam and they both knew that going into it, heck Sharon had been warned over and over. So NO I don't think Victor or any of the Newmans bear any responsibility for Sharon and her antics, cause as we see playing out NOW she like a fool banging her head against the wall, keeps going back for more and more Newman love, like a Crackhead trying to get a fix LOL!!!

I have yet to read SOD, SID or any Blog that stated MS complained about the hit and rum story making Phyllis look bad, Gtiffith didnt like it and thats why he ended it stat, but so what if she did, it didnt effect her acting at all in that story. I do know JM and MS def did not like tha Summer is Jacks kid story and that def showed on screen imo. SC def complained a lot bout her storues these past years on Twitter, in interviews, heck MAB almost fired her, but she too did her job on screen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I loved those Jill and Victor scenes. She was steam rolling right over him. I don't often find Victor endearing, but that little smile he gave her when she said that she would see about him owning Chancellor was cute. He was very tolerant with her. For some reason, it seems the writers are trying to soften him up. Because if MAB had been the writer he would have been screaming, pointing his finger, throwing her out, literally. all while punctuating it with "You got that".

+1...but that wasn't Victor's normal smirk. It had a little affection in it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Let me jump in here if I may...JM gave the same performance with those scenes pertaining to Summer that he always gives. His scene partner, mostly MS and SC, have always carried him. I saw no difference in his performance. However, MS was clearly protesting. She gave repeatedly ridiculous performances. And it wasn't just with JM/Nick. She didn't give her all with PB either. The only time I saw her giving her all in her final months on the show was in her scenes with JC when she was allowed to Avery out. And that scene where Nina slapped Phyllis was equally ridiculously played by her.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

And your point is?

Not sure why you are jumping in when I clearly stated that MS's dislike for said Paternity switch story clearly showed up ON SCREEN, but thanks anyway LOL!!!

And your point is?

Not sure why you are jumping in when I clearly stated that MS's dislike for said Paternity switch story clearly showed up ON SCREEN, but thanks anyway LOL!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

As long as they don't try to "redeem" her or tone her down, she should be fine with anyone. I don't mind her interacting with Cane, his judgmental attitude and finger pointing, makes her sympathetic. But please, no romantic pairing. EVER! Let Lily and the Laners have him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Can I ask a technical question of anyone who might know the answer?

On tomorrow's show, Chloe and Adam have a brief civil conversation. On the day those scenes were taped, did Elizabeth Hendrickson know that "Adam" was most likely the hit and run driver?

And, I just have to laugh when I see the no spitting sign in the prison yard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I like Hilary too. I have from jump despite her terrible intro story. I hope she's not dicktamized anytime soon. I'd hate to see her fire doused by some man. I also don't want her to be suddenly pushed as some schemer turned heroine either ala Chelsea. Keep her scheming and hustling. As for Hilary and Cane, I can't even take that fool seriously the way he be eye phucking Hilary while acting righteous. He needs to run along and start his little company with Lily.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I'm going to respond to you about this show. I've been accused of hating on it for some reason or another. But as a 53-year-old black man I do not hate this show at all. It heavily represents people like me, but I want it to be treated well and not just pushed with half-assedness, which is what I feel has happened on several occasions so far. Bad editing, bad cliffhangers, or no cliffhangers at all, disappearing characters with dropped storylines, etc. I can understand shows no longer wanting certain characters or  storylines, but why the "Judy Winslow" effect?
    • I love many things about BTG very much. For me, it's greatest strength is how the family relationships are so beautifully written. The deep love between family members while acknowledging each other's flaws--it's SO GOOD.  The best of the best is the two sister relationships: loving but very different sisters Dani and Nicole and adversarial sisters Kat and Eva. These two relationships can anchor the show for many years to come, in my opinion. (The one caveat is that the young and very talented Colby and Ambyr may want to leave the show sooner rather than later, but that's to be expected). My biggest problem with this show is this: Where are the romantic love stories? Where are the star-crossed lovers? Almost every character on this show is married, or in a committed relationship, or just fooling around. Right now the only potential for this are in the Ashley/Andre/Derek and Kat/Tomas/Eva situations. Like a lot of people, I feel the sooner they ditch Ashley and Derek, the better. I hate picking on actors, but the characters are so blah and bland it's like they're a parody of soap characters. I like Andre, and there's some indication they might have him become more serious about Dani, but I don't see that becoming a big love story. I could be wrong. Kat and Eva fighting over a man would be amazing. Over Tomas? No.  I've noticed on social media some people are starting to ship Kat and Jacob. I think that shows how much viewers long for a messy love story. There is much I enjoy about BTG and I have no intention of bailing on it. But over all my many years of watching soap operas, the thing that always got me the most excited about them was the question: "When are those two finally going to get together?"
    • FROM THE VAULT: WEEKLY DAYTIME NIELSEN RATINGS: WEEKS OF 11/26/73-11/30/73 & 12/3/73-12/7/73:

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Please register in order to view this content

        Some initial thoughts.   1) a Who's who back in the day with an assortment of well known performers. 2) Surprised Debra Messing would agree to play a conservative character 3) Not surprised a network didn't pick this up because showing a conservative that is human/likable is a no no in Hollywood LOL
    • Yes from when they went on Let’s Make a Deal too. Pam stole Forrester designs for Jackie M. Of course a month later we saw Nick, Lesley, Owen, and Bridget all exit in the same episode.
    • Great pairing that seemed to come out of the blue! Around that time, it felt like Sheffer/Goutman didn’t really know what to do with Emily or Hal. And KM and BH had surprisingly great chemistry. It was good for Emily especially because she was coming off those unsympathetic years with the Tom affair and then running the Intruder and essentially just being a busybody.
    • I think the issue with Lulu is less the character (which was the issue in the Julie Berman days under Guza II) and more the lack of nuance. The current GH team rarely writes nuance for any character or at least can't sustain it for long, or they reserve it for a favored few. I also think the rooting interest at GH BTS often remains on preferred characters or actors - BLQ/Setton - vs. Laura's kids. So it's easy to make Lulu the heavy if you think Brook Lynn and Chase are the money on this show. I don't, but I think FV does. And that's not to say I think Amanda Setton is bad in the role, or that I would get rid of BLQ. I don't trend towards either (though I do think that if Setton's personal beliefs keep getting in the way of material I would reluctantly recast). I think Brook Lynn is essential to use as a lead presently. But I don't think it needs to be the black and white dichotomy of suffering young matriarch BLQ and aggressor Lulu. While it's good that unlike in the Guza years they can recognize that Lulu can be obnoxious and rash, can be her own worst enemy and that that is part of the character, it can be toned down or given more layers than it has of late. There's nothing wrong there the writing can't fix.
    • 1999: I just watched it. It felt so primetime. La Lucci is making history. Aretha's daydreaming segment. @Contessa Donatella Thank you, my love. So helpful and informative as always. adding them to my queue.
    • I know this isn’t a usual or anywhere near universal take, but I loved the relatively brief Hal/Emily relationship/marriage more than I ever thought I would have with KMH/BH.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy