1 hour ago, DRW50 said:

 

That's why FMB used to have him do singing and dancing, which was dropped after she left.

 

Don't remind me. I remember one episode where they had Jack doing a very cheesy rendition of an Elvis-like impersonation.  It had no place in there. I was glad when they stopped doing it.

At least the man can carry a tune. Although the CarJacker in me always resented the fact he crooned at JuliaI. 

On 11/12/2017 at 7:03 PM, DramatistDreamer said:

 

Don't remind me. I remember one episode where they had Jack doing a very cheesy rendition of an Elvis-like impersonation.  It had no place in there. I was glad when they stopped doing it.

God I hate when they have character's sing..even if they sound good. I remember Jack bursting out with a little song and dance number in the police station and it was just so..."Hey LOOK at me...I'm not JUST a soap actor!"  It would have been fine if the other cops would have teased him.."Hey twinkle toes do you take requests?"

 

But then nothing was scarier then Lisa crawling up on that piano!!!

 

I think it's fine for an actor to sing and dance, provided 1) his character is, in fact, a professional entertainer; or 2) there's an actual, story-driven reason (no matter how hokey) for the number -- like, say, as part of a talent show that everyone in town is participating in to raise money for something or someone?  Otherwise, regardless of their level of talent, I think it's just so damn awkward to watch.

Edited November 14, 20178 yr by Khan

20 minutes ago, Khan said:

I think it's fine for an actor to sing and dance, provided 1) his character is, in fact, a professional entertainer; or 2) there's an actual, story-driven reason (no matter how hokey) for the number -- like, say, as part of a talent show that everyone in town is participating in to raise money for something or someone?  Otherwise, regardless of their level of talent, I think it's just so damn awkward to watch.

 

Agreed. The Nurses Ball on GH is a good example, and as a rule I HATE talent show episodes on TV (mostly on sitcoms).

Conversely, what was the best musical moment from the show (guest singers like Whitney Houston don't count)?

Best musical moment? That wasn't a professional? Maybe the moment when Lily's found belting out "I can't make you love me".... the very first time. 

But Craig's surprising Lyla dressed as a lounge lizard has a special place in my heart. 

What I wish I could have seen is Kim's singing the night she bedded Bob. Or any of KH singing. I don't really ever recall Kim singing anything throughout the years. 

 

4 minutes ago, P.J. said:

Best musical moment? That wasn't a professional? Maybe the moment when Lily's found belting out "I can't make you love me".... the very first time. 

But Craig's surprising Lyla dressed as a lounge lizard has a special place in my heart. 

What I wish I could have seen is Kim's singing the night she bedded Bob. Or any of KH singing. I don't really ever recall Kim singing anything throughout the years. 

 

 

They sing at their wedding reception. 

 

(which is also my favorite musical moment on ATWT)

 

 

When the cast sang at Chris and Nancy Hughes' wedding anniversary. It was poignant and heartfelt and completely fit the moment.

14 hours ago, DramatistDreamer said:

When the cast sang at Chris and Nancy Hughes' wedding anniversary. It was poignant and heartfelt and completely fit the moment.

Except..God love her...Helen Wagner should never have been allowed to sing...Oy!!!

 

Speaking of Dolan said that BH and SH had an impression of Wagner that would crack her up..I would have loved to have seen that!

Yeah @Mitch that high-note sort of came out of nowhere but the scene was so poignant, I was/am willing to overlook that pitchy moment.

1 hour ago, DramatistDreamer said:

Yeah @Mitch that high-note sort of came out of nowhere but the scene was so poignant, I was/am willing to overlook that pitchy moment.

True, and it was nice, after the crappy way Nancy and Chris and the Hughes had been treated for 4 years to see that. Anyone who watched during the Dobson's and Bunim years would never think they would make them the centerpiece of the 30th anniversary..(though I have qualms that they were having their 50th anniversary when it was obvious that Bob was older then 50...)

 

Though you can hear Wagner's high pitched "singing" on the Christmas shows also...oh my God, I am saying something bad about Nancy Hughes, I am going to Hell!!

Edited November 15, 20178 yr by Mitch

3 hours ago, Mitch said:

Speaking of Dolan said that BH and SH had an impression of Wagner that would crack her up..I would have loved to have seen that!

I remember on one special episode (either Christmas or an anniversary), there is a scene of Ben Hendrickson (with his back to the camera) doing some sort of impression to a large group of the cast. The cast just roared laughing, but you couldn't see what he was doing.  

I’ve been watching Laiman ATWT all night.

 

And it is so damn good. I have to say that at the time I thought the show was stupid as hell but it is Marland compared to today’s soaps. There are definitely things I’m rolling my eyes at, but there are also things I didn’t like at the time that I can appreciate now. 

 

i just watched the episode where Katie is confronted by her stalker (not realizing that she had a stalker, thinking she and Henry had made the whole thing up) and it was so fabulous. Suspenseful, well acted, and surprisingly great production values that you would never see now. Best part of all is knowing that the payoff from that episode wouldn’t come till a full 4 months later. This was back when soaps made you wait for a payoff. 

^

Loved Katie's stalker story/WOAK arc and is one of the few stories I enjoyed with Katie. Why? B/c they didn't try making her the town saint and prop her up, which they'd do in later years. I loved the pay off where she got exposed at the Endicott awards for all her deviant acts and we saw her fall from grace. 

 

Katie was interesting when she was bad. When they declawed her with Simon and even later with Mike and Jack, I loathed her. It annoyed me that Kim and Nancy would only be brought out at times to speak highly of Katie.