3 minutes ago, Soapsuds said:

I like him as an actor but he is totally miscast as Billy.

 

My wish is for Amelia to be next and they somehow bring back Heather Tom as Victoria. 

 

Miscast is the kindest word!  Amelia has been Vicky too long and Sony likes her.  

 

 

I’m at a loss. I loved Michelle Stafford as Phyllis, but she was so disinterested in the role her past couple years and it showed. I thought her acting was good on GH even though her character was pointless. Gina was such a good Phyllis I honestly forgot she was a recast. I don’t think this was needed. Hmmmm. It’s interesting for sure but I don’t know what to think. 

I don't think MS was disinterested, she just didn't want an age appropriate love interest.  Staff wanted Morrow but the show was moving away from that.  

Gross.

Why they don’t have the balls to do this to Amelia boring aaahh 😂😂 Amelia out; Sarah Brown/Heather Tom in as Victoria.

Gina Tognoni

5 mins · 

 

 

Wow ok. GT deserves better. I’m not a Phyllis fan regardless of who plays her, but I recognize she’s a pivotal character on the canvas that Sony has built over the past 20 years. MS does embody the character, and now they can play more of the history. But the tics. GT has her share of affectations, but MS takes the cake. I do agree Jason Thompson is a marked man with this news. 

2 minutes ago, Dr Neil Curtis said:

Why they don’t have the balls to do this to Amelia boring aaahh 😂😂 Amelia out; Sarah Brown/Heather Tom in as Victoria.

Preach. I think if this next pairing bombs, they may consider it.

Gina Tognoni was definitely miscast as Phyllis but ugh, Michelle Stafford is shady as sh*t and last time around she seemed to give zero effort in her final appearances, she made it quite obvious that she didn't want to be paired with PB, who she had her best chemistry with. 

 

MS could be good when reined in but whew, when she's not...Y&R better make sure they have a director who knows her/his stuff because, whew, MS is a doozy!

 

I haven't been watching and see no reason to tune in (other than the tribute episodes for Neil/KSJ), so you'll have to let me know how this turns out.

Re: Heinle. If Billy Miller also jumps ship from GH and returns, we know she’s absolutely safe beyond a shadow of a doubt. None of AH’s pairings since BM have worked, and they’ve got to be aware of that.

 

Between the new Nate and this, sounds like they are really looking at their cast and seeing who’s working and who’s not. They’re not afraid to recast if an actor isn’t clicking but the role is needed.

Edited March 31, 20196 yr by Faulkner

10 minutes ago, DeeeDee said:

Gross.

Hell is freezing over....first Victoria Rowell is brought back and now this....

Along with a new younger Adam doesn't this really screw with ages of Abbott/Newmans?  Now Billy is older than Adam and he seems out of the range of both Phyllis and Sharon.

Don't be shocked if you see more of Daniel Grazadei(sp).  His presence will now make sense.  There was no way you could have him onscreen with Gina as Phyllis.  

WOW

 

No way is Stafford returning for a romantic pairing with PB, not under JG/AM

Given this guy’s distaste for Phyllis as she’s been written with GT in the role, I had to see what he thought:

 

 

Lord why????.....