Discuss...

 

 

 

 

 

I wonder what the new thing people will gripe about this time? Maybe a prop is placed facing a different direction and that is grounds for Sally to get fire

13 minutes ago, cassadine1991 said:

Discuss...

 

 

 

 

 

I wonder what the new thing people will gripe about this time? Maybe a prop is placed facing a different direction and that is grounds for Sally to get fire

Most of the criticisms I've seen in the thread have been pretty detailed and intelligent. 

But the show is better than it's been in YEARS.  So get over it you guys.

12 minutes ago, juniorz1 said:

But the show is better than it's been in YEARS.  So get over it you guys.

 

 

3 hours ago, slick jones said:

 

3 hours ago, cassadine1991 said:

Discuss...

 

 

 

 

 

I wonder what the new thing people will gripe about this time? Maybe a prop is placed facing a different direction and that is grounds for Sally to get fire

 

1 hour ago, juniorz1 said:

But the show is better than it's been in YEARS.  So get over it you guys.

Really?? You come off so rude. You haven't even posted here in years. Why not say what you like about the show instead of being so negative to those that don't like SS writing.

4 hours ago, DRW50 said:

Most of the criticisms I've seen in the thread have been pretty detailed and intelligent. 

 

Exactly.This reminds me of the early MAB bias where any criticism got dismissed or downplayed just because of the Bell at the end of her name. You can say Sally's not as bad as Pratt, Pissy & Shelly, etc but that doesn't absolve her from critique when she's got plenty of her own glaring issues.

2 hours ago, detroitpiston said:

 

Exactly.This reminds me of the early MAB bias where any criticism got dismissed or downplayed just because of the Bell at the end of her name. You can say Sally's not as bad as Pratt, Pissy & Shelly, etc but that doesn't absolve her from critique when she's got plenty of her own glaring issues.

 

I don't agree with that. I don't really remember the MAB talk on the boards. Sally's not above being criticized but sometimes it's a bit overdone, but that's IMHO. I'm not telling anyone what they can and cannot say. Criticize away LOL but it can always be worse. I still trust her with the show despite her shortcomings. But people were calling for her head weeks after she started. It was a bit much.

 

I don't blame her for everything because I have no doubts she's often told who to write for and focus on. Sure she can take a lot of the blame as she should but people put her on some pedestal before she started, she was never going to live up to certain expectations, no one does.

Edited June 1, 20178 yr by KMan101

9 minutes ago, KMan101 said:

 

I don't agree with that. I don't really remember the MAB talk on the boards. Sally's not above being criticized but sometimes it's a bit overdone, but that's IMHO. I'm not telling anyone what they can and cannot say. Criticize away LOL but it can always be worse. I still trust her with the show despite her shortcomings. But people were calling for her head weeks after she started. It was a bit much.

THIS. 

Most were thought out critiques.....but as this says, some decided 2-3 weeks into her run "She should be fired! bring back JFP and Pratt! their ratings were through the roof with the vents and stunts!! She doesn't get Y&R!" It got old for me real quick. now, IMPO she hasn't written well in many aspects, but things are turning a bit. but...you always have that small percentage that will bitch no matter WHAT is on the screen. they just like to complain.

1 minute ago, Roman said:

THIS. 

Most were thought out critiques.....but as this says, some decided 2-3 weeks into her run "She should be fired! bring back JFP and Pratt! their ratings were through the roof with the vents and stunts!! She doesn't get Y&R!" It got old for me real quick. now, IMPO she hasn't written well in many aspects, but things are turning a bit. but...you always have that small percentage that will bitch no matter WHAT is on the screen. they just like to complain.

 

Very much agreed with this

 

There's a difference between well thought out critiques and complaining to complain. JMO.

18 minutes ago, Roman said:

THIS. 

Most were thought out critiques.....but as this says, some decided 2-3 weeks into her run "She should be fired! bring back JFP and Pratt! their ratings were through the roof with the vents and stunts!! She doesn't get Y&R!" It got old for me real quick. now, IMPO she hasn't written well in many aspects, but things are turning a bit. but...you always have that small percentage that will bitch no matter WHAT is on the screen. they just like to complain.

So much YES to this.

 

Nobody was expecting SSM to correct decades worth of damage in half a year.

 

But it's also fair to say that the things her regime has done during her six month tenure doesn't bode well for Y&R's future.

Today is a perfect example of why Y&R has to keep Bryton & Mishael out of scenes together. Especially with Darnell Kirkwood around.

I was on vacation for 3 weeks and DVR'd all of the Y&R episodes.  I am "almost" caught up with my binge watching and want to say I'm enjoying every single episode.  I did read the spoilers while away, so kept up with the current episodes that way.  I just saw the "new" twins yesterday and that was kind of hard to absorb.  I'm loving Dina!!!!

I'm going to say one thing Kevin shouldn't be around young girls. Did we see him getting treatment?