Jump to content

Y&R: March 2015 Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 334
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I really didn't pay too much attention to her at the beginning or didn't notice her until the MM hit the fan. I don't think she is that great of actress. She is mediocre at best. She gets on my nerves as well and its because of her acting not the actual character.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

So I decided to watch the exchange between Sharon & Nick.... blink.pngblush.pngmad.gif

I am glad someone compared this to Ellen Weston b/c this is exactly what this story is about to be. The Maryanne Carruthers crap on GL.

So we are supposed to believe that Nick killed some girl when we watched him grow up onscreen?

Even though I hate Nick, this totally goes against his character. If he killed someone but has been constantly bashing Sharon and even Redzilla for the past 7-8 years over their heinous acts, doesn't this make him the biggest hypocrite? IMO, this will kill Nick as a character [to the audience] more than when he hopped into bed with Phyllis while grieving.

Going against the show's canon is going to kill this show. They'll be lucky if they even make it to 50. This story is gong to potentially drive a huge nail in Y&R's coffin.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

WTF!?!? I really, really, REALLY hope that you're wrong. You usually are right on target, but in this case, I want you to be way out in left field. lol

Doesn't this show have enough convoluted stories already without introducing more trash. Ugh.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Having love for the actor and character can be two completely different things. Look at Cameron Mathieson on AMC. Most people loved the actor but hated the character Ryan b/c he became a huge ass hypocrite--a huge contrast from the original interpretation of the character. A simple rewrite of a character's past or character traits can kill a character.

I don't think this rewrite will be OK because it will totally go against anything Nick stood for in past years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The whole twist on that story totally threw me off…..makes zero sense at all….even though I know thats not the secret that will resurface again.

I wonder who they are blowing…cause both suck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Not to mention all the other times that Sharon could've used this against Nick - like when he left Phyllis, when she was with Adam, in jail and, oh, I don't know during the whole custody case that just transpired. If anything, this just makes Sharon look bad again. After all the time that was spent finally made Sharon viable again, it's just disappointing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Regarding the mobster storyline: The scripts, the cardroom set, and the writing for Joey -- are all terrible. They seem to be writing a realistic depiction of compulsive gambling as an addiction, showing that it pops into his head all the time -- it has become hardwired into his brain.  The APA (American Psychological Association) describes compulsive gambling as having a similar effect on the physical brain as drug and alcohol addiction. https://www.apa.org/monitor/2023/07/how-gambling-affects-the-brain I think Jason Graham (Doug) is doing an adequate job playing Doug as a compulsive gambler, with the thoughts/urges coming into his head all the time, and being unable to stop. However, the cardroom set is awful and the mobster storyline is a bad cliché, so it's all so uninteresting to watch. I think Mr. Graham is doing the best he can with the crap they gave him to work with. If anyone reading or watching has a gambling issue, check out Gamblers Anonymous.  They have many types of meetings -- in-person, online, video, audio, etc.  They also have resources for friends/family of compulsive gamblers.
    • Today was painful (especially for Philip).  I still feel for Xander. He was clear he was happy sharing and working with Philip. It's just one more betrayal from someone he loved. Going back to last year when he found out about Victor and Fiona, then Alex and Philip. He forgave and tried. Then Philip went behind his back again. He's been walking on the edge for weeks. This is a man who was abused, neglected and has never had any therapy for his horrific past. He has zero coping skills because he's never learned them. I hate this but I refuse to hate Xander
    • Lucy Coe wasn't even this big of a whore. 
    • Kate being the one that Alex called was a nice surprise. The cut to her looking all sheek made me instantly get excited for her to get back into business mode. And the Jack reference from when she first came to town (on-screen) was inserted naturally which is always welcome. When they were talking about how much sex sells, I almost got the impression they were sizing each other up in a May/December type of way.  All the Philip stuff was gruesome. I'm happy the show isn't shying away from Xander's ugliness. I love them both, and it just makes me intrigued for the aftermath for it all to be taken seriously. I cheered when Philip spat out at that Sarah knew the truth. I'm on tenterhooks for their eventual confrontation. I was surprised that Kate wasn't a little vicious towards Sarah for Xander's obvious behavior, but maybe that's still to come. How wonderfully entangled is it that both Philip and Shawn/Steve stopped each other from getting the drug. Both equally at fault. Who/what will ultimately save Bo? And with everything going on, is a Salem where it's looking likely that EJ is about to own the hospital imminent?  
    • Oddly.. Chase and Steve seem to have both vanished from the canvas in December so the Estelle return loses impact when two of her kids stop appearing shortly after her return (and I assume TR leaves in early 1986 as well). The Steve recast doesn't work... but it's odd that he has a long scene with Teri with Cagney looking jealous.. when the majority of his time on the show previously was a relationship and engagement to Stephanie (who he barely has a scene with in the episodes I see). Your idea for Wendy/Bela/Stephanie sounds just like what Ryan's Hope did with Michael/Kim/Rae... and considering Louise Shaffer was playing Rae and Stephanie.. it would have been a lousy redux of a superior story on another soap (that had months of build-up) I think Quinn becoming assistant to Stephanie was Mayer/Braxton... but not 100 % sure. I don't know if Mayer/Braxton was setting up Sarah as a bad girl disguised as a good girl.. but the actress (Joyner) was playing the scenes in that manner.. and Tomlin wisely tapped into that when he took over.  
    • She’s such a caricature - which is a shame because I think the actress is capable of so much more.   I don’t know why Cady often feels like she has overcompensated in her performances. She already proved she can play much more than just Dixie Cooley during her first stint at ATWT (her best acting era). Her performances in various roles since then have been quite strange at times.
    • It feels like the show suddenly woke up today and remembered it was Sweeps month. Lots of action and forward momentum, including a delicious Nina/Carly fight. 
    • Please register in order to view this content

    • Where did I say that you weren't allowed to say anything? Personally I just find "disgusted" a very strong word, and not something I would use for such a trivial matter as a song contest. You obviously do, and that's your prerogative, just as it is mine to disagree.  
    • Please register in order to view this content

         
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy