I'll go first:

B&B

- While not perfect, the show is currently in the best shape it's been in since 2003.

Y&R

- Genie Francis is terrific as Genevieve Atkinson. I know she wasn't well liked in her first few months on her show, but I'm currently watching June 2011 episodes and I LOVE her campy take on the character, despite the overall wretchedness of the storyline. Although I never saw Francis on GH, so I don't have that to compare it to. I'd love to see her on B&B in a Sally Spectra/Jackie Marone type role.

- Phyllis is one of very few characters to actually flourish under MAB (save for the Lucy custody madness). And of course, I still consider La Stafford to be the best actress in daytime.

- Maura West was AT LEAST as miscast as Diane as Shari Shattuck was as Ashley.

Here's another, random, unpopular opinion: as affable as Michael O'Leary was as GUIDING LIGHT's Dr. Rick Bauer, there were times when, in my heart of hearts, I had wished someone hunkier and more masculine was in the role.

Edited June 11, 201213 yr by Khan

Here's another, random, unpopular opinion: as affable as Michael O'Leary was as GUIDING LIGHT's Dr. Rick Bauer, there were times when, in my heart of hearts, I had wished someone hunkier and more masculine was in the role.

If GL were on ABC or NBC, he'd have been fired and recast a long time ago. This would have easily been the new Rick

I hate to say it, especially since it's about mental illness, but Bree Williamson's portrayal of Wes on OLTL cracked me up! It was so bad that it was good. BW is good at OTT mugging. She bored me as Tess and Bess (even if you leave out that it's about mental illness). Other than that, the DID crap disgusted me, especially with Jess, but Wes and Erika Slezak's performances as Niki Smith (especially in 2002) were hilarious.

I always liked Tina/Cord on OLTL, but I liked Tina/Cain more. And speaking of Tina, I could never stand Krista Tesreau. I don't know why a lot of people love her and hate Andrea Evans.

I think Rex on OLTL was even less believable as a sleazy con man than as a leading man. If they wanted me to buy that Rex has ever had sex with anyone (male or female), they should have recast JPL. Possibly the most asexual actor I've ever seen on a soap. And painfully earnest too, ugh! Same with David Gregory, who played that revolting Ford.

I liked Kyle Brandt, Martha Madison, and Jason Cook on DAYS, and I prefer them to the other actors I saw play their characters.

I find Wendy Moniz extremely grating, at best, on both GL and OLTL. Gina Tognoni is always preferrable as an actress (they both played Dinah), even on her absolute worst day.

I love Liam on B&B just because he's played by Scott Clifton.

Edited June 11, 201213 yr by Mathewson

If GL were on ABC or NBC, he'd have been fired and recast a long time ago. This would have easily been the new Rick

be careful what you wish for!

I always liked Tina/Cord on OLTL, but I liked Tina/Cain more. And speaking of Tina, I could never stand Krista Tesreau. I don't know a lot of people love her and hate Andrea Evans.

and where did you get that? KT is almost always universally panned across the board with AE deemed as the one true Tina and KW a worthy replacement. KT, Tina and love arent 3 words Id put together. I didnt mind her though but anyone loving her is an unpopular opinion

Edited June 11, 201213 yr by Cheap21

Well, SOD named her best recast of 1994. Other than that, it's tough to find praise. I have seen one post - literally, one - from a fan.

I find Wendy Moniz extremely grating, at best, on both GL and OLTL. Gina Tognoni is always preferrable as an actress (they both played Dinah), even on her absolute worst day.

If you posted on the AOL Soap Opera Digest message boards back in the late 90's, you wouldn't have had the unpopular opinion. People there used to rip her to shreds... but these are also the very same fans who were thisclose to erecting a gold statue in honor of the majestic beauty that was: MATT & VANESSA

Edited June 11, 201213 yr by Gray Bunny

If you posted on the AOL Soap Opera Digest message boards back in the late 90's, you wouldn't have the unpopular opinion. People there use to rip her to shreds... but these are also the very same fans who were thisclose to erecting a gold statue in honor of the majestic beauty that was: MATT & VANESSA

That was part of it, but there was also the feeling that she was being used to push Vanessa off the show, which I do believe. I loathed Dinah at that time and I had to stop watching in large part because of that Lonitrat disaster.

Here's another, random, unpopular opinion: as affable as Michael O'Leary was as GUIDING LIGHT's Dr. Rick Bauer, there were times when, in my heart of hearts, I had wished someone hunkier and more masculine was in the role.

While I technically like O'Leary, I was surprised he lasted so long in the part, particularly when he was in the younger leading man age range. Heck, they had even replaced the wonderful Mart Hulswit, as Rick's father, for a "more attractive" version. It would have been a shame to turn Rick into another generic, wooden himbo, however; his sense of humor was appealing. I always thought Tuc Watkins could pull off a sexy, yet comedic Rick Bauer.

I actually think Rick Hearst could have made for a good Rick Bauer

While I technically like O'Leary, I was surprised he lasted so long in the part, particularly when he was in the younger leading man age range. Heck, they had even replaced the wonderful Mart Hulswit, as Rick's father, for a "more attractive" version. It would have been a shame to turn Rick into another generic, wooden himbo, however; his sense of humor was appealing. I always thought Tuc Watkins could pull off a sexy, yet comedic Rick Bauer.

He's too smarmy and unpleasant.

I actually think Rick Hearst could have made for a good Rick Bauer

Yes, I had never actually thought of that, considering he was already part of the Bauer family, playing such a good Alan-Michael. But yes, Hearst (or Herbst, or whatever he's calling himself now, LOL) would be a good Rick.

He's too smarmy and unpleasant.

ROTFL! I agree he was smarmy and unpleasant as David on OLTL, but was that the actor or the character? I would hope he could tone it down and be charming without the smarm (is that a word???) if he ever played Rick.

It would have been a shame to turn Rick into another generic, wooden himbo, however; his sense of humor was appealing.

Same. Of course, I'd never suggest turning Rick into another generic soap hunk. I think you could have on a soap opera someone with the right combination of good looks and sense of humor. It's just takes a HW and EP with imagination.

Everything I've ever seen Tuc Watkins in.