@Vee said: "I agree with a lot of this. I think @Darn said it made sense for Kelsey and I was horrified lol. But he may have been right! Megan could just be so crass.
She was the wrong messenger, but I think part of the reason Megan survived so long despite being such a toxic, odious person is not only because she dearly loved and understood certain fundamentals of AMC but also because as Eric notes she was a cynical and highly knowledgeable game player at the network. "
I think this is spot on. (An aside, interestingly in the Kelsey "rape" storyline, McTavish does write "We can bring back the gay friend to help Kelsey realize that she should not have lied about rape. Is he still around. As you know I was against that storyline" I assume she means Kevin Sheffield :P )
"That is capable and impressive. Unlike Agnes and others in the writers room with her who she critiques to Shapiro, et al, Megan doesn't seem to care what story is right or wrong, what leaves a positive impact or is foul and regressive, what makes sense for the characters or which veterans the audience loves; she cares what will bring the show to the top of the heap, what will help it take on Days, what will not make it seem 'old' and leave it in the dust of O.J., etc. There is something to admire in that instinct, though in the end it helped neither AMC nor her career."
Yes! And yeah, I actually appreciate that, I have to admit. Her attitude in general reads as "Well is this sweet story about connection actually going to get us a new audience?" (She makes a point that AMC's legacy has always been younger viewers, and so they should be courting the "MTV generation" to continue that... she's not totally wrong.) I can see why this all put off Wisner Washam so much that he left. I wish Corley would talk to me more about what it was like, but he understandably feels like it's "telling" on his coworkers.
I DO like the desire of Corley and Baldner to redeem Janet, and for me that has always worked (but that also speaks to how I am with storylines like this--I was the kid who when watching Natalie in the well actually thought "well Janet must have had a terrible childhood,...") But I agree, as much as I ultimately often liked the scenes with Janet/Trevor as parents, it was a ridiculous outcome (and I think that's something we can blame on Broderick.) I still think the redemption of Janet, with Laura and Pierce, etc, works--for me, and is good soap writing, and certainly I don't want McT's idea of Janet as a DAYS' Stefano recurring mastervillain.
I stand by being the weirdest teen AMC viewer in the world, I guess, because Brooke remained through the 90s my favourite character :P
By
EricMontreal22 ·
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.