Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

As The World Turns Discussion Thread

Featured Replies

  • Member
13 hours ago, Tisy-Lish said:

Nice analysis of the Dobsons' work on ATWT. They left a bad taste in my mouth when they minimized Chris and Nancy which eventually led to both actors leaving the show. Didn't Helen Wagner say in an interview that, during her last (Dobson) year on the show, Nancy had two appearances?? Two appearances in an entire year? So insulting the long-term fans, not to mention the actor(s). So because of that, I've always been too biased against the Dobsons' ATWT years to write a fair assessment. Although, like many fans, I loved the Dobsons' work on Guiding Light.

I think Wagner had more then 2 appearances..she may have been referring to the last few months before she quit (I know during Christmas of that year she was in almost every episode for the week.) They really did a number of Nancy and Chris either way, and that I can't forgive them. Maybe they had a hard time writing for a longterm married tentpole? I know they were most likely getting pressure from above to youthify the show, but that didnt stop them, or Marland or Long from heavily featuring Charita during their tenures. I think it was more of a lack fo interest.

And yes, casting was a problem. Brad should have been very "sexy" and sexual as I think they were trying to go against the grain of ATWT leading men. Brad should have been a blue collar guy who was making himself better, and the writing told us that the Stewart sisters couldn't keep from horning on him ( the whole point of Dee screwing Ian and him dying in the middle of it was that she became "frigid" and John manipulated that into a relationship..and that Brad brought out the "zest for life" in her, but the actors did not able to get that across. I know its weird, but I wonder if Deas would have made a better Brad...he has a sexy vibe belief of not at that time, and he was definatley more quirky then the usual ATWT leading men. Another case in point, Cricket, who was supposed to be a young Lisa/Erica Kane type was cast with Lisa Loring who could not act her way out of a paper bag and was quickly pushed to the side (I think her hair kept her on the show for so long..)

But it was also the writing, Kim and Nick...the only obstacle was another "back from the dead wife" which we saw with Joyce and Kim spent years battling Susan, a much better and more interesting opponent then "Andrea"??

  • Replies 18.4k
  • Views 4.9m
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • It's a writers' strike episode that was (as far as I could see) not previously up. How nice! @Soapsuds @Mitch64 @slick jones @MarlandFan @Vee @soapfan770 @DramatistDreamer @Franko @Paul Raven @wonderw

  • @Soapsuds @MarlandFan @Vee @soapfan770 @kalbir @SoapDope78 @Broderick @All My Shadows @Khan @Soaplovers @Franko @Faulkner @Paul Raven @slick jones @BetterForgotten @Mitch64 They also put up two April

  • slick jones
    slick jones

    Didn't poor Andy have enough reasons to drink? 😁

Posted Images

  • Member
1 hour ago, Mitch64 said:

I think Wagner had more then 2 appearances..she may have been referring to the last few months before she quit (I know during Christmas of that year she was in almost every episode for the week.) They really did a number of Nancy and Chris either way, and that I can't forgive them. Maybe they had a hard time writing for a longterm married tentpole? I know they were most likely getting pressure from above to youthify the show, but that didnt stop them, or Marland or Long from heavily featuring Charita during their tenures. I think it was more of a lack fo interest.

And yes, casting was a problem. Brad should have been very "sexy" and sexual as I think they were trying to go against the grain of ATWT leading men. Brad should have been a blue collar guy who was making himself better, and the writing told us that the Stewart sisters couldn't keep from horning on him ( the whole point of Dee screwing Ian and him dying in the middle of it was that she became "frigid" and John manipulated that into a relationship..and that Brad brought out the "zest for life" in her, but the actors did not able to get that across. I know its weird, but I wonder if Deas would have made a better Brad...he has a sexy vibe belief of not at that time, and he was definatley more quirky then the usual ATWT leading men. Another case in point, Cricket, who was supposed to be a young Lisa/Erica Kane type was cast with Lisa Loring who could not act her way out of a paper bag and was quickly pushed to the side (I think her hair kept her on the show for so long..)

But it was also the writing, Kim and Nick...the only obstacle was another "back from the dead wife" which we saw with Joyce and Kim spent years battling Susan, a much better and more interesting opponent then "Andrea"??

I agree. Peter Brouwer was a weird actor/casting choice. He was creepy/sleazy in Friday the 13th. They should have cast an actor that resembled Peter Reckell. Reckell really benefited from growing that awesome beard by the time he made it to Days as Bo. I am trying to think of an actor that could have been cast as Brad.

  • Member

I'm more of a GL fan, but this conversation about the Dobsons era on ATWT is so interesting to me. I was so mad when they yanked the Dobsons off GL. We've talked about this many times on the GL board about how this was a huge mistake.

I did watch ATWT during this period. I think part of the problem for ATWT is the Dobsons adapted what they were planning for GL for ATWT. Sometimes it worked, and many other times it didn't.

To me, it's obvious the James/Barbara/Margo story was created from elements of the Alan/Hope story on GL. Instead of the redemptive love story Marland wrote for them, I am convinced the Dobsons were going to take them in a much darker direction. You see elements of that in the John/Dee story as well, a contolling older man who did not have a great reputation with women and a naive young girl.

I remember thinking at the time the Brad character was one of their biggest blunders. All these women crazy for him. I just didn't believe it. They even had a scene where Dee and Brad finally made love and it was such a flop the characters immediately split up.

I think he was probably somewhat based on the Ben McFarren character on GL. While Stephen Yates wasn't the most exciting actor, he had a laid back sexy vibe that made you believe so many women wanted him. Sometimes it's not just the writing, casting is also so important.

With 20/20 hindsight, it's so obvious that the best fit for Marland was ATWT and the Dobsons should have remained on GL a few more years.

  • Member

Brad should have had that late 70's/early 80's charismatic James Brolin/Eddie Rabbitt type of look/vibe.

DREAMS ARE WHAT LE CINEMA IS FOR...: THE AMITYVILLE HORROR 1979

Eddie Rabbitt - IMDb

  • Member

I was most surprised that the Dobson's struggled to write Joyce in the episodes that were made available. Granted, I think it was during the early part of her return from the dead so I think they were trying to reestablish Joyce back on the canvas and having her try to present herself as changed from the person she was before she was persumed dead. From what I understood, eventually Joyce's old tendencies came back in the second part of 1980.. and they put her and Grant back together with her pretending to be ill with Lisa determined to prove she was faking. For whatever reason, once Joyce was exposed and she had left town with her tail between her legs... I was surprised that Grant also left when it seemed like Grant was Lisa's end game.

I think the Dobson's had a good handle on Carol from the 1980 episodes I'd watched and I think the Dee/John story worked... and Maggie Crawford was probably one of their best creations.

I can't think of why Nick was created for Kim and Lyla was created for Bob... when the Dobson's could have started the process of bringing Kim/Bob back together. In the late 1979 episodes that Marland head wrote, you saw that Kim and Bob were being positioned as possibly finding their way back to one another once Kim had grieved Dan with John being the interfering ex husband... but all that seemed to be dropped once the Dobson's took over.

  • Member
8 minutes ago, Soaplovers said:

I was most surprised that the Dobson's struggled to write Joyce in the episodes that were made available. Granted, I think it was during the early part of her return from the dead so I think they were trying to reestablish Joyce back on the canvas and having her try to present herself as changed from the person she was before she was persumed dead. From what I understood, eventually Joyce's old tendencies came back in the second part of 1980.. and they put her and Grant back together with her pretending to be ill with Lisa determined to prove she was faking. For whatever reason, once Joyce was exposed and she had left town with her tail between her legs... I was surprised that Grant also left when it seemed like Grant was Lisa's end game.

I think the Dobson's had a good handle on Carol from the 1980 episodes I'd watched and I think the Dee/John story worked... and Maggie Crawford was probably one of their best creations.

I can't think of why Nick was created for Kim and Lyla was created for Bob... when the Dobson's could have started the process of bringing Kim/Bob back together. In the late 1979 episodes that Marland head wrote, you saw that Kim and Bob were being positioned as possibly finding their way back to one another once Kim had grieved Dan with John being the interfering ex husband... but all that seemed to be dropped once the Dobson's took over.

It also seemed they were testing Kim/Grant in some of the episodes available from 1979. Bob/Kim/Grant could have been interesting.

Edited by SoapDope78

  • Member
5 hours ago, Mitch64 said:

I think Wagner had more then 2 appearances..she may have been referring to the last few months before she quit (I know during Christmas of that year she was in almost every episode for the week.) They really did a number of Nancy and Chris either way, and that I can't forgive them. Maybe they had a hard time writing for a longterm married tentpole? I know they were most likely getting pressure from above to youthify the show, but that didnt stop them, or Marland or Long from heavily featuring Charita during their tenures. I think it was more of a lack fo interest.

And yes, casting was a problem. Brad should have been very "sexy" and sexual as I think they were trying to go against the grain of ATWT leading men. Brad should have been a blue collar guy who was making himself better, and the writing told us that the Stewart sisters couldn't keep from horning on him ( the whole point of Dee screwing Ian and him dying in the middle of it was that she became "frigid" and John manipulated that into a relationship..and that Brad brought out the "zest for life" in her, but the actors did not able to get that across. I know its weird, but I wonder if Deas would have made a better Brad...he has a sexy vibe belief of not at that time, and he was definatley more quirky then the usual ATWT leading men. Another case in point, Cricket, who was supposed to be a young Lisa/Erica Kane type was cast with Lisa Loring who could not act her way out of a paper bag and was quickly pushed to the side (I think her hair kept her on the show for so long..)

But it was also the writing, Kim and Nick...the only obstacle was another "back from the dead wife" which we saw with Joyce and Kim spent years battling Susan, a much better and more interesting opponent then "Andrea"??

It's always been interesting to me that the Dobsons featured so many of the 40-ish generation in major storylines. The characters in that generation were the real stars of ATWT during the Dobson era -- followed by the young adults, with the teens coming up third. Just my opinion of course. Bob, Kim, Lisa, Ellen, David, John, etc. all got major storylines at a time most other soap operas were featuring far younger characters, and using the 40-ish folks in supporting roles. So if the Dobsons thought they were writing the show "younger", they really were not when compared to most other soaps. The only thing they really did was jettison Nancy and Chis who never got storylines anyway, and had always been supporting -- although they did traditionally get a lot of screen time.

  • Member

Were they right to move on from characters like Carol, who must have been around 30 by the time they came on? I believe she was with Steve before he moved onto Betsy.

  • Member

Carol was beloved, but kind of limited in her story potential. Her marriage to Steve was a mistake for the character. Did Dennis Cooney want to leave? Anyway he was gone and there were several months when Jay was offscreen before he was killed off.

It might have been interesting to play into Rita's Christian beliefs and have Carol marry the minister(her real life husband) and become a supporting, talk to. But maybe that would have not have been seen as sexy or interesting.

I agree they should have pivoted towards Bob/Kim with Lisa as a spoiler to them and also have Lisa interfering in Joyce Grant. Try and put all those older legacy characters in one group.

Killing off Melinda seemed dumb as she was a younger character with connections to Kim, Barbara and by extension the Hughes.

Rick Ryan should have returned.

James/Barbara got a lot of attention but he was presented as Prince Charming and I think viewers were disappointed when he turned evil so quickly.

  • Member
2 hours ago, soapfave06 said:

Were they right to move on from characters like Carol, who must have been around 30 by the time they came on? I believe she was with Steve before he moved onto Betsy.

I think Rita may have wanted to retire from acting anyway.

  • Member
1 hour ago, Paul Raven said:

James/Barbara got a lot of attention but he was presented as Prince Charming and I think viewers were disappointed when he turned evil so quickly.

I never thought of James Stenbeck as any type of anti-hero/romantic leading man, at least during the Marland years. To me he was a clear cut villain.

  • Member

By '79 most of ATWT's stories played out in four main venues/locales: Memorial Hospital; the Hughes law firm; Lisa's bookstore(s), which provided employment for Oakdale's bevy of nonprofessional women; and Jay Stallings' construction company, which employed the town's losers and hard hats. In '80 the canvas did not need a silver mining company. Brad Hollister's mining operation seemed inorganic and served no workplace function that could not be met by the Stallings construction firm. It would have been simpler logistically for the Dobsons to employ Steve initially in construction--even as Jay was being phased out--rather than in silver mining since Steve ended up in construction down the road anyway. Similarly, Joyce could have shuffled papers just as easily at Stallings construction as at the mining company, which was largely forgotten by '82. As Jay was eased out, his construction company could have provided an investment opportunity for James as it had earlier for Ralph. A hospital based romance--e.g., with the bland but handsome Dr. Doug Campbell--would have worked more conveniently for med student Annie than would the Dobsons' sudden, convoluted effort to involve the Stewarts with Hollister. My objection to Brad Hollister, then, is not so much the casting but, rather, the character's ill-conceived premise.

  • Member

Yes I think James was first presented as the handsome knight in shining armour with the complicated family ties a la Travis Sentell on SFT.

His family responsibilities, manipulative family members/ vendettas and business deals would be the threats to James/Barbara's fairytale romance.

But instead James turned into first class heel.

The David amnesia plot and rebirth of Ellen put the Stewarts front and center, but I'm not sure it was the best choice as it all ended in David/Ellen back together and unchanged, apart from Ellen losing the bun.

Then we had new young characters like Sofia and Bilan who were pointless additions.

As for Bob/Miranda, lest said the better.

  • Member

@DeeVee @Paul Raven @kalbir I'd wanted to quote a lot but I can barely even post so why bother.

Didn't they start making James irredeemably evil when they brought Gunnar in? It does seem like a real waste of a talented and charismatic actor.

Marland seemed to have real disdain for James. Early on he just seemed to want to make clear that James wasn't any reformed character, even though he was pretending to be. We saw his true colors, and also the exploration of his grooming Emily. By the end any layering was gone and the onscreen result was pure evil turned up as high as possible - he is a big homophobe and I think at one point also makes comments about race-mixing. Marland then goes out of his way to make sure James can't return from the dead (which is undone anyway).

When James is on in 1998/1999, Broderick tries to give a softer side to the character, but that is cut short when Liz Hubbard quits and he's written out.

Edited by DRW50

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 1

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.