I'm all for this. The people on the Facebook groups are horrified. But I think it... could be good? Granted the showrunner apparently is the woman who did Discovery of Witches which I mildly enjoyed but just kinda dropped by the last season (I just stopped looking for it and plans to catch up have never happened.) But I love when animation is used to tell dramatic, serialized stories, being a big fan of the more soap opera style anime classics like Rose of Versailles and Dear Brother (even this year's surprisingly deep discovery A Witches Journal, an exploration of what family is and grief in modern Japan that has nothing to do with Witches.) So I'm always eager to see that carried over to Western animation (the best we have right now is probably X-Men '97.)
I do hope they dive into the soapy aspects and the fact that they have hired the showrunner of Discovery of Witches makes me think they might? And we don't get a superhero version like the comic books. Speaking of...
The DS comic books had some decent art but I think were a mess story wise. However, I'm thrilled with the new complete collection of the newspaper comic strip, with art by the great Ken Bald. Its writer is uncredited but I'm pretty sure it was written by Elliot Caplin, who was Al Capp's brother (and apparently a much nicer guy.) I'm a big fan of the old soap opera comic strips and Caplin co-created one of the very best, The Heart of Juliet Jones (which had stunning art by Stan Drake) which I actually just finished a complete re-read of (the final decade--the 1990s--are a mess, as Drake had retired from it and Caplin's stories become disconnected and bizarre and I don't even know what newspapers covered it.) Juliet Jones actually had a soap opera pilot in the 1950s that you can find on Youtube. But Caplin wrote DOZENS of strips (including the short lived but surprisingly edgy 1950s OTHER soap opera comic he did, Adam Aames) the boxing soap Big Ben Bolt, taking over some of his brother's non Lil Abner comics, etc, etc. And he never took credit. (I could go on and on about the fascinating parallels between the soap opera comic strips and the TV soaps during each era, but I'll save that for some time I really want to bore everyone here.)
So yeah, I recommend the comic strip collection over the comic books. The only issue, and it's a big one, is they were only allowed to use a small handful of characters (so no Quentin, my fave, though it seems if it had continued he might have appeared.)
By
EricMontreal22 ·
Create an account or sign in to comment