Jump to content

Guiding Light Discussion Thread


Paul Raven

Recommended Posts

  • Members

 

I've been watching, too, and while I am enjoying 1993 more than you are, I agree that the show lost something between 1992 and '93. Everyone likes to point the finger at JFP and her decision to kill Maureen in January '93. But I will argue that it had more to do with the loss of James E. Reilly as co-head writer (to DAYS) in December 1992. When he was with the show, all of the plots interlocked like gears in a clock, and the stories twisted and turned in all sorts of surprising ways. After his departure, the show was plenty smart (thank you, Patrick Mulcahey and Courtney Simon) and warm and quite watchable, but it drifted at times for several episodes before getting back on track. That just didn't happen when Reilly was there.

 

After the first two notorious (and brilliant) weeks of January 1993, the show slumped pretty badly until late February or March. The stories slowed to a glacial pace for a few weeks while Nancy Curlee reset the show's course. That was her prerogative as new (well, returning) head writer, but it cost the show, which was peerless in the second half of 1992, a lot of momentum.

 

Still, there's a lot to enjoy in 1993: Ed and Michelle's strained relationship, Eve Guthrie's descent into mental illness, the Roger/Holly tango, David's violent confrontation with Vinny, Bridget's regrets after giving up Peter, some of Buzz's reunion with his family, and, of course, the fantastic who-shot-Roger story in December. 

 

Another observation: Watching the 1993 episodes, I am struck by two actors who did outstanding work and got the Emmy nominations to prove it but who are still undersung, IMO. Jean Carol is wonderful as Nadine, funny and heartbreaking and sweet and rueful and sympathetic no matter what she does. That she was totally repositioned on the canvas in 1993--from the Lewis clan to the Cooper clan--and required to work with an almost totally new subset of the cast and did it so effortlessly is a testament to her talent. And Hilary Edson, who was stuck in a dull triangle with wet rag Nick and a badly recast Mindy, is devastating as her character, Eve Guthrie, loses her marbles over many months. Such moving, chilling performances aided by meticulous plotting by the writers. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 17.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

  • Members

A few months ago we discussed the origins of Blake and how she may not have been originally slated to be Christina Thorpe.

 

It made me wonder if there was ever a concern that people might not remember Roger?  He left more than a decade before Blake arrived.  Holly was not around to provide exposition on his past.  There were few opportunities for flashbacks to the character, given the recastings of other characters.  And he wasn't like Alan where his namesake Spaulding Industries continued even if he was off-screen.  

 

There has to be some threshold of time when writers figure that the audience will remember a past character and those that could not be resurrected because too much time had passed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Before Roger returned to Springfield during the infamous wedding , there were scenes of Blake talking about Bert Bauer as if she had known her personally, and how some of Bert's recipes were so memorable. When questioned about her comments, Blake stumbled and stated that she had "heard" a lot of good things about Bert from the Bauers, but her explanation was not convincing. Later, while folks were going through a scrapbook in Ed's house, they asked who "the little red-haired girl" in some pictures was. Ross said, "I know who that is!" and proceeded to give a recap of Christina's history and her place in Ed's life.

 

Holly also had extensive flashbacks to her time with Roger, leading up to his "death" many years earlier.

 

When the truth about Blake came out, she and Ed had a very poignant scene together. He said quietly, "There was a time when I called you Christina. And...you called me Daddy," which led to a discussion of the past.

 

Holly even brought up the fact that it was hard to believe that Roger would use the pseudonym "Adam," considering the bad blood between Roger and his father...which resulted in more exposition.

 

So even newer viewers would have been brought up to speed on the principle relationships and conflicts from a decade earlier.

 

I don't think soap fans, particularly veteran viewers, mind how long a character has been gone, as long as the story surrounding his return is well-written and his former ties to the other characters on canvas are explained.

 

One of the best-received decisions TGL made in 1996 was to bring back Aunt Meta, who by that point had been off-screen (and largely unmentioned, except for twice) for a whopping 22 years. Soap fans love history.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

If only Mary stuart had gone straight to GL following SFT's demise.

It would be natural for Meta to return at that time following Bert's passing and Mary would have been in better health.

Maybe Meta returns with a long lost Bauer (Trudy's son?) rather than the ill advised Jack & Lainie

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Jack and Lainie and all those "fake" Bauers alienated me. I was furious that TPTB did not mine the show's rich history for REAL Bauer family members. They could have had Paul Kinkaid reappear and prove to be Bill Bauer's offspring. After leaving Springfield in 1974, Meta could have adopted an orphaned teen and later had grandchildren. Rita Stapleton could have turned up with Ed's son. Mike, Hope, or Trudy could have had additional children. Sloppy and indifferent writing and producing, all around.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I was just reading Roger's wiki bio and I thought the same thing about his choice to masquerade as Adam Malik, given that his father was one of only two people in attendance for two of his weddings.  It is always good to hear when writers try to tie up loose ends like those mentioned.  I am a sucker for any scene when a vet character sits down with a newbie to discuss the history of the town.

 

It's an excellent point, however, Meta had ties to Rick and Ed, I don't think they could have brought back the long lost child of Dr Sarah McIntyre in 1996 and expect most of the audience to remember her.

 

The erratic quality of young Holly (Maureen Garrett's not the other one) was really captivating to watch.  Her despair at being a housewife and her difficulties controlling her sexual desires were such 1970's stories.  Today's young female characters want to have a baby as soon as they are married, and nobody ever plays with the ambivalence.  That was a much more sophisticated time of storytelling, when writers appreciated that the audience could understand and relate to a character with more than one motivation

 

It was also remarkably sexier.  Not only was there more skin being shown than we see today, but also everyone was talking about sex and the quality and quantity of sex they were having.  I don't think I've heard DAYS Hope and Jennifer discuss the quality of their orgasms, despite a plethora of ads about erectile dysfunction and vaginal mesh that play between the shows every hour. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 


They really didn't.  And I never understood why.  They just didn't seem to care about the Bauers at all.  Alan Michael was only allowed to be a Spaulding, except for the 4th of July.  Michelle eventually turned into a mob appendage, and RIck was only really permitted to be Phillip's BFF.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

The Bauers were never the same after the mid 80s. Bill, Bert and Hilary died and they shipped off Mike and Hope. I’m actually surprised they let Ed, Maureen and Rick stick around (although they were reduced to secondary players). Of course, Charita Bauer’s passing couldn’t be helped but someone during those years really hated the Bauers and nobody after them cared enough to place them back front and center. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I associated Maureen's death with the eradication of the Reardons.  I know they are not as historic, but I think it is a shame that the Reardons didn't survive as a family.  I was just watching Kassie DePaiva's Chelsea Reardon, arguably the least revered Reardon girl, and she was so charming (you can hear her trying to suppress her southern accent in all the early scenes).  Tony, Jim and all of the sisters were adventurous and romantic.  I adore the idea of a boarding house as a soap setting.  Especially with new nurses and doctors at Cedars.  Along with Matt and Bridget Reardon, they were one of those families that could have produced endless cousins and nephews. 

 

We all know that if the internet was around at the time, every jumbo and their sister would be screaming about how this new family overtook the show.  But isn't that the course for every new family on a soap?  Personally, I think that every writer should get a crack at a new family, some stick and some don't, like the Norris family.  They owned an airline, one would think that there would be a stray cousin.  Otherwise, Holly's inheritance must have been huge.  I know she bought WSPR, but how did she wind up in that tiny apartment at the end?  Also, I forget if Ken got anything in Stanley's will, or if he wound up with Janet, or if they had any kids because I never liked Janet.

 

I guess the Bauers were all "good guys" and that is the characteristic feature of the family?  I would also hazard to guess that the Coopers made them redundant (because it is forbidden by the soap gods to have more than one lower-middle-class family at a time).  Also, who names one kid Harley Davidson and the other one Frank?  However, I thought the Reardons were more worthy of regret upon their demise as a unit, so I decided to bring them up again.

Edited by j swift
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

No one ever mentions it, but Jean Carol - when she took on the role of Nadine, won the Soap Opera Digest award for best/favorite newcomer.  This was a huge deal given that everyone knew that NBC and ABC's fan clubs for DAYS and GH would send the magazines to members and buy many many copies and mail in the votes.  If CBS did, it certainly was not for ATWT or GL.  So for her to win an SOD award which was nothing more than a popularity contest, it said alot.  The CBS/GL people could not have done it on their own...alot of other people voted for her.  She did get a raw deal - I said in other places...Ellen Parker being let go (Maureen), was not the only nail in the coffin.  They made the mistake of letting really popular actresses go...Jean Carol/Nadine, but I also think Jenna/Fiona Hutchinson.  Her relationship with Henry was really nice. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   1 member




  • Recent Posts

    • I was cracking up at how Silk Press tried to hump Not Ted's leg as soon as Kat walked in, but her cackling at the end is getting OTT.
    • I think Doug needs to get his own sidepiece, but not Dani. Dani is only tolerable with Andre (and her daughter Chelsea), so let's keep her there. How about Shanice? She seems like she really cares about him as a person.
    • Does anyone know the air date on the very first time Stephanie referred to Brooke as "The Slut from the valley"?
    • Does anyone know the air date of the very first John & Stefano scene? As well as the air date on the very last time they had a scene?
    • They interacted before when Dani and Pamela were at the casino. 
    • The last few episodes have been good; the acting, the emotions. It's nice to see that GH can still do classic soap opera. I do wish that they would respect their long term audience more and do it without all the silly rewrites though. And where do they go from here? I'm a bit pessimistic and fully expect the show to go back to the drama-less, boring mess it usually is. I'm giving it a month, tops.
    • RATINGS & PREEMPTIONS UPDATE:   1979-Present: 4 Weeks of data missing:   1 Fast Weekly Week: 8/24/81...This week is missing the prelim ratings and full/partial preemption data.   3 Partial Regular Weeks: 12/14/87, 5/20/91, 5/27/91. These three weeks have ratings data (one from Daytime TV; the other two of the three weeks have ratings & share data from Soap Opera Weekly) These weeks are missing the affiliates/clearances and partial preemptions data. Full preemption data is confirmed by comparing the # of telecasts in the preceding and succeeding books.   TOTAL: 4 Weeks of data missing from 1/1/79-Present (out of 2,422 weeks) 99.9 percent complete!   1973-1978: 35 Weeks of data missing:   10 Full Regular Weeks: 9/3/73, 9/10/73, 9/17/73, 9/24/73, 10/1/73, 10/8/73, 10/15/73, 10/22/73, 4/10/78, 4/17/78. These ten weeks are missing the final ratings/shares/affiliates/clearances and partial preemptions data. Full preemption data is confirmed by comparing the # of telecasts in the preceding and succeeding books. For September 1973, the full preemption data is not confirmable, but newspaper listings & Vanderbilt News telecast listings provide the best list possible in its place.   25 Fast Weekly Weeks: 4/23/73, 6/25/73, 8/27/73, 12/24/73, 4/22/74, 6/24/74, 8/26/74, 12/23/74, 4/21/75, 6/23/75, 8/25/75, 12/22/75, 4/19/76, 6/21/76, 8/23/76, 12/20/76, 4/18/77, 6/20/77, 8/22/77, 12/19/77, 3/20/78, 4/24/78, 6/26/78, 8/28/78, 12/25/78. These 25 weeks are all missing the preliminary ratings and full/partial preemptions data.   TOTAL: 39 Weeks of data missing from 1/1/73-Present (out of 2,735 weeks)  98.6 percent complete!   Note: From the Days of Our Lives and Another World research, the full & partial preemptions should be all available, even from the 39 weeks above.
    • Yes. They were very much out of ideas for Reva by this time. A talk show, blindness...the time travel story... That would have made sense.  (were they acknowledging the Beth/Bill relationship by this point)
    • Will be up tomorrow.   lepää rauhassa Taina Elg

      Please register in order to view this content

          TAINA ELG          3/9/1930 - 5/15/2025 THE DOCTORS         Diana Ross      "Tomorrow Is Ours Today" week of 2/3/64 THE GUIDING LIGHT      Dr. Ingrid Fischer     1980 ONE LIFE TO LIVE     Olympia ___Buchanon "Nicole Bonnard"  1980-81 THE EDGE OF NIGHT      Madame Forrester        1984 ALL MY CHILDREN           Countess Irina Korsova         Unknown Year   LOVING                           Mrs. Mulryan           1993 and HERE'S HOLLYWOOD      Self   1961 MISTER BROADWAY    Self    1964 YOKYOPELIT     Self    1966 CA' C'EST L'AMOUR   On Camera host    2003 movies SUOMISEN PERHE     Lapsi Ollin Kutsuilla    1941 NAIMISIIN  PÄIVÄKSI    Tanssija Kabareessa    1946 THE PRODIGAL      Elissa         1955 DIANE       Alys         1956 GABY     Elsa     1956 LES GIRLS   Angele Dueros    1977 IMITATION GENERAL     Simone    1958 THE 39 STEPS       Fisher    1959 WATUSI    Erica Neuler      1959 THE BACCHANTES     Dirce     1961 SUOMALAISIA MAAILMAN   TURUILLA -- TAINA ELG     Self     1963 JUHLAT LINNASSA    Isabelle Oopperan Pikku Tanssijatar   1966   (Made for T. V.) HERCULES IN NEW YORK     Nemesis     1970 THE GREAT WALLENDAS    Helen Wallenda    1978   (Made for T. V.) LIEBESTRAUM       Old Mother Ralston    1991 DON'T DRINK THE WATER    Anna Gruber      1992   (Made for T. V.) THE MIRROR HAS TWO FACES    Female Professor    1994 TRUE LOVE      Self     2003 STARRING -- TAINA ELG   2003      (Made for T. V.) KUMMELIN JACKPOT     Mrs. Skogstedt    2006 BROADWAY LOOK TO THE LILIES        3/29/1970 - 4/19/1970      Sister Albertine UNCLE VANYA     6/4/1973 - 7/28/1973     Standby --   Yelena Andreyevna  WHERE'S CHARLEY?      12/20/1974 - 2/23/1975   Donna Lucia D'Alvadorez  ****  TONY AWARD NOMINEE -- BEST FEATURED ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL THE UTTER GLORY OF MORRISSEY HALL       5/13/1979     Mrs. Delmonde STRIDER      11/14/1979 - 5/18/1980    Replacement --  Viazapurikha; Methieu; Marie   2/5/1980 - ???? NINE      5/9/1982 - 2/4/1984   Guido's Mother    CABARET    3/19/1998 -1/4/2004     Standby -- Fraulein Schneider TOURING IRMA LA DOUCE     1/4/1962 - 8/25/1962      Irma La Douce I MARRIED AN ANGEL    1964      Angel      GIGI      9/9/1964 - 6/22/1965   Inez Alvarez THERE'S A GIRL IN MY SOUP - NATIONAL TOUR    1969     Shubert Theatre   Cincinnati, OH TWO BY TWO   9/15/1972 -3/11/1973      Esther A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC  --  NATIONAL PREMIERE  1973 - 74    Desiree Armfeldt    Australian National Tour ZORBA     1976     Madame Hortense 13 RUE DE L'AMOUR        1978    Léontine TITANIC    1/5/1999  - 9/10/2000      Ida Straus; 3rd Class Passenger THEATER PAUL AND CONSTANTINE     1957         La Jolla Playhouse REDHEAD       1960     Essie       Dallas State Fair THE TENDER TRAP   1963     Poppy Matson   Paper Mill Playhouse CAN CAN        1964   Claudine      Kenley Players   Columbus, Ohio SILK STOCKINGS       1964     Notchka           Melodyland, CA WEST SIDE STORY       1966      Maria   Finnish National Opera   Helsinki THE SOUND OF MUSIC     1966 - 71     3 Productions UNCLE VANYA     1974      Standby for Julie Christie   Circle in the Square Uptown SOMETHING'S AFOOT     1986     Miss Tweed    Liberty Hall   Lowell, MA CABARET     1996      FrauleinSchneider    Walnut Street Theatre Main Stage Philadelphia REQUIEM FOR WILLIAM     2003    Connelly Theater, NYC          MEMORY OF SUMMER    Alice O PIONEERS! I HATE HAMLET Family Ties Parents --     Helena Doroumova (an immigrant pianist) and Ake Elg  (Ake Ludwig) also a pianist Marriages      Carl Bjorkenheim   1953 - 58    Divorced   1 Child -- Raoul Bjorkenheim      Rocco Caporale    1982 - 6/30/2008      His Death         LAURA PILLMAN   THE BOLD AND THE BEAUTIFUL      Cassandra    4/24/2025   NURSES' BALL DANCER                            RODRIGO VARANDAS      GENERAL HOSPITAL     Nurse Jack       5/21 - 23/2025 movies VIVENDO COM ZIKA        2016 LET'S DUB: VOXX STUDIOS COMMERCIAL     Audience    2016 BIO FILTER   Mr. Ramirez    2020 PSYCHE     Entity      2025 RED SOULS FEELING GOOD A MINUTE TO LOVE Upcoming SEESAW     Max      TBA    In Production THEATER ORIGINAL -- THE MUSICAL: THE LIFE STORY OF JANIVA MAGNESS    Candlelight Pavilion LEGALLY BLONDE     Candlelight Pavilion THOROUGHLY MODERN MILLIE          Candlelight Pavilion SINGIN IN THE RAIN     2015      Ensemble    WEST SIDE STORY       2015     Pepe     Candlelight Pavilion  EMPIRE   (World Premiere)   Jesse; Ensemble CHILDREN OF EDEN    2016   Storyteller; Snake    Cabrillo Music Theatre WOMEN ON THE VERGE OF A NERVOUS BREAKDOWN       2017        Carlos IRVING BERLIN'S WHITE CHRISTMAS   2017      Ensemble    Long Beach IN THE HEIGHTS        2017      Swing; Ensemble    Musical Theatre West CABARET    Herman -- Kit Kat Boy     2018      KINKY BOOTS     2020    Announcer; Angel       Cerritos, CA MAMMA MIA       2021   Pepper; Ensemble    Understudy -- Bill     SHREK    Dragon Puppeteer; Big Bad Wolf   YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN   2022     Ensemble           1776           Leather Apron;  Painter A FEW GOOD MEN    William T. Santiago  ROMEO AND JULIET     Romeo TOURING PETER PAN      Cecco SINGIN' IN THE RAIN     2014 https://stagescenela.com/2016/03/juan-caballer-rodrigo-varandas/       WANTED TO LOCK TRACY UP                                      JEFFERY THOMAS JOHNSON       Also Credited as Jeff Johnson   PARTY OF FIVE 2.0    Officer __ Bryce   2020 GENERAL HOSPITAL    Sheriff __ Lewis   April 2025 and NEWTON'S CRADLE     Officer Goodloe   2020 MY SECRET AGENT HUSBAND    Maverick Thompson     2024 HER POSSESSIVE GUARD       Gage      2024 movies THE TWO JAKES      Golfer    1990 QUEENS LOGIC      Club Patron     1991 DRACULA      Van Helsing's Student     1992 TEXAS PAYBACK     Board Member    1995 CALL GIRL    Man in Black   1995 CITIZEN RUTH   Harlan's Biker Friend     1996 LOVE ME TWICE     Phillip   1996 AMERICAN TIGERS     Krause    1996 THE BRAVE       Clerk    1997 CONTACT     Mechanical     1997 THE POSTMAN      Rope Bridge Soldier   1997 GETTING THERE     Waiter in Ski Lodge    2002 OPERATION TERROR     Federal Agent Thomas   2012 LIFE TRACKER   Brigadier General Anthony Morris    2013 CARDINAL MATTER      Jeremy Ryan    2016 THE DEVIL HAS A NAME      Police Captain     2019 AQUARIUM OF THE DEAD     Smith    2021 SUPER VOLCANO    Guillerman     2022   (Made for T. V.) 20.0  MEGAQUAKE     Guillerman   2022   (Made for T. V.) ICE STORM      Guillerman    2023    (Made for T. V.) BIRD OF PARADISE     Dominic Dunaway     2023 THE LAUNDRESS    Guy Sullivan    2024 DEAD WRONG     Mason    2024 24 HOURS TO D-DAY      Major Jones     2024 THE SIX TRIPLE EIGHT    Colonel Davenport    2024 Upcoming FIRE ANT     Nolan Karr   TBA   Post Production  INCIDENT AT COTTER CREEK     Mason     TBA    In Production JOY RIDGE    David Whipliton     TBA   In Production ALL PAID FOR     Jack    TBA     Pre Production                            ASHLEY CAPLE   GENERAL HOSPITAL   Hot Girl at Pool    6/14/2023                            Charlie's Pub Waitress     1/28/2025 and TREASURE KING      Daisy Duke    2014 HEROES WITH ISSUES    Cortara     2016; 2018 movies DESTRUCTION: LAS VEGAS   Spring Break Female    2013 ENTOURAGE      Sloan's Friend     2015 THE GUEST HOUSE   Kristy   2016 DOES SIZE MATTER     Girl in the Park  # 1     2016 HOOKED ON A HEIFER    Hot Babe # 1  Brutus' Girlfriend   2017 TALES OF FRANKENSTEIN    Adelina   2018 ASS CLOWNS: CONSTIPATED   Pool Girl   2021 OFF THE RECORD      KLM Casting Girl    2024 Upcoming NOIR      Mistress    TBA    Post Production     RED CARPET DUDE                                   GEORGE PENNACCHIO   GENERAL HOSPITAL    George Pennacchio, Red Carpet  Nurses' Ball 206; 2018; 2019; 2023; May 2025 movies SPLENDOR     Newscaster     1994 FOUR FINGERS OF THE DRAGON    Self      2003 THE LEGACY     Self    2010 SILENT LIFE: THE STORY OF THE LADY IN BLACK   T. V. Reporter   2023 Appeared in the sitcom Less than Perfect in 2003. Serves on the Board of the charity group, The Thalias. Has been the Entertainment Reporter since 1996 at ABC-7 in Los Angeles. He also hosts Oscar Specials.  
    • I can see why the Sam/Amanda story went downhill so fast. Thomas Gibson was a terrible replacement. I don't remember the circumstances of RKK quitting  (if his contract was over or if the departure was more acrimonious), but Gibson just sucks the energy out of every scene. He has no chemistry with anyone.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy