On 9/10/2021 at 2:48 PM, Liberty City said:

If anything, Christian should've been the ADA and have Carisi demoted back to SVU.

Carisi never should have changed from a detective to SVU in the first place. Even when he was a detective, I hated every time it was mentioned he was studying for the bar - HATED IT.

On 9/5/2021 at 9:55 AM, Cat said:

It is fantastic. I am totally addicted, thanks to its long-story format which allows you to invest in the characters.

Obvs they have Benson showing up with her big sad eyes every episode but its usually FF-able.

High praise. Finally getting around to seeing the reunion episode and sounds like I might start the pilot then. 

 

Happy it is getting a second season. 

Excited to come home after work tonight and re-visit SVU and OC!

The three-hour Law & Order franchise premiere was amazing. They're setting up some amazing things on both Organized Crime and Special Victims Unit. However... what is up with the re-designed squad room on SVU?

1 hour ago, Liberty City said:

However... what is up with the re-designed squad room on SVU?

Yeah...I didn't like it either.

IDK how everyone else feels but I dont like how much more modern SVU is getting into the detective's personal lives. SVU from the start was more personal than OG Law & Order but the stories seem to increasingly  involve the detectives rather than them just investigating the case. For example Olivia being kidnapped or taken hostage etc..

I was really hoping for Stabler to come back to SVU but his new show is decent, and the frequent crossovers somewhat fill the void. Getting them romantically involved however may kill whatever tension between them and they should probably wait till the end of the show...then again it's been 22 years so we've been teased enough.

Edited September 27, 20214 yr by ironlion

1 hour ago, amybrickwallace said:

Yeah...I didn't like it either.

It's almost like Dick Wolf said: "Hey, Organized Crime's squad room is awesome. Let's re-create it for SVU and hope no one notices." I miss the warmth and space of the previous one.

The issue I've had with SVU for several years is how CHEAP the sets look. For all the money this show has made NBC/Wolf, it should look better.

Edited September 27, 20214 yr by amybrickwallace

 

 

3 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

 

 

I don't necessarily think this is a good idea. That ship has sailed.

4 minutes ago, amybrickwallace said:

I don't necessarily think this is a good idea. That ship has sailed.

Same. This'll either succeed or fail. I feel like Organized Crime has genuinely succeeded because it is revolved around Christopher Meloni's Elliott Stabler. I don't know if the flagship can do the same.

As I said in the thread about the revival, I don't know how I feel. While the original should have outlasted SVU and should not have been axed for the failure that was Law & Order: Los Angeles, it has been over a decade since this last aired.

And many of the existing cast members are now on other shows. And, frankly, the current writing on Dick Wolf shows does not exactly inspire confidence in me that the revival will not end up schitting on the original. And some, let's be honest, are too old now. (I adore Sam Waterston, but the man is over 80 now.) That means new blood, and casting is very hit or miss.

Sometimes, things are best left alone. (But I will watch the first episode to gauge an opinion should it truly come to pass.)

Edited September 28, 20214 yr by Wendy

14 minutes ago, Wendy said:

As I said in the thread about the revival, I don't know how I feel. While the original should have outlasted SVU and should not have been axed for the failure that was Law & Order: Los Angeles, it has been over a decade since this last aired.

And many of the existing cast members are now on other shows. And, frankly, the current writing on Dick Wolf shows does not exactly inspire confidence in me that the revival will not end up schitting on the original. And some, let's be honest, are too old now. (I adore Sam Waterston, but the man is over 80 now.) That means new blood, and casting is very hit or miss.

Sometimes, things are best left alone. (But I will watch the first episode to gauge an opinion should it truly come to pass.)

You hit the nail right on the head.

I've been hoping for this to happen almost as long as I've been hoping for AMC/OLTL to come back. This show was canceled abruptly due to mismanagement and the grand ego of Jeff Zucker - the guy who said "DAYS" wouldn't be on the air beyond 2009. That guy. How he ever went on to other higher paying and demanding positions when all he ever did was fail upward is beyond me.

2 minutes ago, Errol said:

I've been hoping for this to happen almost as long as I've been hoping for AMC/OLTL to come back. This show was canceled abruptly due to mismanagement and the grand ego of Jeff Zucker - the guy who said "DAYS" wouldn't be on the air beyond 2009. That guy. How he ever went on to other higher paying and demanding positions when all he ever did was fail upward is beyond me.

That's the same guy behind the Tonight Show Jay/Conan kafuffle as well. I don't know about this. The beauty of L&O the mothership was that the episodes were about the CASE, not the characters' personal lives and I don't trust Wolf/NBC not to screw that up. Besides, it's been over a decade. I say just leave it alone, but who knows.