Melissa Archer!

No, I don't like her.

The only actress that comes to mind is Brianna Brown.

She's 34, quite capable of playing a psycho babe and Jill Farren Phelps hired her once before so ...

Edited May 7, 201411 yr by soapsnstuds

CR only turned down Days cause she had 3 prime time recurring gigs at the of filming began for eve (Late January). Maybe now she has time?

Edited May 7, 201411 yr by John

Melissa Archer as grandmother? No.

As PigPen Grazadei's mother? Yeah ok!

Jensen Buchanan?

I think whoever they choose it be welcomed or universally hated

ABSOLUTELY NOT! Weak overrated actress!

The new chick will not be hated. Many are welcoming Phyllis' return.

Melissa Archer as grandmother? No.

LOL... that's why it's ridiculous that they're looking for a 35 year old for Phyllis.

Robin Christopher, Jamie Luner & Susan Haskell have been the best suggestions thus far.

Wow. If they do settle for Kelly Sullivan that will be so sad. Why is Y&R casting these ABC actors who don't fit the show? It doesn't look for feel like Y&R, despite the writing improving. Hell, even the writing doesn't feel like Y&R.

Robin Christopher, Jamie Luner & Susan Haskell have been the best suggestions thus far.

LAWD! Phyllis is a lot of things, but a monotone drone she aint!

I want Robin Christopher or my beloved Megan Ward.

Lisa Peluso.

considering that GH took MS, and her past w/ B&B... I think Y&R is gonna gun for Sarah Brown.

but, ever since she announced her departure and died her hair a redish brown... I've been suspicious of what's up w/ Alison Sweeney, and I THINK she might have been given a huge offer by Y&R...

honestly, they need a BIG name and someone with proven CHOPS if they want this to happen.

considering that GH took MS, and her past w/ B&B... I think Y&R is gonna gun for Sarah Brown.

but, ever since she announced her departure and died her hair a redish brown... I've been suspicious of what's up w/ Alison Sweeney, and I THINK she might have been given a huge offer by Y&R...

honestly, they need a BIG name and someone with proven CHOPS if they want this to happen.

On AS' best 6 days, she would never be Phyllis. Never!

Sarah should not be Phyllis either.

susan haskell or jaimie lunar

On AS' best 6 days, she would never be Phyllis. Never!

Sarah should not be Phyllis either.

sure, sis...

KMH was the first interesting one I thought of because she was still top on mind during the "recast" Karen on B&B - however, it looks like JJ isn't going to give up that role entirely. KMH has certain limitations, but she has played the full spectrum of Phyllis-type of history, so this would be good territory for her. Emily was bad, very bad, sexy, maternal, warm, funny, impulsive, deeply flawed, but KHM gave her a sense of humanity - plus she played ball in the business world quite well. The red hair would be a problem - KMH is so lovely as a blonde.