I'm just baffled why McPherson was so gosh dang awful on DOOL given the praise nuAMC seems to be getting. Maybe she has a better co-HW to balance her out?

Her Days got praise early on as well, but then time went on and her flaws became apparent. Its still way too soon to judge her and say she's a hit on AMC. I think we will have to wait at least a month to see if she has much direction and if her plots aren't as bare and boring as they were on Days

You have a point. The reason I stated what I did though is because I *believe* the staff agreed to keep each daily thread open 10-14 days after each episode already aired to keep them inline with how Hulu.com operates. So if someone hasn't watched after day one, they have no excuse for being spoiled in here.

I'd just say try to be careful with some major spoilerish stuff at least for the first 8 hours after the show is up. Maybe only up until the 1:00 PM previous ABC air schedule? We'll see how it goes, I guess.

I think 1 pm should be the cut off for spoilerish content in the discussion threads....

I'm just baffled why McPherson was so gosh dang awful on DOOL

Because DOOL as an organism is biologically incapable of accepting good writing into itself.

There is no way in hell I am using spoiler tags all goddamn day. I say cut them off at either 1 or 2 PM EST - the original opening and ending of the show.

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by Vee

There is no way in hell I am using spoiler tags all goddamn day. I say cut them off at either 1 or 2 PM EST - the original opening and ending of the show.

This makes the most sense to me.

One question: does this mean the "In Production" threads are going to be locked? I feel like from here on out stuff like casting and press should probably go into the spoiler forum, when appropriate, like every other show. JMHO.

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by marceline

I think you should do away with spoiler tags altogether. If you don't want to know what's going on, then don't read the thread. If you want to participate in the discussion, then go watch the episode.

I think you should do away with spoiler tags altogether. If you don't want to know what's going on, then don't read the thread. If you want to participate in the discussion, then go watch the episode.

AGREED!

with it just being 30 minutes and less characters, that might make it pretty light on content. I might do a special Monday Hos just for the debut but go back to doing Friday Hos during the recap show and make it more for Hos of the Week

That sounds awesome

Awesome work, Cheap!

One question: does this mean the "In Production" threads are going to be locked? I feel like from here on out stuff like casting and press should probably go into the spoiler forum, when appropriate, like every other show. JMHO.

Shoot I thought that weeks ago...lol

I think you should do away with spoiler tags altogether. If you don't want to know what's going on, then don't read the thread. If you want to participate in the discussion, then go watch the episode.

This.

I think you should do away with spoiler tags altogether. If you don't want to know what's going on, then don't read the thread. If you want to participate in the discussion, then go watch the episode.

Exactly.

I'm just baffled why McPherson was so gosh dang awful on DOOL given the praise nuAMC seems to be getting. Maybe she has a better co-HW to balance her out?

I wasn't watching DAYS yet at the time, but the criticism of McPherson I've seen is that she had bad pacing but good ideas as a general concept. So Errol's comment that more happens on OLTL in the first episode but AMC will be great once it gets going is really not contradicting that so far.

As for whether DAYS can accept good writing into itself, the present team, especially the scriptwriters, is doing great there.

Edited April 28, 201312 yr by jfung79

I think you should do away with spoiler tags altogether. If you don't want to know what's going on, then don't read the thread. If you want to participate in the discussion, then go watch the episode.

THIS!!!

I do think this venture is much more up Marlene McPherson's alley. If you watch her interview with Errol from when she and DRT were starting at Days you can tell she really wanted to modernize the storytelling ("Let's stop sitting around talking about [how we're going to update these shows] and let's actually do it!"). I don't doubt that she hit a brick wall in NBC/Sony/Corday/whoever in that regard.

Having said that, I'm still concerned her material will be dullsville once the excitement of the show being back wears off. I'm also worried that the Uri/Vlad stuff will end up being as cartoon-y and cringe-worthy as when the DOOL teens were being held captive by the illegal online gambling guys (including Carlos the Fusion handyman!), or that the mystery of Celia's locket will end up being as "make-it-up-as-we-go" as the whole Alice Horton secret bank accounts mess.

It's unfortunate the way things worked out because had PP not been looking into the fi-core writers earlier on they probably would never have come across McPherson.

I wasn't watching DAYS yet at the time, but the criticism of McPherson I've seen is that she had bad pacing but good ideas as a general concept. So Errol's comment that more happens on OLTL in the first episode but AMC will be great once it gets going is really not contradicting that so far.

As for whether DAYS can accept good writing into itself, the present team, especially the scriptwriters, is doing great there.

What I meant was that AMC lost a lot of its identity in its latter years. McPherson and Snyder have to get people re-invested in AMC from the start. They re-introduce the characters in a way that for new viewers they don't feel like they are being catered to and for old viewers don't feel like they are being given a lesson. It's hard to explain. Whereas with OLTL, they just go BAM! I'd say both soaps are very family oriented, but AMC is more laid back to a point initially while OLTL is all action from the start. Again, hard to explain. Ya'll will be the judge tomorrow.

Im going in with an open mind. I hope the writers bring everything together nicely.

As for whether DAYS can accept good writing into itself, the present team, especially the scriptwriters, is doing great there.

no