Janet? Hell no!

I preferred and love Kate Collins, but I would have preferred the baby switch happened with Janet and Amanda (characters with history to the show, and Janet as the perfect manipulator and fallguy) than those damn Careys taking over the show.

Deidre hall as Dr Sandy Horton

Richard Guthrie as Steve Olsen

In 76 it would have been possible for Sandy to have now been a practising doctor.With a few tweaks Marlena could have been Sandy and the Horton family would have been bolstered to this day.

Days aged Julie's son David way too quickly and pushed Susan Seaforth into being a grandmother when she was still in her 30's.

David's stories could have been given to Julie's brother Steve(another under used character) and Julie could have a concerned older sister rather than mother.

^While that would have worked, Dee as Sandy, I have always admired how Marlena was able ti became a central character, along with her kids, while not she wasnt a member of a major family or even a family. She effortlessly fit into the show and worked across the canvas. I wish we had more characters like that. Its partially the reason I hated DAYS making Melanie maggies granddaughter, when they already had that bond and that twist wasnt needed and failed basically.

On AMC, I feel that Beth Ehlers should have been cast as Liza or perhaps a new Hayley.

Hayley yes but definetly not Liza. She doesnt have the stature I associate with the character

Edited February 1, 201312 yr by Cheap21

^While that would have worked, Dee as Sandy, I have always admired how Marlena was able ti became a central character, along with her kids, while not she wasnt a member of a major family or even a family. She effortlessly fit into the show and worked across the canvas. I wish we had more characters like that. Its partially the reason I hated DAYS making Melanie maggies granddaughter, when they already had that bond and that twist wasnt needed and failed basically.

I thought the same thing. I'm surprised we never met her parents throughout the years. Surely *they* could've shed some light on whether she was once married to Dr. Alex North or not (that terrible re-write they did in 2005)

McKenzie Satterthwaite on ATWT should have been a Molly recast instead of a Nikki Munson recast. Whatever happened to her anyways?

Cassius Willis as Malcolm on Y&R and Tatyana Ali as Lily.

Final couple of years of ATWT should've utilized its rich history instead of creating Passantate's fluke characters of the month. IMO:

Noelle Beck should've been cast as Frannie instead of a Lily recast.

Jeffery Meeks as Rick Ryan instead of Craig.

Eric William Morris should've been cast as MJ Dixon instead of Matt O'Connor.

Evan Alex Cole should've been cast as one of the Ward boys (Lowell or Gregory) instead of Emily's egg baby.

Chris Heiusler should've been Pete Wendall instead of Cole Norbeck

Wally Kurth as Caleb Snyder or Duke Kramer instead Sam Hutchins

Kin Shriner as Seth Snyder instead of Keith

Sarah Brown as Nikki Munson instead of Julia

Edited February 2, 201312 yr by brandonfluellen

I thought the same thing. I'm surprised we never met her parents throughout the years. Surely *they* could've shed some light on whether she was once married to Dr. Alex North or not (that terrible re-write they did in 2005)

Wrong. Frank Evans was played by two actors (Ford Rainer & Frank Schofield, both deceased) recurring in the role from 1977 - 1979. From the same time frame, plus a 1982 episode, Martha Evans, played by Diana Douglas, recurred as well.

Clumping Y&R and B&B in with what I said about World Turns,

Melissa Claire Egan should've been cast as Jennifer Foster. Jill would've had a niece, a Foster/Brooks would've been back on the canvas, and they could've made her into a modern day Jill instead whiny ass Chelsea. Sean Patrick Flanery should have been her brother Chuck, and with Steve Burton on the show, he could be Brooks.

Aaron D. Spears should have switched with Eddie Winslow and been Malcolm. I still think he should be cast in that role.

The boy playing Mason should've been cast as Nate.

Lawrence St. Victor needs to be Zende instead of a foster brother Marcus had.

This might annoy people but I prefer legacy characters that are practically blank slates to be brought back BEFORE creating a new character.

Nate did come back but he was a John's Hopkin's graduate and surgen I don't see where the hospital scene would fit into Y&R right now.

Nate did come back but he was a John's Hopkin's graduate and surgen I don't see where the hospital scene would fit into Y&R right now.

Yeah I remember when they brought him back and thought they should've kept him then. And I think the hospital scene can fit in if they tried. I'm tired of everyone working at Newman and Jabot anyways.

When ATWT recast Nikki and Molly at the same time, the NuNikki had a strong resemblance to Lesli Kay. It was really distracting. She finally started coming in to her own but then her 13 weeks were up.

OLTL:

Christina Chambers should have come in as Tea, not Marty

Christina Chambers shouldnt have come to OLTL period