Often when we think of a soap actor/actress, we picture them in one defining role. Can you ever see Susan Lucci as anything other than Erica, or Tony Geary as anything besides Luke? Not that many haven't tried, but most times the magic just isn't there, or they are not suited for the role. But there must be some soap stars for whom lightning struck twice. Who do you see as successful in more than one role? And who was GREAT in one role, but awful in another? (For the second category, may I nominate Susan Batten....fantastic as OLTL's Luna, awful as ATWT's Connor).

First. Sarah Brown as Carly and Claudia. Loved her as both.

Don Diamont on B&B and Y&R. Ditto for Heather Tom

Edited January 26, 201213 yr by Cheap21

The GOOD:

Susan Flannery - Laura Harton (DAYS) and Stephanie Forrester (B&B )

Denise Alexander- Susan Martin (DAYS) and Lesley Webber (GH)

Robin Christopher - Skye Chandler (AMC, OLTL, GH) and Lorna Devon (AW)

Heather Tom - Victoria (Y&R), Kelly (OLTL) and Katie (B&B )

Sarah Brown - Carly (GH), Claudia (GH)

The BAD:

Eden Reigel - Heather (Y&R)

Edited January 26, 201213 yr by SoapBoy94

I was going to start something like this but with an actor and his or her roles and which one was your favorite.....

For example.....Lisa Brown as Nola and Iva.......Jane Elliot as Carrie and Tracey Quartermaine.........

Beverlee McKinsey -- Iris on AW and Alexandra on GL.

Robin Strasser - Dorian (OLTL), Rachel (AW)

Soapboy, GREAT choice of Robin Strasser. Her Rachel defined the early bad girl, and her Dorian was quite popular.

My choice would be Cady McClain. She won Emmys as both Dixie on AMC and Rosanna on ATWT. What was great is that the characters could not have been more different.

Ellen Dolan as Margo Hughes and Maureen Bauer......I prefered her as Mo though

Thorsten Kaye-Patrick on OLTL, Ian on PC and Zach on AMC

Terry Lester as Jack Abbott and Royce Keller

Mary Kay Adams as India Van Haulken...sp??? and Neal Alcott....She was very popular in both roles.

Thorsten Kaye-Patrick on OLTL, Ian on PC and Zach on AMC

One of the worst actors IMO...lol....wasnt too into his acting at all.

Not entirely sure about actors who were only in a role for a few years or who had mixed reviews (as Lester and Christopher seemed to on ATWT and AW).

It's also why I'm not sure about Maeve Kinkead (not sure how popular she was on AW).

I guess you should also add Andrea Evans, even if many would say her B&B role is similar to Tina on OLTL, or that her Y&R run was just Tina.

Michael Zaslow - David Renaldi and Roger Thorpe

Edited January 26, 201213 yr by CarlD2

i forgot about Andrea Evans...loved her as Patty and Tina. I just cant stand her as Tawny.

She was on Passions too, although again people might say that was Tina.

Justin Deas - his ATWT/SB/GL/RH roles were all very different.

Hillary B. Smith - Margo Hughes (ATWT), Nora Hanen (OLTL).

Peter Bergman - Cliff Warner (AMC), Jack Abbott (Y&R)

Eileen Davidson - Ashley Abbott (Y&R), Kristen DiMera (DOOL)