I know they were mixed reactions to Noelle Beck as Lily on ATWT?? What did you think of her

I liked her. Martha Byrne WAS Lily and I wish she could've finished up the show's last 3 years but Noelle Beck added a new edge to the character that wasn't there with Byrne. And Beck offering to step aside at the end was totally a classy move.

I know they were mixed reactions to Noelle Beck as Lily on ATWT?? What did you think of her

I thought Noelle Beck was a great addition to the ATWT cast...just not as Lily.

Days recast both Will & Gabi cause the actors Dylan Patton & Gabriella Rodriguez were too young

Days recast both Will & Gabi cause the actors Dylan Patton & Gabriella Rodriguez were too young

They were the same age as LA on GH. I found all three to be too young looking and not good enough in the acting department to do anything worthwhile on their soaps

I didn't care that much for Drew Garrett either...I think the main problem with Michael is the writing. I can see Duell more as AJ's son (Sean Kanan anyway), I just have no interest in the sad sack stuff, or any mob stuff.

I didn't care that much for Drew Garrett either...I think the main problem with Michael is the writing. I can see Duell more as AJ's son (Sean Kanan anyway), I just have no interest in the sad sack stuff, or any mob stuff.

Ugh Duell looks nothing like SK. I thought DG looked more like SK(especially in the pic I saw of them together) though I didn't like the writing for his Michael either.

Eileen Davidson as Kelly Capwell is the poster child of this thread. I feel like she should have been part of "One of these things are not like the other!" when put in with Robin Wright and Carrington Garland.

(Kimberly McArthur doesn't count as she was just a bland void.)

ron raines. great actor wrong role!!!!

besides liz keifer, any role phelps recasted on GL!!

John Novak as Kieth Timmons on Santa Barbara. Justin Deas had made that into a huge role, but Novak was just all wrong for the part.

MA as Tom Hardy on GH was another bad one.

I liked MA as Tom. I wish he'd return now that he's been fired from Days and KW is back as Felicia

I agree, Cheap

Didn't lik him as Tom or Tom and Feclicia and RC would probably bring him on the show as whoever he played on OLTL.

Ugh I could not the stand the last actress who played her ugh

I didn't like Justis either as Sarah. The only thing she had going for her was that she kinda looked like AE and JL mixed together (her onscreen parents) That was about it.

I agree, Cheap

Im glad someone else liked them!

They could do a triangle here

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-FMJROc8Sjk

Edited June 25, 201213 yr by Cheap21