As you know, I cannot disagree with anything you have written. Ed had been a surly, abusive douche throughout Gentry's tenure, and RG played the role very well.
But emotionally, in my heart, I wanted Ed to grow, mature and soften; to become a more viable tentpole character. I was primed and ready for him to stop being a jackass, and MH's affable, gregarious (but still hot-headed and passionate below the surface) take on him allowed me to have the transformed Ed I wanted to see. Was the character transformation completely believable? Do people ever truly change that much? Maybe not, but Bert grew up a lot. So did Meta. So I allowed myself to embrace the older-and-wiser, gentler Ed, particularly after Papa died. Don Stewart's Mike did not exude the warmth that Papa had, but Hulswit's Ed did, and I wanted that warmth to continue on display within the Bauer clan.
Agree. He was a wimpy douche; listless, morose, and generally colorless.
RVV was appealing as Chuck Tyler on AMC, but just...all wrong on TGL. UGH. Like Wesley Ann Pfenning as Alice Matthews Frame on AW. What were TPTB even thinking?
By
vetsoapfan ·
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.