Jump to content
Email System Update

American Idol: Discussion Thread

R!ck

By R!ck
in FOX | Tubi

Recommended Posts

  • Members
David_Vickers Proficient

David_Vickers

Posted
  • Members
Posted

Best guys IMHO, were Blake Lewis, Chris Richardson, Jared Cotter, Brandon Rogers (improved), AJ Tabaldo & Chris Sligh, with Phil Stacy next (much improved).

I wish would go home and vote the worst must have them as their picks ===== Sundance FatHead and Sanjaya "I'm in Love with Michael Jackson" Malakar.

Best girls, of course, were Melinda Doolitle, Sabrina Sloan, Stephanie Edwards, LaKisha Jones, Jordin Sparks & Gina Glocksen. Haley Scarnato was surprisingly good IMHO, and Randy & Simon were way too hard on her this week and Paula was absolutely right.

Worst and should go home Alaina who didn't even have the tune of "Not Ready to Make Nice" and pretty Antonella, who should become a model and forget singing since she can't carry a tune and seems to be a beatch. Leslie could end up going though due to her weirdness.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members
DaysFanJean Newbie

DaysFanJean

Posted
  • Members
Posted

I'm inclined to agree unless Sundance has another relapse of lack of confidence. Right now, I'm even ready to declare Melinda the winner due to her poise and composure. She is very professional, has the voice and I just love her. She comes across as a very sensitive and caring person.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
SteveFrame Newbie

SteveFrame

Posted
  • Members
Posted

If Antonella makes it to the top 6 over some of these other girls I will be very mad. Soem of these girls are giving some magnificent performances and trying. Antonella has been bad for both of them. This will definitely be a case where America gets it wrong if they don't send her out.

And if Sundance makes it to the final 4 that is another bad choice. I have not liked him at all - even in his tryout.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
PhoenixRising05 Newbie

PhoenixRising05

Posted
  • Members
Posted

Yeah. I liked her too King but she butchered one of favorite songs of all time last week and she just takes on the wrong songs. She takes on these big songs and tries to avoid the high notes by pulling most of them out of the song and it dilutes the song, leaving you with a boring song and a forgettable performance.

The fact that Sanjaya, Antonella, and Sundance (who wasn't bad this week but still) are getting more votes then many of the more talented and hard working singers makes me fear for what may happen this season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
DaysFanJean Newbie

DaysFanJean

Posted
  • Members
Posted

Actually I don't think Antonella is all that bad. She was scared and nervous last week and this week, I thought she was being careful not to in any way be compared with Celine. She did it HER WAY and I rather enjoyed it. She still showed some nerves, but I think she is as good as some of the other girls who have a shot at number 6. Of course, if she does get number 6, she probably will be the first girl to go (as does any of the others who might get number 6).

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
R!ck Newbie

R!ck

Posted
  • Author
  • Members
Posted

Voting has now concluded in all time zones. Here are DialIdols final results. Let's see how right they are this week?

100% Safe

Melinda Doolittle - 14.4%

Lakisha Jones - 12.48%

Possible B3

Antonella Barba - 10.92%

Jordin Sparks - 7.73%

Alaina Alexander - 7.60%

Sabrina Sloan - 6.69%

Haley Scarnato - 5.89%

Leslie Hunt - 5.61%

Stephanie Edwards - 5.60%

Gina Glocksen - 4.97%

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
DaysFanJean Newbie

DaysFanJean

Posted
  • Members
Posted

I find it hard to see Gina and Stephanie the bottom two. Surely they won't be the ones to go this time. I expect Leslie and Haley but if they don't go this time, surely they will next week.

Rick, you are cool....yes she does resemble Lily Tomlin only a bit stouter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Members
Cheap21 Veteran

Cheap21

Posted
  • Members
Posted

ITA. Lakisha, Stephanie and Melinda are leagues above the other girls. They just dont compare.

Im not feeling the Gina love. I think she is overated and didnt see anything great about her performance. I hope she gets the boot

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


  • Recent Posts

    • GymnastGuy
      One Life to Live Tribute Thread

      By GymnastGuy · Posted

      Yes, they did.  I still have them.  I think there were three.  AMC and GH as well.
    • Manny
      EastEnders: Discussion Thread

      By Manny · Posted

      Ah okay, thats what I thought. I was hoping I missed the announcement somewhere. Thanks for the clarification.
    • AbcNbc247
      DAYS: June 2025 Discussion Thread

      By AbcNbc247 · Posted

      A new day in Salem… and a new day for Days.  I like the way everybody found out and absorbed the news about John’s death, and how they all eventually found their way to Marlena’s to offer their condolences. I’m not particularly sure why they waited until the next day to tell everybody but I don’t really mind it.  We finally got Roman’s perspective! His scenes with Kayla were one of the best parts of today. I’m glad that Roman is thankful for everything that John did for his kids. I agree with posters who said that he should’ve had a scene like this with John, but I’m happy we got this at least.  Julie was used very well today too. She’s definitely the best person for Marlena to have scenes with at the moment. Hopefully, Julie continues to be there for her. And yes, I totally agree with Marlena and Belle sending EJ away when he came to the apartment. I’m curious to see what’s going to happen to his and Belle’s relationship in the aftermath of all this. And, while I enjoyed most of Brady and Kristen’s scenes, I still think the ship has sailed for them. Hopefully, the aftermath of John’s death causes Brady to finally end this thing with her once and for all.  And, I see a lot of people were wearing some kind of shade of purple today. 
    • Soapsuds
      DAYS: June 2025 Discussion Thread

      By Soapsuds · Posted

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Maxim
      The Slut From The Valley Appreciation Thread

      By Maxim · Posted

      Please register in order to view this content

       

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Maxim
      B&B: Old/Classic Discussion & Articles

      By Maxim · Posted

      Please register in order to view this content

      Please register in order to view this content

         
    • Wendy
      DAYS: Current&Former actors live video tribute for Drake Hogestyn

      By Wendy · Posted

      Wow, I love that current and former actors are participating in this. I barely recognize Staci Greason! She looks fine, just very different. But I will be happy to hear anecdotes from her. I shipped RoJohn and Isabella hard back in the day, and I sobbed buckets in my dorm room at college when Izzy B passed. Honestly, I'm interested in everyone's stories. Drake seemed like he was well loved among the cast.
    • Alan
      BTG: June 2025 Discussion Thread

      By Alan · Posted

      When she first appeared, I was sure she was setting Tyrell up for a prank. She was too much of a manic pixie dream girl- I wasn't surprised Tyrell also became suspicious. Now I'm not so sure. If Jessica genuinely likes Tyrell, it seems like a missed opportunity to not have started her out as a bully, then we see her gradually catch feelings for Tyrell.  The McBrides are definitely the "C" family of BTG. They always get last priority. There have been a few times where the Doug/Vanessa/Joey characters reference off screen conversations which seem too important to not show us. Like when Doug thanked Joey for giving him extra time to pay off the loan. When did that happen? Or when we abruptly moved from Vanessa/Joey at Uptown to Vanessa/Doug in the hotel room. The McBrides don't even have their own set - even though Vanessa is a realtor. It's a shame because I am a fan of the characters and actors. 

      Please register in order to view this content

      I am also adjusting to KR as Ted but I feel that AM and MJ had way more chemistry as father and daughter than AM and KR. We saw Eva dream of having a real relationship with MJ's version of Ted for months so it's a bit of a bummer not to have that payoff with the original actor except for those scenes in MJ's last episode.  Something I noticed about Eva today is how she takes genuine delight in being a schemer. As badly as she wants to be a Richardson, she still has so much of her mom in her. It was jarring seeing her earnestly promise to steer clear of Leslie in her scene with Ted, then immediately switch attitudes when her mom showed up.  I'm very surprised with how quickly the accident story has been moving along. I was sure that it would be months if not years before people figured out it was Leslie on the motorcycle, not to mention responsible for the potassium overdose. I'm looking forward to seeing how MVJ and Guza avoid writing Leslie into a corner.  Finally, I have been loving the Articulettes story. Bonita Brisker was just the right amount of OTT - remember Sharon is supposed to be even more angry than Tracy is. If Sharon didn't come in swinging, people would say she fell flat. The way Sharon and Tracy describe the breakup is so Supremes-meet-Original Recipe Destiny's Child. I get the sense that MVJ is re-writing the Return to Love Tour as a roman a clef, and I love it. I'm looking forward to finding out what the secret they share is. If Dante Green is as shady as Berry Gordy was, it's something dark. If/when they go through with the reunion, I expect Dante to show up and claim to own the Articulettes trademark in a Lou Pearlman-esque twist. 
    • Jdee43
      GH: June 2025 Discussion Thread

      By Jdee43 · Posted

      Other than hanging out with Liz, all of Lucky's stories have been stalled out or dropped; the relationship with his son; his wanderlust. He hasn't been involved in any of the action/adventure or con artist stuff. I don't think he's even had a scene with Sidwell since the latter came to town. He's a real after thought. I doubt he's long for the show.
    • janea4old
      Y&R: June 2025 Discussion Thread

      By janea4old · Posted

      invitations received during May 30 US (May 29 CDN) episode

      Please register in order to view this content

        You are cordially invited to join ARISTOTLE  DUMAS for an extended stay at his summer home in NICE, FRANCE Departure June 13, 2025 Travel details to follow
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

  I accept