Literally the only soap opera that feels like a soap opera.

GH has had an excellent sweeps so far. As someone who hasn't watched consistently in a decade I'm surprisingly heavily invested. When Ryan showed up at Wyndemere last Thursday I was legitimately shocked, even though it was telegraphed in the episode I was like "oh shît".

Although the hook thing has been dragged out probably a bit too long and isn't the most compelling of mysteries (it's got to be Laura's deputy mayor, right? For all the killings that haven't been Heather anyway, the one in this promo IS Heather though), at least it's a story! It's something happening.

It's not Days where the only story they can seem to tell is people fake dying or B&B where Sheila runs around the entire cast like she's Bugs Bunny and they're Elmer Fudd or Y&R where you get to watch beige people watch beige paint dry in a beige house on a beige street in Beigetown, U.S.A.

Edited February 20, 20232 yr by Darn

So Heather really was a decoy? There really is a Hook?

 

Now back to who it could be then...?

4 hours ago, Darn said:

When Ryan showed up at Wyndemere last Thursday I legitimately shocked, even though it was telegraphed in the episode I was like "oh shît".

THIS.

 

Or see what a difference being invested in story makes when they turn the focus to people we actually care about. Mac, Felicia, etc. 

7 minutes ago, Taoboi said:

4 hours ago, Darn said:

When Ryan showed up at Wyndemere last Thursday I legitimately shocked, even though it was telegraphed in the episode I was like "oh shît".

THIS.

I literally screamed out loud when it was Ryan at the door, even though he had just said, plain as day, "One more stop!" 

8 minutes ago, Taoboi said:

So Heather really was a decoy? There really is a Hook?

This is what I've been saying. Not with many people thinking I made sense, though! 🤪 Heather was trying to protect Esme by putting up a screen. She made two Hook attacks - Rory, who was just an opportune target at the wrong place, at the wrong time. And, then, she attacked Joss but ended up killing Britt. I was told that the reveal on the actual original Hook would be March. Can we possibly wait that long?!!!

Someone said on twitter they feel the hook stuff was a rewrite, that they feel it was initially Rory or Esme 

Okay. I surrender. I talked to someone. Heather is going to be the one, the only, the original ... HOOK. Doesn't make sense. The writers just made it up as they went along. I'm disgusted. I want to take back every nice thing I have said about GH for the past 2 weeks. 🤪

3 hours ago, dragonflies said:

Someone said on twitter they feel the hook stuff was a rewrite, that they feel it was initially Rory or Esme 

Oh? Because I know me and @AbcNbc247 used to discuss Rory maybe back when it started.

 

On 2/20/2023 at 12:02 PM, Tonksadora said:

 

On 2/20/2023 at 11:54 AM, Taoboi said:

So Heather really was a decoy? There really is a Hook?

This is what I've been saying. Not with many people thinking I made sense, though! 🤪 Heather was trying to protect Esme by putting up a screen. She made two Hook attacks - Rory, who was just an opportune target at the wrong place, at the wrong time. And, then, she attacked Joss but ended up killing Britt. I was told that the reveal on the actual original Hook would be March. Can we possibly wait that long?!!!

Yeah, that was the impression I have always gotten as well with the Heather reveal after Britt and Joss were attacked. And the dialogue in the episodes following suggested that Heather was decoying for the real one to be sure people didn't think it was Esme.  And to date (i'm up to last Friday), it appeared that was still the case.

 

I also felt there was a reason why other characters kept mentioning it had been weeks since a Hook attack at some points. To set up the REAL reveal.

 

But it sounds like the writers are just going to stick to Heather as Hook which as I've said in the discussion thread is just too anticlimatic to me. 

7 minutes ago, Taoboi said:

Oh? Because I know me and @AbcNbc247 used to discuss Rory maybe back when it started.

 

Yeah, that was the impression I have always gotten as well with the Heather reveal after Britt and Joss were attacked. And the dialogue in the episodes following suggested that Heather was decoying for the real one to be sure people didn't think it was Esme.  And to date (i'm up to last Friday), it appeared that was still the case.

 

I also felt there was a reason why other characters kept mentioning it had been weeks since a Hook attack at some points. To set up the REAL reveal.

 

But it sounds like the writers are just going to stick to Heather as Hook which as I've said in the discussion thread is just too anticlimatic to me. 

Yep that was us lol

I miss Rory 😂

3 minutes ago, AbcNbc247 said:

Yep that was us lol

I miss Rory 😂

Lol. Yep, yep.

 

As much as I've loving Sprina, I think the only false note for me is the fact that Rory sooo feels like a speedbump now after a year of he vs Spence. 

15 minutes ago, Taoboi said:

Lol. Yep, yep.

 

As much as I've loving Sprina, I think the only false note for me is the fact that Rory sooo feels like a speedbump now after a year of he vs Spence. 

If the show hadn’t dragged their feet, we could’ve gotten a proper Spencer/Trina/Rory triangle 

6 minutes ago, AbcNbc247 said:

If the show hadn’t dragged their feet, we could’ve gotten a proper Spencer/Trina/Rory triangle 

Exactly!

My impression had been this:
Esme *was* the hook at the beginning.  At some point Heather jumped in and took over (without Esme's knowledge).  Heather killed at least one person when Esme had an observable alibi, as a way to draw suspicion away from Esme.  Meanwhile Esme got pregnant and couldn't do it anymore anyhow. 

Edited February 22, 20232 yr by janea4old

I don't think Esme was ever the hook, but they'll have to account for who was hooking early on while Heather was still in the more restrictive mental health facility.  She has easily snuck in and out of this place, but hasn't it been determined to be less restrictive that where she was when she first reappeared?

The Hook started hooking when she attacked Ava on August 26th and Heather didn't reappear until October 28th.

I've crossed the Lt Mayor off of the list, as she's involved in the Anna haunting story, and I think that will be her exit plot.  And I think Rory was just a classic red herring and Esme is obviously who we are supposed to think is the killer.

I still think the key is the clue that the poison was from a South Seas reptile, and only a few people would have access to that...

 

 

Edited February 22, 20232 yr by j swift

On 2/20/2023 at 11:54 AM, Taoboi said:

So Heather really was a decoy? There really is a Hook?

 

Now back to who it could be then...?

THIS.

 

Or see what a difference being invested in story makes when they turn the focus to people we actually care about. Mac, Felicia, etc. 

i still think the hook killer is Rory (who isn't really dead) and he was working with Esme, but now she has amnesia.

17 hours ago, janea4old said:

My impression had been this:
Esme *was* the hook at the beginning.  At some point Heather jumped in and took over (without Esme's knowledge).  Heather killed at least one person when Esme had an observable alibi, as a way to draw suspicion away from Esme.  Meanwhile Esme got pregnant and couldn't do it anymore anyhow. 

I like this better than the hook they're leaving us hanging from. 

On 2/22/2023 at 2:00 PM, dio said:

i still think the hook killer is Rory (who isn't really dead) and he was working with Esme, but now she has amnesia.

I wouldn't mind that at all. What a twist, too.