Jump to content

When did MAB jump the shark? Y&R


Recommended Posts

  • Members

When do you guys think MAB jumped the shark with Y&R?

I think it was when Muhney was recast as Adam. Not that recasting with Muhney caused the jump, but the things Muhney's Adam did and have done were deplorable. It has required too much suspension of belief for a soap, for him to have gotten away with all of it. The only character on the soap that seemed to not ever buy into any of it was Ashley.

The chipmunk part of Kevin's story was odd, but overall the story wasn't so bad. I have always wondered what the behind the scenes story was about the chipmunk head.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 45
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I think the chipmunk story was the beginning of the end. After that, the entire tone and types of stories she wanted to tell changed and became more outlandish, character-destroying, and just offensive to watch.

Not to mention, she and her henchmen had no idea how to plot or pace a story to save their lives.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Definitely the chipmunk. I was glued to the screen throughout the fall of 2008, through the Kay/Marge story and then they did that crap and it went to hell from there with Adam terrorizing Ashley, Colleen's death, stunt casting, the numerous false deaths, etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When do you guys think MAB jumped the shark with Y&R?

I think it was when Muhney was recast as Adam. Not that recasting with Muhney caused the jump, but the things Muhney's Adam did and have done were deplorable. It has required too much suspension of belief for a soap, for him to have gotten away with all of it. The only character on the soap that seemed to not ever buy into any of it was Ashley.

The chipmunk part of Kevin's story was odd, but overall the story wasn't so bad. I have always wondered what the behind the scenes story was about the chipmunk head.

When she was hired? That's when I last paid any mind to the show. But if I'm honest with myself, it was actually after the show decided to break apart Chloe from the Billy/Cane/Lily storyline.

For me, that moment came when it seemed like entire episodes were centered around Victor and Sabrina traveling to art museums.

God was that boring. Thank god they killed off that bore!

Making Sharon and Adam a couple

That too!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Shadam as a couple was horrible

Lawd have mercy! One of the most wretched ideas and was the end of Sharon for me (getting with your child's kidnapper is the lowest of the low). I would very much like for Case to be gone when I begin watching again. Sharon cannot be salvage, and there is no need in wasting time trying. She's done! 18 years is plenty and it's time to get rid of this wretched hobag. She is nothing to YR anymore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Phillip faked his death because he is gay. That was it for me.

Recasting Adam and giving him horrible stories, killing off Brad and Colleen and keeping Cane around didn't help things. Should I mention Jill being Lauren's sister?

Worst fan fic ever.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I can't remember exactly when I tuned out of Y&R, it had to have been sometime after the whole Lauren/Sarah Smythe storyline. Victor & Sabrina was definitely a BORE (wasn't there one "location" shoot that was really just outside the studio doors overlooking the parking lot at CBS Studios?).

The thing that really keeps me from watching Y&R again full-time is that there are SO many new characters and SO many recasted younger characters. I can't even keep up with who's supposed to be whom, who's related to whom, who's romancing whom, etc. I only tune in to see the vets and sometimes, even they don't have a worthwhile story to watch (I like Neil, but hate any storyline I see him in as of late). Haters gonna hate, but I love Phyllis and anything surrounding her. The only time I roll my eyes and fast-forward is when she's in story with the young dumb ones like Daisy (that's her name right? That Yvonne Zima sleepwalking girl?)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I think the chipmunk story was the beginning of the end. After that, the entire tone and types of stories she wanted to tell changed and became more outlandish, character-destroying, and just offensive to watch.

Not to mention, she and her henchmen had no idea how to plot or pace a story to save their lives.

I agree. Many stories have been disjointed and characters destroyed.

Definitely the chipmunk was the beginning... it continued with Muhney's Adam and that horrible Ashley story, then followed by Colleen's death.

Yeah, Colleen's death was gutwrenching, and how many times did Victor vow to change only to revert back? Ugh.

Making Sharon and Adam a couple

Word! Too much suspension of belief required for me! And it repeatedly played out over and over and OVER...

Shadam as a couple was horrible

Word to you too!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Recent Posts

    • And on another note...I find it interesting that all this Jeannie stuff has grown down (I was even at work earlier and she was the MAIN story when you bring up the browser) as Ex Soap Opera Star over in BH is dealing with another controversy picture she's in involving blackface. 
    • RONALD LISS RADIO THE ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN    Robin/ Dick Grayson BRIGHT HORIZON       Bobby West BUCK ROGERS IN THE 25TH CENTURY     George "Buddy" Wade  HILLTOP HOUSE    Tiny Tim MARK TRAIL      Scotty PEABLES TAKES CHARGE     Ned THE STORY OF BESS JOHNSON     Crutch THAT'S MY POP        Son TWO ON A CLUE          Mickey UNKNOWN  ROLES THE CAVALCADE OF AMERICA THE CIMARRON TAVERN COAST TO COAST ON A BUS THE COLUMBIA WORKSHOP DIMENSION X THE ETERNAL LIGHT THE FORD THEATER INHERITANCE LET'S PRETEND NEW WORLD A'COMING STUDIO ONE SUSPENSE THEATER FIVE    1965 THIS IS YOUR F. B. I. TWO THOUSAND PLUS    2000+ X-MINUS ONE YOU ARE THERE             RAYMOND "RAY" WALKER RADIO HILLTOP HOUSE      Duke TELEVISION GANG BUSTERS       Detective O'Reilley     1952 movies BULLDOG EDITION      Ken Dwyer     1936 PIRATE OF THE SEAS     Pilot Hal Weston     1939 IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE     Joe from the Luggage Shop                  GEORGIA BACKUS Wrote for NBC Radio     1926-28 Wrote for CBS Radio from 1928-?   RADIO ARABESQUE        Myra   1929-31 BRENTHOUSE      Portia Brent A DATE WITH JUDY      Dora Foster                                   Mitzi Hoffman THE LIFE OF RILEY      Peg Riley THE ORANGE LANTERN    Olga Nesheim THE STORY OF HOLLY SLOAN      Aunt Keturah Sloan UNKNOWN ROLES THE CAMPBELL PLAYHOUSE THE CAVALCADE OF AMERICA   THE ENO CRIME CLUB     1931-32 JOE PALOOKA LET GEORGE DO IT THE MAGNIFICENT MONTAGUE NBC UNIVERSITY THEATER THE PACIFIC STORY THE PALMOLIVE BEAUTY BOX THEATER THE SCREEN DIRECTOR'S PLAYHOUSE THIS IS MY STORY movies CITIZEN KANE     Miss Anderson      1941 COPPER CANYON     Martha Bassett     1950                  Please register in order to view this content AARON VAN WAGNER DAYS OF OUR LIVES      Jason Welles      1999-2002; 2007 DAYS OF OUR LIVES: THE LAST BLAST REUNION     Jason Welles  2020
    • lol. Yeah, I definitely could have thought of a better title. Heck, GH people should have thought of a better title.  lol. Yeah, I definitely could have thought of a better title. Heck, GH people should have thought of a better title. 
    • Yes so big in fact that if GH was cancelled, I would shocked if Sonny did not ride off into the sunset with Brenda...with needed changes of course. Please register in order to view this content  She is still too heavily connected to the canvas...or can be...to not even NOT be relevant. As Brenda should be.   But I really came by LOL...granted I'm farther back than the rest of you, but I haven't gotten to the repetitive nature of the conversations between 'Sonny' and Carly yet. And like I've mentioned, I like this feels very much (as much as a soap can be) organic conflict.    But one thing I have liked about it (so far) has been Carly HAS NOT reacted to it the way she usually does. Let's face it...once Carly knew Sonny was alive and Nina knew, 9 times out of 10, she would have EXPLODED and @Cheap21 would have done one awesome 'Oh Lord Carly's on the Loose' gif/pic. Then she would have raised h#ll from the moment she found out to now, complete with a revenge plot.   I liked that they have truly just showed...yes, showed...Carly wrestle with her feelings over Nixon Falls. Olivia. Gladys. Willow(?). She has made a LOOOOOOOT of effect to not just explode at the drop of a hat. And even when she has started to, Carly has caught herself. And I found LW was playing that to the hilt. It's been over weeks, too. If that is not maturity, I don't know what is.   That said...I still keep that Carly will be her own worst enemy in the end. But at least it has a build to it.      THIS.   And they definitely prove that last part when VM came back for GH's 50th. First scene and it was there. At least for me. lol. 
  • On Soap Opera Network

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy