Id be more pissed if she was a recasted Di than Liza or Hayley to be honest.

Id be more pissed if she was a recasted Di than Liza or Hayley to be honest.

So would I. Kelli Giddish IS Di - I'm still mad that they let her go last year.

I would be upset though if they recasted Liza and Haley!

Kelly and Marcy said they would come back to AMC............It would be a slap in their faces if they just recast the character!

I would be upset though if they recasted Liza and Haley!

Kelly and Marcy said they would come back to AMC............It would be a slap in their faces if they just recast the character!

Didnt Marcy retir? I doubt she would come back honestly.

as for kelly - i also doubt she would come back fulltime.

both roles can be recasted, esp with an actress like BE.

Most viewers would NEVER accept a Hayley or Liza recast , so why go there?

Both kelly and Marcy have said they would return short-term.

Hayley without her Boys wouldn't work and even then everyone would be wating to know where Mateo was , she was given a very happy exit with a awesome Family and bigtime Talkshow job so there's really no reason for Hayley to return fulltime.

However short-term with kelly would be awesome and give the show a major ratings boost.

Marcy is also open to comingback short-term and should have been brought back for the Jesse/Angie stuff.

Like some very smart poster said if they wanted Beth to play Hayely and be with RPG they should have brought he back as Mateo and not Jake.

She falsely accused both Tad and Ryan of raping her (it was actually Ryan's brother Braden who did it), so she didn't exactly endear herself to anyone. She was a lame-o character anyway.

I actually liked Kit. We the right writers she could've been a great character.

I would be upset though if they recasted Liza and Haley!

Kelly and Marcy said they would come back to AMC............It would be a slap in their faces if they just recast the character!

Marcy Walker has retired from acting, she's a child minister now. She has recently said she would return short-term, btu IMHO, Liza is needed long-term not short.

Didnt Marcy retir? I doubt she would come back honestly.

as for kelly - i also doubt she would come back fulltime.

both roles can be recasted, esp with an actress like BE.

I agree JackPeyton.

Whoever she plays I hope it's someone that will come between Zach and Kendall.

*Fingers crossed*

I don't really want to watch 2 newbies together (Jake/BE)

no matter how popular they were on another show.

Whoever she plays I hope it's someone that will come between Zach and Kendall.

Beth Ehlers and Thorsten Kaye?? ...no thank you.

I actually liked Kit. We the right writers she could've been a great character.

I also liked Kit and wouldnt mind if she did return. BE as her would be great

So would I. Kelli Giddish IS Di - I'm still mad that they let her go last year.

Me too.

Me three. Loved Kelli Giddish.

Ugh, if just hope that one day AMC will bring back Di, Dixie (alive!!!!), Brooke and Bianca :=)

It's obvious they're going the route GH is going with Kirsten and Jason by pairing up RPG and BE

Whoever she plays I hope it's someone that will come between Zach and Kendall.

LOL because that's worked so well for Dixie and Greenlee and Ryan? So you want her character to be hated before she starts? Yeah that makes so many kinds of sense

Edited May 26, 200817 yr by Zendall Fan

It's obvious they're going the route GH is going with Kirsten and Jason by pairing up RPG and BE

LOL because that's worked so well for Dixie and Greenlee and Ryan? So you want her character to be hated before she starts? Yeah that makes so many kinds of sense

For all of the people who aren't fans of that particular couple, i don't think Beth will be hated; she would be celebrated!

So you want her character to be hated before she starts?

It makes perfect sense - spin it whatever way you want, but not everyone wants Zendall together. Not everyone would hate her for that.

I think it was Adam who said she's better off being a new character, I agree, making her Hayley or Liza would cause too much backlash, given both actresses have spoken of their desire to return

It makes perfect sense - spin it whatever way you want, but not everyone wants Zendall together. Not everyone would hate her for that.

Where in my post did I say that? Oh and I'm not the one who spins stuff

Yeah when has putting any character between a popular character ever gone over well? That's the freaking kiss of death, I thought that was pretty much a given.

Imagine if this were Nuke or CarJack on ATWT, putting characters between those popular couples is the kiss of death.....

Edited May 26, 200817 yr by Zendall Fan