Jump to content

New "Marlena De Lacroix" column up ~


Recommended Posts

  • Members

Veteran soap critic Marlena De Lacroix objects to colleagues who swoon over Ron Carlivati's new OLTL already.

A soap should be viewed for at least a year before it is crowned 'best soap,'she says.

Still, Marlena does adore Carlivati's sophisticated writing stylings. including a newly "socialist" Viki, and the farce-style dooring-slamming do'in's at the Buchanan mansion and the Paris Suite's hotel.

Read Part 1 of her unique analysis of OLTL at marlenadelacroix.com/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 17
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I agree with her. OLTL has improved in some ways, but still has a LONG LONG way to go. I still FF over half the show. I think the teen scene and younger set in general need a revamp. Sarah needs to be recast, the Vega brothers are dull, Vincent, Layla, Miles, etc. are worthless and screenhog John needs to immediately go. To think they gave a failed recast (Marty) an expensive, drawn out exit is ridiculous. SHe should've been immediately rushed out of the door. Cole too.

I do think his new characters have been strong and I like his focus on the vets, but nothing else is really working for me. He's certainly not the new Douglas Marland as some have suggested. I'm going to give him a year to truly decide. Look at LML, she started off hot (thanks to the Bell leftovers), but the show is abysmal now. Higley, McTavish, Passanante, etc. also started off well.

Let's see if he can hold it!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

It's been almost 3 months with Carlivati as a sole HW... but it's too soon. The most part of 2007 wasn't good and I just hope 2008 will be the best in the last few years. Ron is doing wonders and I'm just enjoying the ride... I hope it lasts. But the best? I'd say it's the best these last few weeks (if you compare it to the others).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I've been one of those people praising OLTL up the yin-yang. After the dreck that was Higley's reign, it was nice to tune into the show and actually enjoy it!

Ron's done a great job of restoring balance to the show, making it seem like a real soap. Gone are the days of going weeks without seeing contract actors, or only using them on prop duty. Ron has also done a good job of giving characters who've been forced down our throats a break (Jessica/Nash, Antonio, John, Miles, Rex/Adriana) and bringing out those we necessarily haven't seen much of.

Is the show perfect? Not by a long shot. But everything, at least IMO, is being so well written that I can forgive the occasional screwup. I'm finally adjusting to the new Sarah. I enjoy her & Christian together. I'm actually liking Natalie for the first time in maybe 2! The newbies (at least the ones that will be sticking around) are fleshed out and don't appear to be one dimensional, and he's integrating established characters into the stories of the new characters (i.e. Dorian now being involved in the Jared/Charlie story).

There are some characters who under any other writer would be written out (Miles for instance). After what he did to Todd & Marty, he would have just been written into the ground or turned into an over the top villain. But, Ron gave us a break from Miles, and put him with a character you wouldn't expect to see him with, Roxy. Lol, those two have good chemistry and I'm looking forward to their scenes coming up. Plus, Ilene Kristen just rocks my socks. Anytime I can see her in an enjoyable story is great!

And btw, thanks for the e-mail ChrisL. I'm going to respond! :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I agree with her to a certain point.

I think it was quite ridiculous to give Carlivati so much praise only weeks into his tenure as sole HW. I even agree with some that say OLTL didn't even deserve to get "Best Soap" this year. (RC was only HW of three months this year, so it makes sense. It does deserve the title of "Most Improved".). However I think after three months he's proved himself somewhat. Sure for some he might still have a long ways to go, but in the three months that he's been HW he's done wonders. He's started some of his own stories and fleshed out a variety of characters. Even some of the characters who were clunkers under Higley, are being revitalized these days such as the Vega brothers, Sarah, and Natalie.

IMO OLTL at the moment is the best soap opera on air.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Yeah, I was fickle. I abandoned baby watch & just tried to think of really well matched pairings. Yeah, they sent Carter & Thomasina away far too soon for my way of looking at things.  I REALLY liked them & they were rare being both young & African Americans. 
    • My watching in that time period was sketchy.  After high school, I didn't have a TV.  I would watch in the dormitory common room  my first year away from home, but then after that I lived in a rental with housemates who didn't want TV.  I think I caught up on the soaps during school(univ) vacations, when visiting my sister's house.  And then many many years later on soapnet?  Not sure. I had no idea that Jeff ever tried suicide. Reading just now is the first I ever heard of that. Interesting. I will agree that Monica wanted Jeff out of the way so she could be with Rick, but she would have wanted him gone emotionally.  But I don't remember watching Jeff having any medical issues, so I don't know if she would have wanted him dead.
    • Didn't he have a nightmare last week?
    • Nothing about Joss ever works. I can't blame them for trying a completely fresh approach for her, but she needs to be written out. 
    • Thanks @Paul Raven  Some of this sounds strong but it's all so heavy and some elements, like with Felicia and Charles, almost veer on parody. L&L seemed to always be a heavy show - did they ever even have comic relief moments? - but I do wonder if it all became too much for viewers.
    • It's a joke. If there's a way to put Joss into a WSB spy story that works, I haven't seen it. What they're doing is just ridiculous. Imagine trusting a huge operation to someone who "finished training" a month ago. I think they're trying to make this work by having a college-age agent be a part of the professor's class, etc. It might look acceptable on paper, but it doesn't work when you see it.
    • Monday, after the party, Leslie showed up at the Duprees. Martin was with everyone as they listened to her for a bit. Then Martin said he was needed at home.  Anita and Vernon knew he was upset and they were concerned. Vernon asked "Do you need Titus, or are you okay to drive?"  Martin said he was okay and left to drive himself home. Either Titus is a chauffeur or just some helpful all-around employee.
    • if only Dante had admitted to hating string instruments earlier....

      Please register in order to view this content

    • I know the other soaps talk about staff help who we never see (especially Y&R with all those ridiculous "Mrs. Martinez" mentions), but I wanted BTG to do better.
    • @Franko As requested 1976 story summary. I'll be posting it in parts as it is very lengthy  and probably too much to take in at once.  Since 1951 the story of the residents of the town ofRosehill, Love of Life, has revolved around the livesof Vanessa (Van) and Margaret (Meg) Dale and their families. ' Van, now married to Bruce Sterling, finds her husband has become mayor due to the death of the former mayor, Jeff Hart, who was her sister Meg’s husband. Meg offered her son Ben half a million dollars as a wedding gift to marry refined and responsible Betsy Crawford and thus abandon his playboy existence. The offer was so good that Ben married Betsy with alacrity despite the fact that he was already married to Arlene Lovett, a fact very few people knew. Arlene reluctantly agreed to the bigamous marriage on Ben’s assurance that as soon:as he had his hands on the money they would skip town. However, Meg decided Ben needed more time to become responsible for such a large sum of money and has held up the gift. Attorney Jamie Rollins has discovered discrepancies in Ben’s stories concerning his close friendship with Arlene but has been thwarted in his attempts to expose Ben by Ben and Arlene’s successful blackmail retaliation.They drugged him and took suggestive pictures of him in bed with Arlene, which they now threaten to show to Diana Lamont, Jamie’s lover, who is carrying his child. Knowing that Diana’s health and age make carrying this child dangerous to her, Jamie can do nothing. Ben is horrified to discover Betsy is now pregnant, too. Felicia Lamont, married to Diana’s ex-husband, Charles, has been unable to consummate her marriage due to extreme emotional frigidity. Charles has been exceedingly patient, but Felicia’s emotional torment has been increased by the constant harassment of hoodlum/rapist Arnie Logan, whose subtle terror campaign is apparent only to Felicia, thus making her appear to be emotionally unstable. Only Eddie Aleata, Meg’s ex-husband, seems aware of the tortures Felicia is undergoing. Caroline (Cal) Aleata, Meg’s daughter, is becoming romantically involved with Rick Lattimer, formerly married to Bruce’s daughter Barbara, to the dismay of his business partner in the Beaver Ridge Club, who has him earmarked as her latest lover—Cal’s mother, Meg! Realizing that she is an accomplice, albeit unwillingly,in her- husband Ben’s bigamy, Arlene Lovett (Harper) tells attorney Jamie Rollins that she and Ben were once married but divorced before his return to Rosehill. To: prove good faith, Arlene gives Jamie the negatives of compromising pictures of him with Arlene that Ben set up, hoping they could keep Jamie in line by threatening to send them to his wife-to-be, Diana Lamont, who at forty is pregnant for the first time, and thus vulnerable. Jamie finds Diana collapsed on the floor and rushes her to the hospital, where their son is born prematurely. Learning that Diana found a partially burned picture of him and Arlene in bed, Jamie blames himself. The baby, Adam Jonathan. Rollins, has respiratory problems and cannot be saved. Diana feels she has lost everything, recalling the picture as well as the baby. Di and Jamie start to make plans for the future. Then Dr. Albertson informs them that | more tests are necessary, as a shadow appeared on her final X-rays. Exploratory surgery is scheduled, and Diana is shattered to learn later that a hysterectomy was necessary. Ben again asks his mother when she’s going  to give the wedding present (Ben married Betsy Crawford because Meg promised a half million dollars, but she postponed the gift until Christmas, and still hasn’t delivered.) Betsy tells Meg she’s destroying Ben’s manhood by dangling the money in front of him. Learning that Ben is into Ray Slater, a gambler, for six thousand dollars, Meg withdraws her promise of the money. When Ray informs Ben that his loan, with interest, is now up to nine thousand dollars, Ben threatens to go to the police. Ray replies that it’s the money or Ben’s skin, and when Ben tries to slip out of town, he’s badly beaten by collection men and dumped in the snow. Found by two backpackers, Ben is taken to a small hospital with a skull fracture and pneumonia. Meg is stunned to discover that her partner in Beaver Ridge Club, Rick Latimer, whom she considers her private property, is in love with her daughter,Cal. Learning that Cal and Rick are planning a weekend together, Meg arranges an immediate audit of the Beaver Ridge books, keeping Rick in town. Meg’s plot backfires, however, when the audit reveals that Meg wrote the down payment for her next project, the Priestly Estate venture, on the Beaver Ridge construction account. Meg replaces the money, but Rick warns her to stop trying to run his life or he’ll press misappropriation charges. Felicia Lamonte has been harassed by a young hoodlum, Arnie Logan, who has served time for assault and rape. At her painting studio she is again accosted by Logan, and she pulls out her gun, scaring him off. Unable to reach her husband, Charles, she calls Edouard Aleata, who has reinterested her in painting, and he arrives with the police. Charles, finding Eddie there with Felicia, fuels his growing suspicion that there’s something other than friendship between them. Because he’s already jealous, Arnie’s new harassment—notes to Charles that Felicia is unfaithful seem believable. Felicia convinces Charles that a week apart will help their marriage, and in looking over her paintings, she realizes she has grown as a person and feels ready to be a woman. She calls Charles, telling him she no longer wants to be his child virgin bride, but a real wife to him. Later, hearing someone at the door, Felicia assumes it is Charles, and is grabbed by Arnie when she opens it. He drags her downstairs, but she manages to escape and get back to her studio and her gun. Hearing footsteps outside, she fires blindly. Cautiously,she then goes to the door to find Charles lying there. He is rushed to the hospital, where it is discovered that the bullet is lodged in his spine. He’ll recover, but will be paralyzed. Logan is picked up, and charges are confirmed when other victims come forward with similar stories STAY TUNED.MORE TO COME...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy