For a long time, I thought the Newmans were a creative albatross around Y&R’s neck.
They’ve struggled to create fresh and interesting dynamics for them. Victor is a caricature. They tried to make Nick into an alpha businessman, that flopped, and now he’s back to just sorta being “there.” Victoria has flailed in her father’s shadow for two decades. Abby’s Newman heritage has almost become an inconvenience. They’ve essentially written Nikki into a corner enough that she’d hardly be missed if MTS left.
They’re played by some of the least dynamic (and often laziest) actors on the show.
They haven’t been able to elevate a newer generation. Victoria’s kids are pretty much props, and they couldn’t find a place on the canvas for Reed. Part of that is the resistance to let Victor ride off into the sunset, and neither AH nor JM can convey gravitas. Nick is so infantilized that Noah feels like his peer. (The less said about the characterization for Noah, the better.) They refuse to invest in a vibrant teen scene to support Faith.
They so quickly burned through story with Adam that he’s become rather absurd and stuck.
Unfortunately they are hugely popular with viewers, and on a show as gutted creatively over the years as Y&R has been, they are foundational. One would need a writer as talented and creatively unfettered as Bill Bell to replace them, and that’s never going to happen.
Mal’s instinct to push Victor out was the right one, but Mal sucked.
It’s a wonder they haven’t explored Victor and Nikki’s extended families more, brought Casey back with family, or something.
But it’s hard to pinpoint the Newmans as problematic when Y&R overall and soaps in general are so dreadful.