I would have taken Hilary B. Smith and Gregg Marx at the end of the shows run.
Justin Deas, they might've been able to get but I doubt they could've gotten Margaret Colin, she does films and primetime TV and stage now. She's pretty busy.
I would've loved Hillary and Gregg to unite. They were smoking hot in their day.
No offense to Scott Holmes and maybe it was how androgynous they'd made Ellen Dolan but there is no way that John and Lucinda should've had so much more sexual chemistry than Tom and Margo and by the time they got to Dolan and Holmes that's exactly what happened.
I never cared for Ellen and Scott's version of Tom and Margo. Ellen was never Margo for me. HBS owned the role of Margo. Scott was only good with HBS Margo. Justin Deas bloated up way too much to have been Tom at the end of ATWT run.