NOT STEPHANIE SHOOTING ERIC AT THE FORRESTER FASHION SHOWCASE!! THAT WAS INSANE AND PURE BRILLIANCE! OH MY! That was an awesome fake-out, oh my goodness... if only it had been real. 😍
Jennifer Gareis' casting of Donna is what I think they were hoping Heather Tom's casting of Katie was. It completely derailed the character in my eyes. Yes, time went by, but it was not what should have been done. Katie got some deserved confidence and maturity, whereas Donna just got rescinded into the makings of Brooke 2.0, and it was off-putting. Donna was rebellious and careless in a way that only made sense for a middle child. With Gareis, she became some... sex pot, which Donna was, even when she was modeling during the first few years.
And it's also why I feel like it should have been Donna who had the affair with Bill and not Brooke, which would have linked back to Donna's relationship with Rocco behind Katie's back. That would have been a solid use of history repeating itself, especially since Donna did flirt at one time with Jim Storm's Bill Spencer. That would have been the proper way to tell the story.
See, I liked the potential of Ethan Wayne's Storm with both Caroline and Kristen. Two missed opportunities there. So far, Brian Patrick Clarke is not bad, but it's also clear he's only back for the sake of having a male presence in the Logan family ⏤ kind of reminds me of when Scott Jenkins was recast as Warren Lockridge on Santa Barbara. Bad choices for no good reason. Almost feels like they wanted to cast someone who is more aligned with the look of Katherine Kelly Lang and the O.G. Beth Logan. Also, they feel more matched as romantic partners. Clarke, to me, would have been a more suitable Dave recast or someone from Dave's family if that character had stayed on (and should have stayed).
By
Liberty City ·
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.