I'll accept James DePaiva and Fiona Hutchison pretty much on any soap, just to see them again. But you all know that, of course.

Alicia Minshew as Victoria Newman or Dinah Marler

Eeeeeeeeeeeeeew! Thanks for putting that horrible image in my head!

Eeeeeeeeeeeeeew! Thanks for putting that horrible image in my head!

Minshew does not have the chops to play either. She's not even on the level of Heinle, and that's pretty bad. As far as Dinah is concerned, when Wendy vacated the role, they should have tried harder to replace her. The role could definitely be recast, but Gina was not the one! Wendy made gold out of everything!

I remember rumors of Maurice Bernard possibly joining YR and playing Victor's brother, Matt Miller. I was totally fine with that had it came true. I'd actually like to see him on YR.

Minshew does not have the chops to play either. She's not even on the level of Heinle, and that's pretty bad. As far as Dinah is concerned, when Wendy vacated the role, they should have tried harder to replace her. The role could definitely be recast, but Gina was not the one! Wendy made gold out of everything!

Who would've been your pick

I'll accept James DePaiva and Fiona Hutchison pretty much on any soap, just to see them again.But you all know that, of course.

I wouldn't have minded seeing James DePaiva on Guiding Light

I wouldn't have minded seeing James DePaiva on Guiding Light

I actually think he would've been a good choice as Sam's dad on GH, lookswise and agewise.

Edited October 4, 201312 yr by MissLlanviewPA

I don't know why -- maybe it's because Heather Tom made such the impression -- but I find "re-casting" Victoria Newman difficult. I think I'd have to do something radical, like re-cast with a blonde, in order to come up with someone "worthy."

I actually think he would've been a good choice as Sam's dad on GH, lookswise and agewise.

How about as Jimmy Lee Holt?

And if Fiona Hutchison were to show up on GH, I'd want her to be either Anna's long-lost sister or a distant relative of Lila Quartermaine's from England.

Edited October 4, 201312 yr by Khan

James DaPaiva looks somewhat like the actor that played Johnny Bauer. Do you all think he'd been a good recast?

St Alban was a Daytime don't! God, at some point, they should just consider killing a character off! I remember the storyline where Michelle lost her memory and became this irresistible sexpot. Absolutely laughable! Shackling PAS to her was criminal!

Please don't remind me of that tragic story. As a MANNY fan, that turned me off. That story made me glad when they shipped them off.

Alicia Minshew as Victoria Newman or Dinah Marler

Robin Strasser as Erica Kane or Barbara Ryan

I don't think these two would work. AM is under the best of circumstances a rom-com lead at most. She is dreadful when leading in drama her limitations become desperately apparent. She works in small doses as a supporting dramatic player, but it's clear she needs a strong lead in order to be effective. Romance and comedy are where she excels, in that light I think a role similar ATWT's Vienna would suit her talents best. Something light, frothy, sweet and funny. Anytime she had a big dramatic scene she always underwhelmed or plain out and out failed. She doesn't have the power for combative, fiery or dramatic scenes -- see Budig or Sweeney for big dramatic outburts and classic soapy scenes. Her coming up on top in a big dramatic exchange simply wouldn't be believable and the weight and heft of Victoria would easily be lost. Not that Amelia Heinle, has any of these properties but she would continue to be a weaker dis-empowered version of the character.

Conversely Strasser wouldn't work as Erica Kane at all. In that way Lucci fit the role like a glove. Erica was a complete and utter fantasy, she's not real and that's why I always had the hardest time with her character. She is a dream with no basis in reality and Strasser is just too hard and strong of an actress for that. Erica had a whimsical free quality that made her almost ephemeral, everyone loved her, everyone wanted to be her, everyone just fawned over her just because of who she was and because of her otherworldly beauty. In that way Lucci just fit the bill. Strasser has a lot of dramatic weight and gravitas that I just don't think would mesh well with this Marilyn Monroe-esque ideal that Erica Kane invoked in others. By this extent she might have made a good Stephanie from B&B.

Edited October 5, 201312 yr by Skin

I remember rumors of Maurice Bernard possibly joining YR and playing Victor's brother, Matt Miller. I was totally fine with that had it came true. I'd actually like to see him on YR.

Again, eeeeeeew. Bernard would have played Sony 2.0--so not Matt.