Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Black Character Portrayals in Soaps Today

Featured Replies

  • Member

David Fumero is one of the very few initially wooden minority actors who was given time to grow into a solid actor.

He'll never be Michael Zaslow but he held his own in enough pairings to justify his hiring.

  • Replies 242
  • Views 32.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member

I agree with that, I never thought he was *great*, but it was refreshing to see a dubiously talented minority actor kept around for as long as he was. I mean, if Aiden Turner was kept around for as long as he was while they tried to figure out what to do with him, I say Fumero deserved the same. I also like how Fumero had a very noticeable accent and presumably wasn't encouraged to get rid of it, and how Cristian dated a pair of white sisters and a pair of black sisters. :P

Edited by SFK

  • Member

Seeing all the posts by GH fans that RS should be kept on as a romantic lead(his horrible acting is half the reason why that should never happen) do you think they'd ever want a black, hispanic or asian character that is a rapists and murderer to be redeemed and kept around?

  • Member

Seeing all the posts by GH fans that RS should be kept on as a romantic lead(his horrible acting is half the reason why that should never happen) do you think they'd ever want a black, hispanic or asian character that is a rapists and murderer to be redeemed and kept around?

RS?

  • Member

I know I've mentioned this before but given the various conversations I've seen here about why web series don't/can't/won't work, I think this article is very timely. I'm a big fan of the web series The Misadventures of Awkward Black Girl and now the creator of that series is fielding offers from networks to bring the series to television and has sold a show to ABC. Granted ABG is basically a comedy but it has some soapy elements. Last season was all about a romantic triangle. Of course it was two guys competing for a woman's attention which is unheard of in the soap verse. Issa Rae is gaining increasing success by creating programming for the audience that soaps consider irrelevant.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/magazine/issa-rae-and-her-web-series-the-misadventures-of-awkward-black-girl-are-rising-stars/2012/10/01/bf3c04a4-fc2b-11e1-8adc-499661afe377_story.html

Edited by marceline

  • Member

This is the show I've dubbed (lovingly!) "The Days and Nights of Molesha Dodd." (Get it?)

Good for her!!! smile.png

Edited by Khan

  • Author
  • Member

I'm not keen on Shonda Rhimes being involved in this (I have my own issues with her), but I am glad that Issa Rae is attaining more success.

  • Member

I know I've mentioned this before but given the various conversations I've seen here about why web series don't/can't/won't work, I think this article is very timely. I'm a big fan of the web series The Misadventures of Awkward Black Girl and now the creator of that series is fielding offers from networks to bring the series to television and has sold a show to ABC. Granted ABG is basically a comedy but it has some soapy elements. Last season was all about a romantic triangle. Of course it was two guys competing for a woman's attention which is unheard of in the soap verse. Issa Rae is gaining increasing success by creating programming for the audience that soaps consider irrelevant.

http://www.washingto...e377_story.html

That series often has me laughing hysterically. It would be nice if she had more financing and could put out episodes faster. It takes so long between each installment but I understand that she's hustling on a shoe string budget. Still with the obvious following she has, it is a bit disconcerting that she wouldn't have more influential people stepping up to give ABG a bigger production boost. If she were Lena Dunham, that show would've been on HBO or Showtime.

  • Member
If she were Lena Dunham, that show would've been on HBO or Showtime.

Same.

  • Member

I don't think anyone's mentioned Another World yet. I think there were a half-dozen black actors on regular contract back in the early 80s, when playwright Corinne Jacker was at the helm. Quite honestly, I was bored by their stories, but the acting was so good and the actors themselves so charismatic, I kept watching. From an AW Today interview with the lovely Petronia Paley (Quinn Harding):

AWT: In the early 1980s, AW attracted some phenomenal African-American talent. In addition to you, there was Michelle Shay, Joe Morton, Howard Rollins, Reggie Rock Blythwood, and Morgan Freeman, among others. How in the "world" did Bay City get so lucky?

PP: At some point, the decision was made to expand my character, which meant giving Quinn Harding a love interest. The wonderful Bob Christian was hired. Because soap opera thrives on youth and the eternal love triangle, I was given an adopted daughter, Thomasina, who in turn had a boyfriend who just happened to be Bob’s character’s son. The plot thickened when the lovely Michelle Shay was brought on as his wife. From there, the characters and story grew. Howard Rollins, fresh off the success of the movie, Ragtime, was brought on as my brother. Jackee was hired as Thomasina’s funny and irascible aunt. Eventually, I had a construction company and Morgan Freeman was brought on as a business partner who later married the available Henrietta after Bob’s character was killed. Over the ensuing years, there were other love interests in Joe Morton, John Carter, and James Pickens. It came as a shock when I was told that Quinn would be killed, but all good things must come to an end.

  • Member

You can see a lot of the vibrancy and character which Shay, Paley, and Jackee brought to the show (I don't think the men fared as well). There was no good story reason to kill off Quinn. It was shock value and probably ageism. When fans wrote in to SOD to protest, they were told that AW had no idea she was popular.

  • Member

Given the way the world is going, IMO it's not practical or fair to keep trying to figure out an actors ethnic makeup. Nobody should have to submit their heritage for approval. The problem is that the industry still employs a version of the paper bag test and that leaves a lot of good actors out in the cold while one or two get one role after another thrown at them.

As for soaps...sigh...I feel like this conversation has been had so many times that I'm just done having it. One of the many reasons soaps are dead is because they refused to evolve. Or more accurately they chose to devolve. I remember watching GL back in the 90s. The Grants and the Speakses were just as much a part of the canvas as everyone else. David and Kat had a front burner story. Both were complicated, layered characters from different worlds and yet both completely believable. Hampton Speaks (one of my favorite characters on any soap ever) and Billy Lewis had a friendship that feel absolutely real. And last I checked they all "talked white."

If you look at the current environment, does anyone think we would see a Monte Sharp, Nia Long or Vince Williams cast? Hell we wouldn't even get a Debbi Morgan or Darnell Williams and if by some miracle we did, you know what comes next, "Why do we have to look at these newbies? They need to concentrate on the CORE!!"

Soaps did this to themselves. They alienated minorities, they alienated women and they alienated anybody who interested in a story more complicated than triangles and pregnancy. How does anyone expect a halfway decent depiction of minorities when we can't even get a portrayal of a woman who takes the pill?

Plus when we do get a black character, he/she has to be everything. Good enough to be a role model but bad enough to get frontburner status; authentic (which is one hell of a moving target) but not a stereotype and whatever story that character is in has to be perfect because again, there's only ONE so no cheating, no lying, no committing a crime IOW, no doing anything that soap characters do. Look at Frankie Hubbard. He was the "perfect" black male character so he got to wander the halls of Pine Valley Hospital like the [!@#$%^&*] Phantom of the Opera and remain shackled to a poorly conceived character played by one of the most cardboard actresses ever seen.

I truly feel that there's just no hope for the genre anymore. The people who were willing to write diversity all left the genre. The people still in charge are just doubling down on the homogeneous ocean of skinny, white, rich characters we see now in the hope of not alienating the last few viewers left behind. The viewers and TPTB are now just a closed circle of bias and narrow-mindedness feeding each other as one show after another dies.

ETA: And let's not even get on the subject of interracial relationships because that opens a whole other bag of crazy.

All I can say is WOW this is awesomely well said may main gripe as I've said repeatedly for years when I watched soaps in black and white as a little kid...this is 2012 they had/have with the few left a huge opportunity to "redefine the genre" yet steadfastly refuse(d) to do it and stuck with the old school soap formula not even their triangles / pregnancies etc...have evolved into the 21st century its the same old story women aren't like, this for the most part we've come a long way baby...speaking of which....although it is a primetime (soapy drama)....Kerry's Olivia Pope is the only black lead character (heading a show) and this is 2012 on the main networks so I think this pretty much says it all.

Edited by Cyberologist

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.