Lord not every character is destroyed for every bad act they do.

That's not the reason Maxie was destroyed. She was destroyed because there was no plausible motive for her actions as simple as that. Never mind the fact that Maxie would have never done what she did during the Summer of Sleaze in a million years prior to that point. That's why Maxie was ruined not because "she committed a bad act." But because she was so completely off kilter and it was plot written drivel to get her there, I still have no understanding of why she did what she did or what caused her sudden deviation into vixenvill. The only thing that made sense is that Guza wanted certain things in place and he needed her to make it happen. Either way the true version of Maxie, Robyn Richard's Maxie - died as soon as that happened and Kirsten Storms cum Guza's slutty version of Maxie was born.

I'd rather her come on as Georgie. If they cannot get LL back.

Don't ever say that again!!!

That's not the reason Maxie was destroyed. She was destroyed because there was no plausible motive for her actions as simple as that. Never mind the fact that Maxie would have never done what she did during the Summer of Sleaze in a million years prior to that point. That's why Maxie was ruined not because "she committed a bad act." But because she was so completely off kilter and it was plot written drivel to get her there, I still have no understanding of why she did what she did or what caused her sudden deviation into vixenvill. The only thing that made sense is that Guza wanted certain things in place and he needed her to make it happen. Either way the true version of Maxie, Robyn Richard's Maxie - died as soon as that happened and Kirsten Storms cum Guza's slutty version of Maxie was born.

Didn't Maxie "lose her way" after Jesse died? I think the problem with Maxie was/will again be Kirsten Storms. From what I saw of JL, I really liked. Never been a Maxie fan, but I'd take anyone over KS at this point.

I saw motivation. Maxie was still hurting from Jessie's death. Maxie had a crush on Lucky from her childhood and never really cared for Liz. Was it played well no but that doesn't mean the motivation didn't exist. I enjoyed Maxie scheming and aligning herself with Sam more than anything involving Maxie since then. I also thought she and lulu worked better as enemies but then I think they characterized Lulu wrong. lulu should have been the bitch, Georgie the good girl, and Maxie well whatever.

I think she's been gone too long to bring her back.

JL has made this her role now.

Maxie had a crush on Lucky from her childhood and never really cared for Liz.

Yes. Having a crush on someone automatically gives them cause/motivation for destroying a person's marriage, becoming a homewrecker, getting a man hooked on pills because he is in pain, slutting herself up for pills, faking a pregnancy and in general making everyone's life a living hell. Let us remember this was Maxie not Heather 2.0/3.0. Point blank. Guza turned out the character of Maxie and made her completely unrecognizable for certain storyline agenda's. Since then Maxie has been completely retooled as a different character/entity on this show and it's shown since that storyline.

Edited June 23, 201213 yr by Skin

Maxie was trying to sleep with Lucky ever since she was 16. She saw the oppurtunity present itself during the drug storyline and she went after it

Maxie was trying to sleep with Lucky ever since she was 16. She saw the oppurtunity present itself during the drug storyline and she went after it

Given the good girl Maxie was then and the methods she employed to make such things happen it simply wasn't believable or at the very least it was out of character. It never made sense.

Edited June 24, 201213 yr by Skin

Yes. Having a crush on someone automatically gives them cause/motivation for destroying a person's marriage, becoming a homewrecker, getting a man hooked on pills because he is in pain, slutting herself up for pills, faking a pregnancy and in general making everyone's life a living hell. Let us remember this was Maxie not Heather 2.0/3.0. Point blank. Guza turned out the character of Maxie and made her completely unrecognizable for certain storyline agenda's. Since then Maxie has been completely retooled as a different character/entity on this show and it's shown since that storyline.

Losing the love of your life which is what Jessie was characterized as yes. I never saw Maxie as a home wrecker. I saw her as fractured and hurting and Lucky one of the people who reached out to her initially after Nikolas did in the aftermath and Lucky hurt as much as she did for a variety of different reasons.to each his own. I don't even like KS or Maxie. Let's be honest the charCter was not ruined because she became Luckys drug supplier and contributed to his marriage crumbling but as a result of a poor recast and pairing which completely altered the character.

We'll have to completely disagree. Maxie's characterization was assasinated. She was just another character in a long list to be destroyed for the Summer of Sleaze. They did the same thing with others.

Edited June 24, 201213 yr by Skin

When a character is ruined, they are no longer viable after said destruction. Maxie has been very viable and has long since moved past that summer. I really dont think its a stigma on her character today

When a character is ruined, they are no longer viable after said destruction. Maxie has been very viable and has long since moved past that summer. I really dont think its a stigma on her character today

That's because they completely changed the character that Maxie was. She bore no resemblance to RR's Maxie and still doesn't for the most part.

Edited June 24, 201213 yr by Skin

I loved RR's Maxie but she was severely underdeveloped. I cant look at Maxie today and say she would never end up like this,. I think I can see her as a fashionista

That's not the reason Maxie was destroyed. She was destroyed because there was no plausible motive for her actions as simple as that. Never mind the fact that Maxie would have never done what she did during the Summer of Sleaze in a million years prior to that point. That's why Maxie was ruined not because "she committed a bad act." But because she was so completely off kilter and it was plot written drivel to get her there, I still have no understanding of why she did what she did or what caused her sudden deviation into vixenvill. The only thing that made sense is that Guza wanted certain things in place and he needed her to make it happen. Either way the true version of Maxie, Robyn Richard's Maxie - died as soon as that happened and Kirsten Storms cum Guza's slutty version of Maxie was born.

Maxie did that, cause they changed the character to fit KS being in the role and her limited acting ability.

KS MAXIE woudl do that, but RR's would never have. tis why I dislike KS Maxie so much.

JL's Maxie feels like what RR's could somewhat have become,not perfect, flawed, but with a heart.

I dare someone to tell me KS Maxie would have confessed to save Matt, not in a gazillion years

That's not the reason Maxie was destroyed. She was destroyed because there was no plausible motive for her actions as simple as that. Never mind the fact that Maxie would have never done what she did during the Summer of Sleaze in a million years prior to that point. That's why Maxie was ruined not because "she committed a bad act." But because she was so completely off kilter and it was plot written drivel to get her there, I still have no understanding of why she did what she did or what caused her sudden deviation into vixenvill. The only thing that made sense is that Guza wanted certain things in place and he needed her to make it happen. Either way the true version of Maxie, Robyn Richard's Maxie - died as soon as that happened and Kirsten Storms cum Guza's slutty version of Maxie was born.

That summer MADE Maxie a viable character. She went from an annoyince to a character with a clear purpose, motives, and didnt care about the fallout. Yet they kept her human because of her own pain, her relationships with Mac, Georgie, Robin, Spinelli. RR's Maxie was great as a child/pre-teen. But lets not act as if Maxie taking the direction she did is so unrealistic given her history. And it was not out of character, because someone that young doesnt have much of character.

And JFP is the one who took Maxie in that direction, not Guza. Of course Guza wrote it, but Jill told him to take her that way. She and KS have both spoken in the past about the change. It was needed. The show needed a bad girl character and Maxie was the perfect fit. It stemed from her going after Nikolas.

This debate of Maxie tho is odd. They took her in this direction after Robin;s death, a natural progression for the character. I highly doubt it has to do with JL given the show was unsure of when KS would return, but they knew she would be returning. If they changed the direction of story and character for temprecast, that says a lot about their management TBH.

Edited June 25, 201213 yr by JackPeyton