Jump to content

FX: American Horror Story


Toups

Recommended Posts

  • Members

I tried to give this a shot despite my disgust for all things Ryan Murphy. I made it to the end of Week 1 and I just couldn't be bothered to come back, despite the lure of naked Evan Peters, even if they did CGI out his dick. Maybe Netflix someday. But nothing I've heard makes me terribly enthused.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 340
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

This bugs me. I cut some slack when it comes to Ryan Murphy's lack of character development when it comes to this show (or more the fact that we see characters move from point A to C and miss point B) but in this case I couldn't tell if we were meant to feel sorry for LaLaurie and Queenie's "betrayal?" One scene of them bonding over fast food does not do that. If they took another episode to show some of that, I might have. But in an interview about the episode on EW, Murphy said he wanted us to feel sad that Queenie still felt she needed to betray her friend. WTF?

I still think Season 2 somehow was all tied together effectively (though the last two episodes apparently were mainly Tim Minear's idea.) This season is a clusterfuck and I'm not sure it can be tied into something cohesive.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Yeah, the Queenie/LaLaurie stuff made me not want to pay attention to the rest of the show last night. I just don't feel comfortable with the idea that we're supposed to feel sorry for LaLaurie. I definitely don't feel comfortable with Queenie's storyline revolving around making nice with the racist who slaughtered slaves.

And don't get me started on the Zoe sh!t. I don't care about her.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Mission accomplished because, last night on Twitter, Queenie was not treated very well for her "betrayal". I was shocked with the name calling. Kathy does such a wonderful job at everything, and she made me feel for Delphine - not that I won't be enjoying what Marie has in store for her next week (didn't the preview show her cutting off a limb). The absolute fear in Delphine's eyes was a bit sad, but I don't hate Q for it. I am just shocked she went thru with it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I am not. White privilege dictates that that the LaLaurie can torture and murder black people, but she should be forgiven and embraced by Queenie as the representative of all black people. How dare Queenie be disgusted by hearing about LaLaurie's depravity first hand. The most unbelievable part is that LaLaurie is not sorry or has she begged for forgiveness. If given the chance, she would likely do the same to Queenie. Frankly, everything bit of pain LaLaurie is going to suffer is deserved 100 times over.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Dang who'd have that though all Kyle needed was a good lay.

tumblr_mwrnhbckjh1qcne1io7_250.gif

Can they please give Cordelia some glasses? She is really creepy to look at

tumblr_mwrtthZdnP1qj5cd5o2_250.gif

I like Madison's new goth look

tumblr_mwsk9jeC5s1seki3po3_250.giftumblr_mwsk9jeC5s1seki3po1_250.gif

Good for Queenie joining up with Marie. Speaking of Marie, I love her. She is one of the best character currently on television. Angela Bassett is doing such an amazing job

tumblr_mwd1n4rBgC1qfy2kdo1_500.gif

:lol:

tumblr_mws61f4lT21snvpl4o1_500.jpg

tumblr_mwsn1zDtzT1sk9rgqo1_500.jpg

I really like some of the fanart popping up for the show

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

While they hit some valid points, Queenie's doubts didn't just come out of nowhere. She has been calling the other witches derogatory names from day one. Queenie never thought she really fit in and Delphine only reinforced that by telling her the others will never truly accept her. Marie? She needs an in, and she will do anything to get one. Queenie is vulnerable, so naturally, when a black woman tells her she has a home, she is going to lap that up like a new puppy. Marie is only using Q because she has no use for witches, not even black ones. Once Marie is done with Q, she will discard her properly, assuming Q doesn't strike first with her abilities.

I think they chose Gabby because she appears to be comfortable with her size, and if she is happy, the viewers won't fuss. Gabby will not lose a pound because if she does, out the Hollywood window she goes. She may as well stay unhealthy for as long as she can get away with it because the roles are coming in.

So agreed about FrankenKyle. I think Ryan is so enamored with Peters that he tossed him in because when you really look at it, FrankenKyle fits nowhere in this season! Perhaps he will prove to be useful later, and if that is the case, there was no need to feature him so much.

Love the fan art, and Angela is totally rocking this role! I absolutely love Marie Laveau!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Ryan Murphy must be a totally incompetent writer. I thought we were suppose to rejoice that Queenie betrayed her. Look at the story LalAurie told about that baby...and her utter lack of remorse for it. Saying "it was a different time" to explain it away or convince Queenie that it was okay. Then for her to tell Queenie that she would never be accepted because she is black. Come on now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

"Queenie switches sides because a couple of people tell her that her fellow schoolmates will never think of her as a sister witch and because LaLaurie—a woman she already knows to be an immortal racist murderer who created a minotaur—once killed a baby. Yeah, I get why she doesn’t want to be forever friends with LaLaurie after that revelation, but turning on everybody else? The show is trying to use race as a central motivation in its “Now, you go here, and you go here” action-figure storytelling, but it just doesn’t work or conform to the characters as we’ve gotten to know them."

I don't think that this it is as simple at that with Queenie. She feels like an outsider and is looking for somewhere to fit in. How may times has she said she doesn't need the "sorority" because she is used to looking out for herself. But then she is secretly looking for love and acceptance which we saw with the Minotaur. So really her talk is just a front for what she really wants. We know that she has aspirations to be a powerful witch. Look how easily to ate that line up from Fiona about being the supreme. But she never really believed that and neither did Fiona. I don't see it as Queenie turning on the rest of the witches moreso than it is about her own ambition accompanied by her desire to be accepted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

ITA. I don't see this as Queenie turning on the other witches. Rather she is trying to find a place to belong and be loved. As far as she knows Marie only wants LaLaurie who is a monster. Queenie is not privy to Marie's plans. When she does find out, this is when we will see where her loyalty lies.

I am clueless about what Murphy is trying to say about "race," but I like that he is generating difficult and uncomfortable conversation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Or they are not even attempting to see actions through the eyes of the characters...or just can't empathize with Queenie's situation/story. Someone who has always fitted in may not understand the thoughts and feelings of an outsider (which is a situation that doesn't have to necessarily do with race, could be class, gender, straight/gay. cis/trans, general interests, hobbies, basically anything that is not like the most of the people you are around).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Durkin was awful. The writing did her no favors, but she was all wrong for the part, lacking the mix of mystery, steeliness, sorrow and hesitancy that defined Victoria. I still have the awful memory of Adam lugging her around like a rag doll. And her voice...
    • It's a shame she only appeared in three episodes for the purpose of being written out - I thought she was quite good in the little we saw. I liked her vibe better than Durkin that never seemed to quite capture Victoria as a character.
    • He did a lot of romance novel covers, so that might've just been enough for them to get their panties in a twist.
    • Pre-TGIF, ABC most successful 1980s Friday 8 pm comedy I'd say was Webster. Full House wasn't a hit its first two seasons but it started showing growth in its third season which overlapped with the launch of TGIF. Funny thing is, Full House became a Top 10 show with the 1991/92 move to Tuesday.
    • Oakland Tribune, 14 July 1985   AW is another show with Schenkel at helm By Connie Passalacqua For the most part, dictators of South American banana republics enjoy better reputations than executive producers of daytime soap operas. Total authority is vested in these producers, who can kill off a character (thus firing an actor) with a stroke of a pen, or completely change life in his or her soap opera dominion (both in its fictional locale and backstage at the studio) on any kind of whim.  Most rule despotically, inspiring fear in their actors and writers. Which inevitably surfaces on the screen and subtracts from a show's quality. Then there's Stephen Schenkel who became executive producer of Another World last fall. He's been described by one of his actresses as "a teddy bear." He has noticeably improved the show, mostly because his natural warmth encourages backstage cohesiveness, and he believes in personally nurturing his staff and cast. 'I like to be supportive', he said.' I like to generate a certain amount of enthusiasm. I love actors and writers and technical people. And I like to laugh..  ' Schenkel said that most of the factors that have led to the shows improved ratings existed before he took over. There were well defined characters, outstanding writers and excellent production values, he explains. 'These things were in place but needed to be stimulated. There wasn't a lot of excitement. What really was missing was an adequate story. We added Gillian Spencer as a writer. (she also plays Daisy on All My Children), who's wonderful, and it just coalesced. The writers energy and commitment to the show began to give it an emotional intensity and some real passion within the characters." Schenkel, a former ABC programming executive who helped develop Ryan's Hope, is a strong believer in stressing romantic and comedy elements in soap operas. AW is also one of the only soaps with an established group of comic characters, including Wallingford (Brent Collins) and Lily Mason (Jackee , Harry). Schenkel raves about the talents of all his actors, and even has something good to say about the Brooklyn location of the shows studio, which most of his Manhattan-oriented staff loathe. I like the people here. I like to walk down the street and feel their energies, he said. He also violateda soap opera no-no, ' inviting actors and writers to the same party. "Everyone got to know one another, he said. And I didn't get any complaints about actors ' begging for story lines, he said. 
    • Since it's pride month.

      Please register in order to view this content

         
    • National City Star-News, 5 May 1977 TV topics by Peter Blazi Lear’s ‘All that Glitters’—doesn’t The best thing that can be said about Norman Lear’s newest soap opera“All That Glitters” is that it comes on so late at night most people will miss it. Role reversal is supposed to be the big draw, with women the breadwinners, mainly executives of a huge conglomerate. The men either fuss with the housework or fidget at the office as secretaries to their bawdy bosses. A female fantasyland? I doubt it. While the role reversal idea has some possibilities, the show pushes too hard for laughs and winds up with raucous females and effete males. A confident, independent woman is indeed a sight to behold and attract, but femininity need not be sacrificed. Unlike Lear’s “Mary Hartman, Mary Hartman,” "Glitters” doesn’t, but you’ve got to give him credit for trying. Today’s experimental comedy is what tomorrow’s hits are made of. Better luck next time, Norman. (“All That Glitters” can be seen weekday evenings at 11 p.m. on Channel 6.) .
    • Actually Kim Zimmer got six weeks off to test the waters for pilot season in L.A. - she said later she went on many auditions and got one offer for a sitcom, but she would one of many in an ensemble. She turned it down, because it wasn't worth leaving Guiding Light for a supporting role on a sitcom. 
    • I'm not even sure why Zoe would care, even if they know each other offcamera.  I can't see Jean going, but if she is - good riddance at this point.
    • I just found the commercial on YouTube, with several other GL'ers doing the same commercial - how fun!

      Please register in order to view this content

        She did the same for me once Ghost Reva arrived (the anxiety and paranoia) - which is when the storyline for Rick/Annie started, with their Chicago past and her alcoholism. But before all that, when she was new and tending to Josh's broken leg, she was just normal, sweet and very cute/flirty. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy