March 29, 201114 yr Member That's a good commercial. I wish they would let him succeed at this for the shock value and permanence of it all. That's a better way to get your message across than miracle happy endings. Agreed
March 29, 201114 yr Member Yeah, they blitzed through this story (which is poorly written but could have been excellent) for no good reason, other than perhaps the transformative experience that is Andrew Trischitta. Not to absolve them of blame for bad writing, but I would guess that they may have been told to do this story quickly or not do it at all. I think the main point of this story is going to be about Todd and his harem and what a victim Todd is.
March 29, 201114 yr Member Not looking forward to Farah's "acting" but this is a good promo actually.
March 29, 201114 yr Member That's a good commercial. I wish they would let him succeed at this for the shock value and permanence of it all. That's a better way to get your message across than miracle happy endings. I see your point, but if Shane lives, I'm glad. Kill too many kids and the audience will become numb to it. We just had Jake die, another kid in such close succession sort of goes against soap tradition. Different shows, I know, but same network. I like that soaps refrain from going to this well too often. I think it's almost as effective to have him try to kill himself.
March 29, 201114 yr Webmaster Had OLTL killed Shane off, they risked the chance of some viewers mistaking the message, in particular those suffering through this serious problem. Should they see him killing himself as the solution to the problem they have as well, they might do the same. Having him live does more good for those going through this issue.
March 29, 201114 yr Member Had OLTL killed Shane off, they risked the chance of some viewers mistaking the message, in particular those suffering through this serious problem. Should they see him killing himself as the solution to the problem they have as well, they might do the same. Having him live does more good for those going through this issue. That's an excellent point. I'm glad OLTL is bringing attention to this problem, but when I watch it pisses me off so much. I want one of the adults to actually see the problem and deal with it or I want Shane to just kick Jack's ass. It makes me sad that Shane is going to internalize the hate, but i think it makes for a good story and hopefully wake parents up to how dangerous bullying can be. The advent of the internet has changed so much for kids and I think a lot of parents aren't aware of how much things have changed in a relatively short period of time.
March 29, 201114 yr Member Not a bad promo, more low key than most of them are. From what I've read Shane doesn't die, but I think he might end up with brain damage .
March 29, 201114 yr Member Had OLTL killed Shane off, they risked the chance of some viewers mistaking the message, in particular those suffering through this serious problem. Should they see him killing himself as the solution to the problem they have as well, they might do the same. Having him live does more good for those going through this issue. well that's true. I change my mind, you are correct.
March 29, 201114 yr Member I really get why they are doing this story and I like the Shane parts of it but I just wish we had better people playing NuJack and his buddies.
March 29, 201114 yr Webmaster That's an excellent point. I'm glad OLTL is bringing attention to this problem, but when I watch it pisses me off so much. I want one of the adults to actually see the problem and deal with it or I want Shane to just kick Jack's ass. It makes me sad that Shane is going to internalize the hate, but i think it makes for a good story and hopefully wake parents up to how dangerous bullying can be. The advent of the internet has changed so much for kids and I think a lot of parents aren't aware of how much things have changed in a relatively short period of time. Might I suggest reading this article... 'One Life' Takes Bullying Storyline to the Next Level
March 29, 201114 yr Member I don't think they're going too fast with the storyline on this. I think it started off way too slow and it was boring at the start. But, now it's starting to heat up...and even though this is happening now. This does not mean it's the end of it. Because, Shane is probably gonna live. And, then kick Jack's ass..hard! IMO.
March 29, 201114 yr Member I don't think they're going too fast with the storyline on this. I think it started off way too slow and it was boring at the start. But, now it's starting to heat up...and even though this is happening now. This does not mean it's the end of it. Because, Shane is probably gonna live. And, then kick Jack's ass..hard! IMO. No one can do that to any of Todd's kids. The story will probably eventually become about how Jack suffers, or how Todd suffers, or what a terrible mother Blair is. Shane will be forgotten.
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.