I knew she wanted to bring the show to NY since she didn't want to move, but the cast of Broadway Bares too? Oh Lawd.

http://gawker.com/262672/rosie-odonnells-price-is-right-campaign-ends-in-tears

What changes did she wanna make? "Hot men showing off the showcases instead of just women," reports an attendee. Whoa, lady. America's not ready for that!

There were other media outlets that reported this as well.

I'm not sure that comedians are always the best choice for these hosting gigs, I think Wayne Brady and Jeff Foxworthy do good jobs, but some comedians' personalities just don't lend themselves to handing over spotlight or even being enthusiastic hosts for that matter (Drew, Louis Anderson).

Louie Anderson was bloody awful on the Feud. Always drunk on KFC and Evan Williams.

Later incarnations haven't worked because the world has become decidedly less prudish, a lot less is risque and what is risque these days certainly doesn't belong on daytime television, but I loved Match Game, I wish that one would come back. Or Win, Lose, or Draw. I'd take either of those (cheaper!) shows over LMAD, which I was actually in the studio audience for many years ago.

A TV-14 Match Game would rock my face off.

I think alot of it was Les Moonves and Nina Tassler. FREEmantle definitely wanted someone outside of gameshows, hence the auditioning of George Hamilton, Ian Ziering,

Ian Ziering? Your'e fu@kin with me.

Ryan Seacrest would have been "good," but he would have never "lowered" himself to do Price. It would have been better than Drew AND he would have stayed in the FREEmantle family.

I don't know... if they offered him more money than he gets for his syndicated radio show, he might have dumped it and done TPIR. I think the industry sees Seacrest as the "Heir apparent" to Dick Clark, so he would have been good in the spot.

HELL EFFING NO!

In addition to liberals and conservatives alike hating Rosie, she also tried to move the show to NY and actually suggested naked Broadway boys instead of Barker Beauties. Pathetic.

I actually like the broadway boys idea (I would, of course)... but the little old ladies who watch TPIR might not be able to handle it. I like the idea of two hunks, two "beauties"... a little something for everyone. But Rosie's stint on the view did alot of damage to her image. She went form being the "Queen of nice" to this big, bullyish loudmouthed dyke. If I had to choose a woman to host the show, I'd rather have had Janice Pennington do it than Rosie!

What about Vicky Lawrence as a host?

I've been fond of Vicki for years, she did a great job carrying the ball on Win, Lose or Draw when Bert Convy fell ill. But rather recently, I've wondered if she harbors a b!tch that she does a good job of hiding from the public. I say this because I watched the Mama's Family reunion on her talk show up on YouTube a few years ago, and she seemed passive aggressively rude to Beverly Archer (Iola). Maybe I, and some of the folks who made comments on the video, were looking too deeply into it, and we don't have the full story, but rudeness is a major turn off for me and it can break my fandom.

Edited October 24, 200916 yr by SFK

To add to RoseVioletDaisy's comments, GL just wasn't GL any more. I don't know if fans believed that GL would ever spring back to the top of the ratings. I have to wonder if (after 72 years) the anger fans felt was related more to the colossal 'F U' CBS seemed to give the show and the last of the viewers. GL may not have been the show it once was, but something was wrong with dismantling the show before fans eyes and having it seem as if no one cared enough to stop GL's destruction. If GL had to go, let it go on a creative high, but fans couldn't get even that much.

EW seemed to take delight in sticking a finger in fans' eyes. Her comments were abrasive and dismissive. She knew how unpopular BC's Jeffrey was, especially with Reva, and even at the very end she killed off the character only to bring him back in the most ridiculous way possible.

I also think that GL's demise was confirmation for fans that their other beloved soaps were closer to the end than anyone wanted to believe. Many GL fans were fans of other soaps so I can imagine that like myself, they knew that others were soon on their way out.

GL's end was just one great big ugly lesson in learned helplessness for soap fans.

72 years is all the more reason that CBS had a responsibility to really do everything it could to save the show, not a reason to cancel it ... 72 years means something has brand resonance and a core remarkable idea ... CBS did not even give Phillip coming back a chance to succeed (less than 2 months is not a chance) before pulling the plug.

Comparing Andy Griffith and a soap - no. Different animals.

No, to me, 72 years means "Wow, this show has had an amazingly long run, and now it seems like it has finally gotten to the point of winding down and ending the story." To be frank, I think it's [!@#$%^&*] bananas to expect a television show to last forever. It would have been canceled at some point. Why not cancel it when it's the least watched show on network daytime and getting some of its worst ratings everrr? 72 years. Heh. Watch the last week of shows again. You'd never know that this was the end of a show that had been on for 72 years. It was the end of what EW had managed to turn GL into.

And some anti-hosts/comedians work well in gameshows, but they have to know what they're doing. Kennedy(Friend or Foe) and George Gray(The Weakest Link) were great on their respective game shows.

Kennedy

Friend or Foe :wub:

Would you guys have preferred Rosie O'Donnell over Drew Carey? I wonder. Thing is, I don't think Rosie would have been too good at putting all the focus on the contestants, she would annoy us trying to work in personal anecdotes. Her show was really the best thing she's ever done, it was the perfect format for her before it got all preachy.

No indeed Lawd! Never!!!!

Is Tom Kennedy still alive?

Yes. His brother, Jack Narz (Now You See It, the 70s versions of Beat the Clock and Concentration), died last year.

http://gawker.com/262672/rosie-odonnells-price-is-right-campaign-ends-in-tears

What changes did she wanna make? "Hot men showing off the showcases instead of just women," reports an attendee. Whoa, lady. America's not ready for that!

There were other media outlets that reported this as well.

Actually, I like the idea of having male Barker's Beauties. Have two beautiful ladies in gowns alongside to handsome gentlemen in suits, and when the time calls for it, they can be in their bathing suits as well. Male models have barely been used in game show history though.

My issue with Rosie was that she supposedly wanted to "gay the show up" or some silly [!@#$%^&*] like that. She wanted to make the set all pink, remix the theme song into a techno/trance arrangement, give away Koosh balls and trips to Fire Island, and yes, have half-naked boytoys showing off goods from Cuisinart and Michael C. Fina.

My issue with Rosie was that she supposedly wanted to "gay the show up" or some silly [!@#$%^&*] like that. She wanted to make the set all pink, remix the theme song into a techno/trance arrangement, give away Koosh balls and trips to Fire Island, and yes, have half-naked boytoys showing off goods from Cuisinart and Michael C. Fina.

Oh MY!!! I'm the biggest queen on SON, and even I wouldn't be down for that! My issue with Barker's beauties is that they all look like fake breasted bimbos. Holly, Diane, Kathleen, and Janice had ELEGANCE and an air of class. It's like when they replaced Susan Stafford with Vanna... talk about a trade DOWN. Don't get me wrong, I love my boytoys... but they'd probably be a bunch of waxed metrosexual queens with herhsey's kiss hairdo's. I'll pass.

Edited October 25, 200916 yr by alphanguy74

No, to me, 72 years means "Wow, this show has had an amazingly long run, and now it seems like it has finally gotten to the point of winding down and ending the story." To be frank, I think it's [!@#$%^&*] bananas to expect a television show to last forever. It would have been canceled at some point. Why not cancel it when it's the least watched show on network daytime and getting some of its worst ratings everrr? 72 years. Heh. Watch the last week of shows again. You'd never know that this was the end of a show that had been on for 72 years. It was the end of what EW had managed to turn GL into.

ITA. All television shows get cancelled eventually so all the soaps are going to be cancelled. It isn't being pessimistic or doom and gloom. They get stale so people get bored and stop watching. I felt bad when Santa Barbara was cancelled, but the show had gotten bad and it was obviously time go. GL had a good run, but it was at the end. There was nowhere for it to go other than down.

Actually, I like the idea of having male Barker's Beauties. Have two beautiful ladies in gowns alongside to handsome gentlemen in suits, and when the time calls for it, they can be in their bathing suits as well. Male models have barely been used in game show history though.

My issue with Rosie was that she supposedly wanted to "gay the show up" or some silly [!@#$%^&*] like that. She wanted to make the set all pink, remix the theme song into a techno/trance arrangement, give away Koosh balls and trips to Fire Island, and yes, have half-naked boytoys showing off goods from Cuisinart and Michael C. Fina.

I have no interest in gaying the show up. I like your solution at top, though. That would be engaging and different.

I've never really liked gameshows.

Even though I tried, I did try.

I've never really liked gameshows.

Even though I tried, I did try.

Thank the dear Lord!

Man, this thread is amazing, but every time I enter, I stand in wonder: All these people really like gameshows?! Really? I wish I liked them, but boy do I find them boring snoozefests with no end.

Edited October 25, 200916 yr by Sylph

CBS keep sending me emails - begging me to watch LMAD - wonder if it's because I let them know that I was 3rd GL gen. had watched GL on CBS all my life, however since they took off GL I have not watched CBS daytime since 9/21, I still miss GL, but I don't miss CBS at all. I wouldn't be surprised if they would offer to pay me to watch LMAD and guess what I would tell them?

Thank the dear Lord!

Man, this thread is amazing, but every time I enter, I stand in wonder: All these people really like gameshows?! Really? I wish I liked them, but boy do I find them boring snoozefests with no end.

Game shows are awesome kthxbye! The ones on today just aren't that exciting and fun or all that challenging. It's unfortunate. The high drama of soaps can be perfectly balanced by the fun and excitement of a game show. It's just sad that soaps aren't that dramatic anymore and game shows aren't that fun anymore.

Game shows are awesome kthxbye! The ones on today just aren't that exciting and fun or all that challenging. It's unfortunate. The high drama of soaps can be perfectly balanced by the fun and excitement of a game show. It's just sad that soaps aren't that dramatic anymore and game shows aren't that fun anymore.

I think some gameshows today are fun and exciting and challenging. I think the biggest problem is with people in charge trying to fix what isn't broken or responding to budget cuts in the most unsubtle of ways. Wheel of Fortune, by far, is the biggest offender. I know alot of people who are turned off by all the extra crap on the Wheel that is complicated and makes no sense. The Million Dollar Bonus Round should be saved for a yearly "Best of the Best" instead of the complicated way they have to win it.

Game Shows aren't making their content more challenging. They're making the actual gameplay more challenging. And that's a big turnoff.

Thank the dear Lord!

Man, this thread is amazing, but every time I enter, I stand in wonder: All these people really like gameshows?! Really? I wish I liked them, but boy do I find them boring snoozefests with no end.

Oh, they're EXCITING!! This is what we love about them.... (Lucci fans should view this)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fP3OCqLujtc