1 hour ago, DRW50 said:

September 9, 1994. 

I haven't seen the wording of the original question, but they may have just asked for other suggestions, rather than giving specific names as choices. If I have it I'll see what the question was. 

Ah, so ~ 1 week before CD's last episode aired.  I love how the question/possible responses were phrased as though the writers/casting director still had months to plan next steps.

But, that would have been my next question—which other actresses were they teasing?  Even if write-ins were an/the only option, Kate Collins at least looked/comported herself someone like Iris as portrayed by CD; and she had been on a popular soap just a few years before.  KC may have just won a plurality among the sliver of respondents who chose that (younger recast) option, which could have been due to name recognition more than anything else.  I'm not sure the majority of her fans at that time would have even read a soap mag poll about AW all the way through.

Edited October 30, 20214 yr by DeliaIrisFan

Wasnt that he same timeframe where they considered recasting Vicky & almost did with Kelly Rutherford

17 minutes ago, John said:

Wasnt that he same timeframe where they considered recasting Vicky & almost did with Kelly Rutherford

Yeah, Jensen Buchanan nearly left AW in 1994.

@DeliaIrisFan  The more I think about it the more I agree that asking whether the  character should be de-aged (if they did) is offputting, and really tells you where the mindset of the soap press and industry was.

Much as we may  all take lumps off soap fans for some of their views, they were usually very upfront about wanting to see older characters - so much so that when soaps began chasing young faces, their ratings dropped en masse and  never recovered. The refusal to respect older characters, who were loved by viewers of all ages, was one of the greatest nails in the coffin.

2 minutes ago, DRW50 said:

@DeliaIrisFan  The more I think about it the more I agree that asking whether the  character should be de-aged (if they did) is offputting, and really tells you where the mindset of the soap press and industry was.

Much as we may  all take lumps off soap fans for some of their views, they were usually very upfront about wanting to see older characters - so much so that when soaps began chasing young faces, their ratings dropped en masse and  never recovered. The refusal to respect older characters, who were loved by viewers of all ages, was one of the greatest nails in the coffin.

Yeah, honestly, it wouldn't surprise me that much if they were floating some of the same names as potential Iris and Vicky recasts.

If they wanted a younger woman/character to fit into Iris' role, Nancy McGowan and Pammy Davis were right there ...

 The amusing thing about this whole "younger" Iris discussion is that at no point did AW itself suggest this as an option, it was Soap Opera Magazine's 1994 version of magazine clickbate

3 hours ago, Franko said:

If they wanted a younger woman/character to fit into Iris' role, Nancy McGowan and Pammy Davis were right there ...

I thought of a few more women from the AWverse who could have returned to the canvas, albeit with some possible changes: Blaine (weren't they considering bringing back Sandy?), Cecile (who did come back, a year later) and Paige Marshall (with or without a new actor as ex-husband Dennis).

1 hour ago, j swift said:

 The amusing thing about this whole "younger" Iris discussion is that at no point did AW itself suggest this as an option, it was Soap Opera Magazine's 1994 version of magazine clickbate

It worked. It just took 27 years.

Edited October 31, 20214 yr by Franko

11 hours ago, amybrickwallace said:

Yeah, Jensen Buchanan nearly left AW in 1994.

How would you think Kelly would've done in the role(s)? 

1 hour ago, Forever8 said:

How would you think Kelly would've done in the role(s)? 

Kelly would have done at least as well as Jensen.  And maybe Vicky would have retained more of her spit-fire with Kelly in the role.  Jensen essentially turned Vicky into Marley -- Jensen and the misguided writers.   

1 hour ago, Forever8 said:

How would you think Kelly would've done in the role(s)? 

I think she would have brought a lot of fire to the role, and I would have liked to see her play Marley as well.

Ironically, Kelly Rutherford went on to a primetime career of often playing serene, at times remote beauties, first as the ethereal hooker-turned-snow white heroine Megan on Melrose Place, then as the ice queen socialite on Gossip Girl. But I do agree she had plenty of fire and would've done well. MP rarely utilized her properly.

Edited October 31, 20214 yr by Vee

On 10/31/2021 at 9:03 AM, Vee said:

Ironically, Kelly Rutherford went on to a primetime career of often playing serene, at times remote beauties, first as the ethereal hooker-turned-snow white heroine Megan on Melrose Place, then as the ice queen socialite on Gossip Girl. But I do agree she had plenty of fire and would've done well. MP rarely utilized her properly.

If she had landed AW, I think they would have followed the template from Generations.

Kelly played a smart aleck 40s bar tender on Homefront after Generations...and her character reminded me of a Vicky...while her Gossip Girl character was more like a Donna Love.  I don't know how she would have been as Marley..tbh

4 hours ago, Soaplovers said:

Kelly played a smart aleck 40s bar tender on Homefront after Generations...and her character reminded me of a Vicky...while her Gossip Girl character was more like a Donna Love.  I don't know how she would have been as Marley..tbh

 

On 10/30/2021 at 4:37 PM, John said:

Wasnt that he same timeframe where they considered recasting Vicky & almost did with Kelly Rutherford

She was great on S3 of Dynasty as a mean rich girl who is a little nuts.