I agree with everyone else that Dinah Lee was the one who was meant to be killed off, and SHOULD have been (too bad if it meant another tragedy for Trucker :P Also I think it could have been interesting, maybe having Curtis and Trucker reconcile over their shared tragedy.) I am gonna assume Janie was the one killed off instead simply because she WAS so instantly appealing (character and actress) and had a connection to Buck so despite only being on the show for what, three, four months, there would still be some consequence. But yeah, then bringing in Brianna (this is cynical of me but I'm pretty sure it was because they now had a void of a younger black woman--which was part of the reason to bring on Janie) was sooo ugh. C'mon Agnes (if she was still writing--she certainly was still involved) remember when people were so upset that Kelly was killed on AMC and you brought back her double, Kitty? Couldn't you do a double here?? :P
I really liked Jocelyn but I agree with you. It's funny Loving and The City was my first exposure to so many soap actors--both newbies and ones (like Roscoe Born) that longer soap fans would have known well, and I have such nostalgic good will for their characters that I still think with a lot of those actors I liked them best as their Loving/City character (add Jocelyn to the list.)
And you're right, it's obvious there's a passionate Loving fanbase there (and I mean the show was MASSIVE in Italy and my South African boyfriend told me was so popular that a character from it was actually legally imported to a South African soap? Now I can't remember the details but I did look it up one time and it seemed he was right?) It's too bad that the guy who released oral histories about Ryan's Hope and the short lived Texas and now has one about when AW went to 90 mins (which includes mini oral histories of Lovers and Friends and From Richer and Poorer) wouldn't do a Loving/The City book... But I know him from FB and he's one of those Ryan's Hop fans who blames Loving for the destruction of his show lol And I know this is no big revelation but it's interesting to look at the ratings--when 2, 3 million people watched. Which was a drop in the pan then but of course now would be a big deal for any soap, so... people were watching. (Even if like I said, despite becoming soap obsessed after getting hooked on AMC and immediately reading books on the history, and at least checking out the other soaps, I had no idea a show called Loving existed until I saw the adverts for the AMC/Loving crossover. I grew up in Victoria, BC and like most Canadians we got the big US networks via their closest affiliate--Seattle for me--but all of the major soaps were also simulcast on Canadian networks, CBC carrying AMC for ages, going back to the 70s when it wasn't as common to get american affiliates apparently. But, you guessed it, the only soap that no Canadian station simulcast at all was Loving/The City. I can't remember if anyone picked up PC or not.)e), but this thread shows that fans' passion is still there. I've learned so much about the show, after all these years, from this thread and the discussions. The recent replies have tempered my phantom Trisha criticism and understand better that the show was almost backed into a corner.
By
EricMontreal22 ·
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.