Everything posted by P.J.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I don't think Newman/Zimmer lacked chemistry, I think Reva/Josh was the same old story. Josh always ended up looking like a fool for falling for Reva's lies, then he'd fall for someone crazy and realized Reva's craziness was a lot more manageable. I think the difference between Billy and Josh was that no matter how big an [!@#$%^&*] Billy was being, you wanted to hug him. When Josh was an [!@#$%^&*], you wanted to slap him.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I can't speak for everyone, but as a preteen, it was Nola/Kelly/Morgan that got me hooked on GL. Granted, I probably didn't even understand what "chemistry" was, and maybe it was more the chemistry between the three of them that sold the story, but there had to be something there that drew people in. Of course, now I'm a little creeped out by the optics of it. lol And while we couldn't listen to GL, I definitely remember one of my classmates having a boombox and a bunch of us listening to Y&R over lunch.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
Rebecca said they'd been trying to cast Trish for a while, and Betty Rea found her in CA and asked her to audition. She got the job and then shared a dressing room with Maeve. She and Jane started within a few weeks of each other, but the Andy story was wrapping up, so maybe they couldn't wait. Then again, maybe Jane wasn't interested in that role, and Doug came up with something she was. I know I've heard her say she was most proud of Carrie, because it challenged her as an actress. While Jane would've been completely wrong for the part, the idea of Jane and Jordan Clarke arguing in scenes fascinates me.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I just watched an older Locher room interview with Rebecca Hollen/Robert Newman/Krista T where Rebecca says she thinks DM wanted Jane Elliot for the role of Trish. The mind boggles. Jane would be completely wrong for the role as written. I can't see her fitting into the Lewises at all.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I did ask, but later found confirmation that it was 6/24. I'm not sure why there seems to be a discrepancy with the German episode dates. At some point, I'll try to dig into it a bit more. Yikes...I know Vanessa's a manipulative bitch at this point, but I'd never seen Maeve have anti-chemistry with anyone before.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I actually thought the timing for recasting Blake worked. Both as a soft reset for the character and a fitting end for Stringfield. Sherri deserved to play that climax after all her hard work. And honestly, I'm not sure I could've ever believed her falling in love with Ross knowing she set it up to hurt Holly.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I don't think the problem with Blake was Liz Keifer. Admittedly, she wasn't Sherri Stringfield, but those come few and far between. (We're not talking about a drop off similar to Melina Kanakaredes and Jennifer Rozelle, IMO) GL stopped writing rounded characters. Roger departed, so she wasn't daddy's little girl, she wasn't working (that I recall, other than the stupid romance writer) and she suddenly had three kids. And they completely lost interest in her after Ross's death. Didn't she spend a year in a coma?
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
eeee....I have read recaps about it, but I haven't watched that at all. There's a moment before the custody's resolved where he's having a court visit with Peter at Vanessa's, and he taunts her with "we could solve all of this---by getting married." and Van looks like she wants to throw up. I know it gets uglier with Ross and Vanessa once Dinah hits town. At some point, I did realize that Ross and Vanessa deal the most with Roger after his return. Everyone else capable of throwing up roadblocks, Phillip, Alex, Billy, Josh (who, let's face it, isn't a threat anyway) tap out at some point from '90 to '95-ish.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
There's no need to be sheepish. I'm a tad obnoxious about Billy/Vanessa, but I've rediscovered my love of them/Maeve/GL in general in the last six months or so. I know Vanessa/Matt had their fans, and Maeve's said she got plenty of fan mail from people who connected with Vanessa picking up her life and moving on. I'm actually glad to have found so much Billy/Vanessa online. They kind of predate VCRs, fandoms and squish names. Hell, they don't even really have a special song that's identified with them. It is what I envy the Matt fans---that story is probably almost all online.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I just wish they'd found someone with some soap cred to pair with Maeve. Not someone with "himbo" as his wheelhouse. I don't know who else was available in '94-'95 (and honestly, for all I care, they could've blown up Ross/Blake and given Ross/Vanessa a real shot finally) but there had to be SOMEONE. LOL...as I was watching the custody battle, and suddenly Josh is all intense and defending Vanessa, and pissed at Ross ...I'm like---geez, OMG, would they have gone there? They were already taking enough heat for hooking up Roger and Holly at the time, so I don't know if they would've crossed that line. As much as Reva, Blake and Harley slept through families, it's not like GL didn't know how to write it. Vanessa always did have a blind spot when it came to her kids. She's always quick to defend Bill from any criticism, and she keeps defending WM's Dinah to the point of enabling her behavior. If there was anyone she'd really unleash on, it was a guy. Her fights with Billy could be brutal, and the best moment in the entire Vanessa/Fletch relationhip (imo) is when she rears up and tells him to never EVER make her chose between him and her son, 'cause Fletch ain't winning. Vanessa and Mindy were always close, but as Vanessa would swing in and out of Lewis sphere when not married to Billy. I watched her giving birth to Maureen, and while Josh and Reva finally show up as she's about to die (which really seemed like mostly an excuse for Dinah to bitch at Reva about Cassie), she's got flippin' Jenna moaning in her ear about their precious friendship. I'm like bisch, step back, you're boring the woman to death. Lonitrat? Is that when they were gaslighting Roger? Seriously---about the only people in town not involved were the Coopers. Even Tangie took a side (I'm not sure why, but she was on Vanessa's.) YES! another Ross/Vanessa fan. Maeve's smile always seemed a little more sparkly if she were smiling at Jerry or Jordan. Her face just lights up. I get a little sad thinking of GL at the end--it's like we only got Vanessa back because Ross died.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
yeah, just pretty much anything you can define. I've recently discovered I'm not fond of Fiona Hutchinson and her irritating accent, but that wasn't exactly a story. lol. Most stories at least have some promise to them--I know The Fishing Picture story gets hammered, but I give it points for being a huge umbrella story that didn't overly rewrite established history (Brandon had never been a huge character on the show, he's mostly the off-screen big bad that the Spauldings blamed for their dysfunction.) Obviously even when shows honored their history, they tweaked them. The way Henry talks about Brandon, you wonder why he ever considered them "friends". And somehow, I think Alexandra started out as Alan's older sister, but in the '89 stuff, Alan talks about protecting his younger sister from Brandon's rages.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I had not seen them since they aired! I've really always considered myself more of an ATWT fan, and I while I remembered the broadstrokes of what went on, I had forgotten so many of the details. And some of the early 80's stuff I'd never, ever seen because I was in school. God bless utube. I'd listen to any of them talk about anything from back in the day. I was so sad we'll never get Lisa/Michael/Maeve talking about the early 80's. I'll have to check and see if they did one about Jerry verDorn.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
Challenge accepted: Dolly Chelsea's stalker The Dreaming Death San Cristobell Jeffrey O'Neill Reva the Amish Ben Reade Serial Killer Cyrus Paul Valere Infinity disHM, the two plots with Carrie Nye, the ridiculous Cottage from Hell and the mega-history rewrite of Billy/Josh/Buzz/Ed/Alan's pasts.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
LOL...Julie/Bridget could've been epic, had not there been a revolving door of Harts. JS was much more interesting as a tramp than the boring teen. That could be. At the point I picked it up (which seemed to be right after Nick and Mindy's wedding), Vanessa didn't even know Ross was Bridget's lawyer. I skipped around a bit, and Vanessa was hyper-focused on the case. After the hearing, she was so pissed at Ross that refused to go to his wedding to Blake. I don't mind that Vanessa and Dinah's relationship is so complicated. It lets Dinah avoid the trap that Reva's kids fell into (which is being "normal" after such a chaotic upbringing, ie terminally boring). And what's never quite expressed (at least from the spotty rewatching I've done) is that Vanessa sees the same self-destructiveness in Dinah that she herself had at that age. It's just that they almost acted like '86-88 with Dinah didn't happen. Granted, Vanessa left at the beginning of '88. But Dinah had a lot of time with Ross, and when Vanessa returns to town in '89, she and Ross are in touch with Dinah and everything's good. But then in '94 Ross is blaming Vanessa for having a "almost non-existent" relationship with his kid. I also don't know if Dinah ever did, but if she'd thrown it in Vanessa's face that she was a better mother to Mindy and Dylan than her, that I could've understood. I just don't think Mindy and Dinah were in town at the same time other than '87. LOL...yeah, Blake saw exactly what trouble Dinah was. It takes one to know one.. I don't know why Vanessa/Matt was more than a fling either. I don't see chemistry, but I know that's subjective. All I can think is that some of GL's pairings were low watt anyway (Ed/Eve, Nick/Mindy) and it was to move the plot along. I didn't realize it until recently---Billy doesn't have a serious love interest other than Vanessa for his entire run. I do not count Reva, although I will concede Nadine, depending on the definition of "serious". I know there was Selena, and they tried some kind of triangle with Holly & Buzz, which just seems inconceivable to me. Some of that is timing. But it seems like Reva got a new love interest every year over the same period.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
*sigh* It seems to be (at the time) the go to move for "older" characters to hook up with someone almost inappropriately young (Ross/Blake, Ed/Eve) lovers. Maybe it was a hot topic in the mid-90's? (my apologies to Kurt McKinney fans, but this is less about him than the infuriating writing where Vanessa is only "liberated" by this horse's ass after years of running her own damn life...but I digress.) I'm split on Dinah---dramatically, I get it. But she is usually so f***ing horrible to Vanessa I want her to just go away. I'm annoyed that Vanessa is roasted over a spit for nearly 15 years (off and on) for putting her up for adoption, while other "long lost" children spend about six months being mad and get over it. I think Maeve gets overlooked for being understated. It's just so opposite of what most actresses would've been tempted to do. Maeve is never cartoon-ish, now matter how outrageous the material. Oh, and back to the hearing, just when I'm saying to myself "hey, where's Nadine, who's really responsible for this mess?"....Ross throws her up on the stand, and she apologizes to Bridget. If she ever managed to apologize to Vanessa, I hope Van threw it back in her face. And Morgan Englund impressed me. I'd forgotten how much he improved from his days in wife-beaters mooning over Sam.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
The temp was just for one day, which is just odd. The scenes you're looking for are here at the end. Vanessa spends the 5/30 episode in Billy and Nadine's attic, reading Bridget's depostion about the last months of her pregnancy. Then Vanessa flashes back to after she gave birth to Dinah during Bridget's testimony on the stand. Honestly, Maeve was robbed of an emmy. I watched from about mid-April to mid-June, and it's devastatingly good. It made me mad all over again that they then end up throwing her at himbo Matt. It's rich and character driven. That's what happens when you put a good story in the hands of actors who've been in those role for 15+ years. 'Cause it's not only Ross, Vanessa and Ed, it's got a good dose of Roger, Holly and Josh (who is a hell of a lot more interesting away from Reva) and Henry, who ends up reaming Ross after Vanessa's turn on the stand. Vanessa confirms she had Dinah at 17, the summer before she went to college.
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I had been avoiding the second half of '93, as it crushes my Billy/Vanessa heart, but I ventured into '94 to try and find the custody battle over Peter. HOLY SH#T. It gets intense between Ross and Vanessa, with both of them dragging Ed into the middle. (Or at the very least Vanessa, who goes there at one point and threatens to drag up Ed's affair with Lillian if Ross crucifies her on the stand) That's a little before this, which is Ross brutally questioning her at the hearing. Oddly, the episode before this has that fake Vanessa again stepping in for Maeve (in what I swear is the same suit she wore in '92, when she single-handedly kills the momentum of Bill's running away). I suppose it was all a set up for bringing Dinah back, but damn.
- As The World Turns Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread