I think Martha Madison would make a great Sarah Webber.  She did a great job playing Elizabeth when Rebecca Herbst was out.  She even dyed her hair to look more like Rebecca Herbst. I like Madison as Belle, and think she's much better than Kisten Storms would be.  Heck Madison could replace Storms as Maxie, LOL. 

I am pretty positive MM was wearing a wig as Liz.  And she could not replace Storms as Maxie.  I don't even like KS as Maxie, but MM can barely handle Belle.  Maxie is quirky and has humor.  MM does not bring any of that to the table.  KS was a much better Belle as well.

7 hours ago, carolineg said:

I am pretty positive MM was wearing a wig as Liz.  And she could not replace Storms as Maxie.  I don't even like KS as Maxie, but MM can barely handle Belle.  Maxie is quirky and has humor.  MM does not bring any of that to the table.  KS was a much better Belle as well.

Martha Madison did dye her hair for the role; she only wore a wig for the June 9 episode.

Her natural (dyed) hair:

Wig:

1 hour ago, Liberty City said:

Martha Madison did dye her hair for the role; she only wore a wig for the June 9 episode.

Her natural (dyed) hair:

Wig:

I stand corrected.  For some reason I only remember that wig.  MM looks pretty good as a brunette.  Anyhow, I still don't think she could play Maxie at all.

21 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I stand corrected.  For some reason I only remember that wig.  MM looks pretty good as a brunette.  Anyhow, I still don't think she could play Maxie at all.

I know Madison was teasing going darker again in June; I wouldn't want her as Maxie, either. Jen Lilley or Molly Burnett would be my choices for re-claiming that role, honestly....

Jen Lilley was on Dishin Days a few years back and made it seem as she would never do GH again

 

Molly could work if she was open to it

I really enjoyed JL as Maxie and I have always liked Molly Burnett.  I would like either of them back, but I still think Maxie as a character just needs a rest.  I would write Maxie out for at least a year and then revisit recast options and/or KS again.

Maxie and Michael both need to be rested a minimum of 3-4 to 2-4 years, respectively.

30 minutes ago, John said:

Jen Lilley was on Dishin Days a few years back and made it seem as she would never do GH again

Didn't make it seem; she's gone on to state she wouldn't, because of her experience there.

I tend to think Michael needs a recast more than a rest.  Although having Willow die and Michael leaving town for awhile wouldn't be a bad thing either.

9 minutes ago, Vee said:

Maxie and Michael both need to be rested a minimum of 3-4 to 2-4 years, respectively.

Pair them together (as teased some time ago), and have them go live off-screen in Pine Valley, etc. and then return broken up.

Just now, Liberty City said:

Didn't make it seem; she's gone on to state she wouldn't, because of her experience there.

What was her experience?  Was it the fans or behind the scenes?  It was a really strange situation.  KS kept extending her leave and I really thought Lilley was permanent after so much time. 

4 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

Pair them together (as teased some time ago), and have them go live off-screen in Pine Valley, etc. and then return broken up.

Nah. It was my own idea to pair them ten years ago as screwball opposites with an intriguing older irresponsible woman angle. Today both actors and characters are beyond spent and don't need new story to write them out. You can revisit that idea when there are fresh options (and hopefully a more invigorated Kirsten Storms if possible) after Maxie spends 3-4 years offscreen.

3 minutes ago, carolineg said:

What was her experience?  Was it the fans or behind the scenes?  It was a really strange situation.  KS kept extending her leave and I really thought Lilley was permanent after so much time. 

And she was horribly treated by fans, something KS IIRC passively encouraged.

That being said, no, I do not think she should return. An actor like Lilley being decent in a role or badly treated by the show, or just a nice person IRL (hi, Martha Madison), does not mean they should be given the job or change the fact that certain characters are burnt out and need to go for awhile or in some other cases permanently.

5 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I tend to think Michael needs a recast more than a rest.  Although having Willow die and Michael leaving town for awhile wouldn't be a bad thing either.

I think people are sick of Michael in general, not just Chad. Michael is a wimpy joke at this point. He needs a break. Not as long as Maxie, but awhile.

Edited August 8, 20232 yr by Vee

Just now, carolineg said:

I tend to think Michael needs a recast more than a rest.

Robert Adamson was such a nice change of pace. I don't necessarily hate Chad Duell. I just feel like he has rested in the role, and when an actor is resting... it's time for them to go

5 minutes ago, carolineg said:

What was her experience?  Was it the fans or behind the scenes?  It was a really strange situation.  KS kept extending her leave and I really thought Lilley was permanent after so much time. 

She stated she was pressured to stay as thin as she was while on set when filming, and found it unhealthy.

5 minutes ago, Vee said:

Nah. It was my own idea to pair them ten years ago as screwball opposites with an intriguing older irresponsible woman angle. Today both actors and characters are beyond spent and don't need new story to write them out. You can revisit that idea when there are fresh options (and hopefully a more invigorated Kirsten Storms if possible) after Maxie spends 3-4 years offscreen.

When Jonah "died," and Michael was going to grief meetings or whatever, I sensed a possible pairing between Maxie & Michael, and I wouldn't have hated it. My one worry with writing Maxie out is that Felicia would possibly re-fade into the background, and I wouldn't want that. I need my Felicia on-canvas.

I remember Lilley being treated badly by fans, but I also remember her saying some boneheaded things and actually getting into it with KS online.   I really enjoyed JL as Maxie so I would welcome her back eventually.   I was just curious if she ever said anything about the recast situation.  I have always wondered what was really going on behind the scenes.  Her run kept getting extended and extended and it seemed so chaotic how GH handled the situation.

I really wouldn't miss Maxie or Michael.  I just think both performers are a big part of the problem although Maxie has run through years of story and is written into more a corner than Michael.