Jump to content

FX: American Horror Story


Toups

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 340
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • 3 weeks later...
  • Members

What was Connie Britton like on Friday Night Lights? The few times I've seen her on this show she's done hilariously awful Valley of the Dolls style acting. Ryan Murphy shows spit on acting, it's just about hysteria and poses, but I wondered if this is just what she does on all her shows.

I thought this was an interesting article. It's nice to see a writer finally call out the bigoted views of Murphy's writing, and she does it in a way that goes with the flow of her fascination with the show.

http://www.fempop.com/2011/11/21/american-horror-story-shocks-but-not-like-you-think/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

That is a worthwhile read--and I enjoy the show largely for the very reasons she initially gives. At first when I saw the link I thought it would be an article about how Murphy (and yes Falchuk who never seems to get the credit or blame for his work as co creator on every Murphy show post Popular, probably because he doesn't like to give arrogant, stupid interviews like Murphy loves to do--like his recent one with EW where he seemed to realize he gave away, while bragging, a major spoiler for future episodes and they had to hours later go back and delete it--but I digree) are misogynistic. And they probably are--but I do honestly think they make the male characters at least as stupid and repulsive as the female ones.

I'm not sure I'm fully on the anti-choice thing--at least not fully. On one hand horror stories are known to almost always take elements like that--that cause queasiness and controversy--and build their frights from them. So I'm not sure it's as easy to place that view on the creator, as much as it's just another thing that riles people up--and scares many people even who are pro-choice, or at the least makes them unvomfortable. Also, I think, but I could be wrong, that it's been shown that the house itself is what created the doctor's increased madness, dependency on drugs, etc, in th first place--before he started performing abortions. And it could maybe even be argued that the show is condeming the fact that the laws many people want, and we once had, caused the need for these inept abortion doctors in the first place. But the show's really not that deep, so I won't try to argue that.

As for Connie-I only saw the first season of Friday Night Lights, and that's all I know her from, but I thought she was absolutely *great* in it. I think she's ok in this--as I've said McDermott is the only one I find really not good--considering the material and how vague her role is. The show is all abotu atmosphere and that doesn't leave much direction for her character or motivation--Lange is lucky because she's playing a caricature of all her award nominated Tennessee Williams' grande dames--Maggie, Blanche and Amanda--and can just run with it.

And yet, and I know I'll hate myself at some point for admitting this, it's currently the one show I most look forward to each week.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I thought both Quinto and Sears were fine (I still haven't seen tonight's episode in which they return I believe). They are played broadly as stereotypes but frankly so is everyone on the show, particularly the characters/"ghosts" in flashback, and in this case (though I do think Murphy and Falchuk have a very weird mixed message thing when it comes to gays) I don't think their catty comments to each other were all that offensive (or even all that different from the way I've seen a few fighting gay couple friends of mine interact). I twasn't bitchy on the level of Boys in the Band and a number of other things.

LOL what spoiler do you mean?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

You said he gave away a Glee spoiler and had to retract it.

It seems like the message of Murphy shows regrading gays is what you would find in the Celluloid Closet - gays are bitchy, sad, tragic people, and not in a noble way, like we were supposed to see Christian and Sean on Nip/Tuck as noble. Just in a freak show way. The only exception is Kurt on Glee, who is the biggest Mary Sue ever, and who seems to represent Murphy.

Spoiler for tonight's episode.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...
  • 3 months later...
  • 3 weeks later...

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I know this isn’t a usual or anywhere near universal take, but I loved the relatively brief Hal/Emily relationship/marriage more than I ever thought I would have with KMH/BH.
    • In my field (not that) I've written my share of dreck when it's what people wanted vs. something good. In the end what matters is the check. These pilots may not be great, but whether or not those writers intended otherwise they got paid.
    • I think there is plenty to critique and/or roast about the show, but I think there's also good bones and a lot of progressive improvement. It's the Bell/B&B formula and house style that is hardest for it to shake and the most necessary IMO, as well as some dead weight actors or characters, but that formula also apparently works for a lot of general viewers and I suspect CBS. OTOH it's also very modern in certain ways (sometimes overly hip dialogue, and some story) that still make it feel like a show that's bouncing between distant past staples of soap opera fundamentals and the present moment. And the old fashioned product placement is fun but also so goofy, while material like June is hysterical. Imagine leading with 'the underpass is where I live, and I like it there!' It's an unusual show in that way, because its identity and tone is still not fully formed. You don't know what it'll be. But that's normal at this juncture. The closest thing to a glimpse of the future foundation, I think (besides the obvious core family setup that's been there since Day 1), is the rivalry and future familial bond - and likely love/hate relationship - between Kat and Eva. A la many central sisters or siblings throughout soap history.
    • I loved Kelley Menighan! She was an MVP, especially during the show’s last few years. I always looked forward to anything she did with MM, BH, CZ, MW,  and the two grownup Alisons. Wasn’t a big fan of her with RH’s Paul. I always admired how she balanced being a vixen and being neurotic.
    • LLC can be a lot (lady definitely doesn’t phone it in), but her scenes with Rena made me wish they played actual sisters on a better platform.  Aside from JE, who is a legend so it’s no surprise when she’s excellent, Amanda Setton is my MVP of this story and she hasn’t always been great in this role. You see so much happening in her face as she’s navigating the shifts and layers of this story. She’s fully locked in. Glad Rory Gibson is getting his due on GH. I knew he had more to give than what Y&R was giving him. The writing will be a factor here as well because the character of Michael hasn’t been written well in ages (if ever, arguably). GH just can’t sustain the good stuff for more than a few weeks. Alexa Havins is a very good actress and was widely embraced as Lulu initially, but the character’s one-note abrasiveness has a lot of folks wishing she was gone at this point. 
    • It's pilots like "Hurricane Sam" and "Anything for Love" that makes me so afraid to write professionally, because, my God, what if I actually tried and came up with something just as awful, if not worse (if that's even possible)?
    • JANUARY 1974 SPECIALS ADDED... Here are the January 1974 specials which have been added to the yearly list on page 76:

      Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Wow, you have the patience of a saint watching through this period. I think the show does get better but it takes a while.  I won't give any spoilers about Zachary, but I will drop a slight hint: GL was probably trying to get a ratings boost by doing a story inspired by one of CBS's few primetime hits in the mid-1990s. And no, Zachary does not turn out to be a Texas ranger. 
    • Love makes everything possible.

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Please register in order to view this content

         
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy