Jump to content

OLTL: Discussion for the Week of December 8th


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I don't understand how it's supposed to be fascinating psychological drama for a psychotic rapist who never pays for any of his crimes to hold his mentally impaired former rape victim hostage and brainwash her into thinking she loves him in a pathetic, desperate attempt to remake her in his own sick fantasy. Then after he's caught, we have to see the ex-wife who he beat up and deserted defend him and rip his victim apart on the witness stand in order to convince those of us who know how sick this all is that he didn't rape her yet again when we all know that he did. I must be missing something here. There is certainly potential for psychological drama, if they focused on Marty's journey back to a normal life after what was done to her again but they're not pursuing that. No, it's all about Todd, as always. Misunderstood Todd. Todd the victim. Todd against the world. Todd's lost everything. Everyone's out to get Todd so we can't hate him for being the evil predator that he really is. Blah, blah, blah. It's just more of the same but with far more offensive undertones.

Carlivati clearly loves rehashing old stories, remaking them in his own vision. This time he's not merely making a joke of some good characters or a great former story like he did with Tina's return and 1968, he is actively undoing a lot of positive cultural movement that this show helped spawn. He's taking this show back to the freaking dark ages in terms of gender and sexual politics. Sadly, our culture has long connected rape with sex and even love instead of power, violence, and misogyny. With Todd's insistence that he "loves Marty" and Tea informing him that he's never loved anyone because "Marty was always in his head" this show is attempting to romanticize the victim/abuser relationship. The good old "she really wanted it, deep down" or "he only did it because he wanted her so much" mentalities that have destroyed the lives of so many rape victims over the years by blaming them for their being attacked and that the initial rape story did a great deal to dispel. I have to wonder how long it'll be before we see Marty going to Todd, on her hands and knees, begging for his forgiveness because of what she "put him through" and thanking him for the gang rape because she was uppity and needed to be taken down a peg. Yeah I know, RC won't go there, right? Yeah, that's what everyone said about them developing "feelings" for each other. Everyone said that he'd never let them have sex either. Everyone said that Todd would be killed off soon after she was found. Everyone's been wrong so far. At every opportunity with this story, this show has sunk even lower than almost anyone imagined and this is only the beginning of the fallout.

I've seen alot of people in the ratings threads lament and wonder how OLTL can be so wonderful and the ratings not show it. The answer is simple: it ain't that great. It's probably better than all the others right now and while it had a few good months earlier this year, they were followed by several months of utter garbage and it's only now starting to pull itself together again. OLTL's biggest probably is that it's still horribly inconsistent. Not just week-to-week or day-to-day but scene-to-scene even. There are scenes of power, emotional weight, and humor but then they're ruined by infantile camp, bad acting by teeny boppers, or something truly offensive to it's target demographic like Marty surmising from her conversation with Andrew yesterday that she was a terrible person until Todd raped her and that the only way to get her life back is to become just like Todd and hurt him back. Huh?! Stuff like that doesn't tend to fill women with that holiday spirit, no matter how many shiny trees are on the set or how many cheesy fake B&W Christmas movie clips they show.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 107
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I think the overall story with Todd and Marty is fairly indefensible, and I found the lovemaking disgusting and Todd to now be un-viable as a character. I think RC takes the hit for that. But I've found almost all the resultant drama since to be excellent. While Todd may be parroting this disgusting line about Marty's love changing him, and RC's comments may not help, the actual on-air show does not seem to be giving Todd much of a leg to stand on in the writing. Todd can give his POV til the cows come home, but no one on the show is really buying it (except Tea) and we are still allowed by PTB and the creative staff to see him as a sick criminal. So Todd's position, "she wanted it" has not really been endorsed.

It's a difficult situation right now; in the summer, I felt the show's heart was in the right place but bogged down in too much light comedy and camp. RC has done well with comedy before, and I don't think it's a dirty word, especially on a show that has a history of going as dark as OLTL, but there was just too much. Then this fall, the Tarty story went berserk, the Montez storyline lurched into gear and then sort of stopped, and the Tess thing went on forever. Now we seem to be in a transitory stage, where there's a clean slate on a lot of those stories, some compelling new ones, one dud (Vanessa/Cristian), and one ugly, ugly story which is now being written pretty well, but wasn't worth the cost. (Tarty) I think this is easily the best the show has been since May/June, which was very good, but I hesitate to jump on the "OMFG SO AWESOME" bandwagon yet. While I think the show is overall pretty good right now and I am one of RC's earliest and biggest fans, he's made some huge blunders, and you are correct that this story with Todd has already violated a lot of viewers' trust, mine included, and could do so again at any point. (For example, the events coming next week - repulsive on their face, but it depends on how the situation is played; whether

)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I respectfully disagree, though I not so respectfully will call Roseanne bug-eyed. I thinkVanessa is much hotter, she has a smidge of a latina MCE thing going on. I could NOT STAND Roseanne, ugh... "Chrisshun Chrisshun Chrisshun..."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Great show today. Nice Friday cliffhanger with Tea bursting into court. Tea's in Llanview to kick some @$$ isn't she? LOL

I just want to say how enjoyable the show has been these past few weeks. When you have a soap like GL or GH which basically say F--- you to the many fans of the show, it's great to enjoy a well written OLTL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Rover, I get tired of defending Todd and Marty, don't you? I guess there are two sides to this - either you get it and enjoy it or you don't! No matter what side of the coin you are on, it's certainly a hot topic of discussion. I have noticed that plenty of the folks who "hate" this story or those who are offended by it have continued to watch. That tells me a lot.

Michael, I knew Tea would be fun, and I have not been disappointed! What a firecracker she is!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Tea Delgado is made of pure awesome.

I am LOVING how she's being written. This is the tough as nails attorney who first showed up in Llanview, yet they have also given her moments where you see that softer side underneath.

When she walked into the courtroom yesterday? Just so fun!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Thank you for the info about SFT related to EON. I thought about adding SFT to my watch list, but I don't know if it's the kind of soap for me. I know very little about it except for a few of the actors and that it was on two different networks. I also know based on this board or somewhere else that the two Lizas both died young from cancer. Warms my heart to see so many EON people on SFT because they are such good performers and I wish they had been moved to other shows. Perhaps, they were and I'm just not aware of it.
    • There was a few times when Silk Press Sheila came into her apartment after going grocery shopping.. she could have been unloading her items as she talked to Eva or Ted and saw a few of the products on the counter that are P & G products.
    • I enjoyed today's show. I liked seeing Mona again and her confronting both Eva and Leslie. I did feel for Eva, especially at the end of their confrontation, when Mona said "Good", when Eva mentioning losing everybody she cared about. Though, I can understand Mona's anger and Leslie deserved every bit of her ire. Both Leslie/Eva betrayed her especially Leslie. Mona put her both her professional and personal relationships with the Duprees on the line and what Leslie/Eva did put her in an awkward position. Speaking of Leslie she continues to act trifling and caring only about herself and her needs. At this point, it only seems like she cares about herself and wanting Ted for herself. I'm not even sure how if her feelings for Mona were even sincere, though she called out about people turning against her after Mona left. I have yet to see Leslie really display that she sincerely cares about anyone, and I do think that needs to change at some point. I enjoyed Nicole and her scenes today with Leslie/her children. I also like that Martin took a more sensible approach regarding how the family should handle Eva. He did straight up acknowledge she was his sister, and it seemed like he was opened to up to accepting her. I think he will be among the first in the family to soften towards/accept her. And in spite of the way she was introduced into their lives, he will end up being happy to have two little sisters. I wonder again about Kat/Eva being twins/Eva being Nicole, when Martin/Kat brought up them being the same age and Kat even used the word "twins" in disbelief, when Martin suggested they shared a connection from the beginning.
    • LOL! They did show a Pantene and Dawn commercial today. Image them incorporating those into the show. 
    • He joined Julian in Bermuda when he getting a divorce from Ivy. And, was the one who tricked Theresa and Julian in to believing that they had gotten married there. That would be nice.  That was such a good book, and it was too bad that the show retconned it so much. I still have my copy somewhere.
    • Instead of Febreze, Eva pulled a few tissues of Puffs and cried into them. Hayley comes in with a pack of Always and is like "Well, Bill turns out I'm not pregnant." Andre and Derek sharing a bottle of Pepto after eating Ashley's cooking. Vernon and Anita drinking up their Metamucil. 
    •   I liked the actress who played Tina. She was not the typical soap hire. I hadn't thought of her in many years until I saw a Spauldingfield video of her. It makes sense if they were planning to make her Frank's daughter as she was tied to the Coopers and nothing else was done with her beyond singing and the relationship with Marcus that Rauch never cared about. David was hurt by Monti Sharp leaving the role. I don't blame Monti for leaving, as he was getting less and less to do, but Russell Curry was a very generic actor was too old for the part. Yes, black don't crack, but he was nearly 40. When David returns at the end of the decade they cast an actor who was a little too young, which just shows how little interest the show had in the character or black characters in general (and random recasting would return with the Boudreauxs). Marcus is a character who got a lot of buzz early on and then the show lost interest (again).  Anyway, if you stay watching, be warned that the Hart/Dinah/Roger stuff gets worse and worse. Luckily you don't have the same lengthy ties to the show so it may be OK for you. It made me feel a bit sick at the time. Thanks for giving more info. And to @DeeVee and @P.J. as well. I suppose there were tiers of people who were seen as disposable, and Eve was shielded for a time due to that tier. Once they were clearly getting rid of characters like Justin or Amanda, then she was also on that list (I know she left before they did but it wasn't that long before). Characters like Eve, quiet, able to be used in many avenues, are important for community, or they should be, although she had clearly reached a natural end. The problem is no one really replaced her - all the characters who were likely seen as dull were shipped out from 83-85, and we were left with an unbalanced canvas (and characters who were meant to be exciting but were still dull, like Calla, Simon, et al).
    •   Footballers Wives! That takes me back 

      Please register in order to view this content

    • I just find her obnoxious and I need somebody to start checking her (other than Bill) without couching it in you’re so strong and wonderful and Bill did you so wrong. Even Anita pulls punches with her. Her personality would definitely rub some people the wrong way and I hope once the canvas evolves beyond Dupreeland, she gets some adversaries who aren’t villains or 90-lb. weaklings like Haley.
    • Wow.... Anita and Dani are the ultimate symbol of mean girls.   I hate to tell this to Dani... but Eva's ability to do hair is a much more coveted job and skill than Dani's modeling.   I doubt Dani could cut it if she lost her money and was truly forced to start over from square 1.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy