Emmerdale: Discussion Thread

[Bright Eyes]

The show still needs to get rid of Steve November anyway.

[Ben]

It has been confirmed. Someone will meet their maker in the Live episode. SB has said the person "has it coming".

[Bright Eyes]

My guess is Cameron or Robbie then. But if it's Carl, I will be f*cking pissed!

Edited October 10, 2012 by Bright Eyes

[BadBoy93]

I hope to god its not Carl that dies. He has so much more potential at being one of Emmerdale's most complex villians in its 40 year history. Might even rival Kim Tate as one of the best.

I actually think it might be Declan, seeing as SB said that the person dies "has it coming". Isn't Declan trying to swindle Megan off her money ? Maybe he meets an unfortunate demise.

Characters I'd axe are

Brenda Walker - No way to go and pretty much does nothing.

Priya Sharma - Similar and seeing as Alicia is coming back soon and will likely get with David, presents no other avenues left to explore.

Declan Macey - Only to introduce a new family into Home Farm

Cameron Murray - Dragging Debbie down and is just an uninteresting character

Alex Moss - Dull character and dragging Victoria down

Sean Spencer - Don't like the character at all

Ali Spencer - Don't like the character, Too shouty and show off

Rishi Sharma - No point in having him

Robbie Lawson - Poor villian. Kill him off or send him off to prison

Kerry Wyatt - If she isn't developed by Mid 2013, get rid of her

BRING BACK

Kim Tate, Nathan Wylde

[DRW50]

Great to see you here again.

[BadBoy93]

Thank you. I have been following so heres hoping I can start blogging with some more soap fans again

Tonight's episode was pretty good. I'm starting to like Katie a lot more now. I also hope Carl doesn't die.

[DRW50]

New producer.

http://www.digitalspy.com/soaps/s12/emmerdale/news/a430844/emmerdale-kate-oates-named-new-producer.html

[DRW50]

What a waste. No one who fills out a pair of jeans that way should ever be killed off. One of the hottest men ever in soaps.

What an awful way to end Chas/Carl. I don't see where she can go now.

[Ann_SS]

Chas is overexposed anyway. Regardless, she did not kill Carl, Cameron did so if anyone is going next, it is him.

I have to say that I don't mind them killing off Carl. His violent death feels like karma. Too bad EE won't do the with Phil Mitchell.

[DRW50]

If they needed to go there I would have done it based on his behavior toward his family, mroeso than the sudden violent obsession with Chas. The whole story of Carl was that he was so screwed up and weak he inadvertently caused harm. The end didn't seem like him.

[DRW50]

So is Dan gone? I doubt she'll be getting together with Cameron. I wonder if she may actually be alone for a while.

[Ann_SS]

My favorite part of the episode is when Nikhil and Gennie held their baby girl. Too bad so much time was spent with sad sack Debbie's birth.

[Ben]

So, they did it. They killed Carl, and made him and evil, attempted rapist to boot. More character assassination from SB.

What a horrible story. Cameron should have died. Carl should never have been ruined and written out. This story is so predictable. Chas thinks she killed Carl, and Cameron will let her believe it (or some variation), while Jimmy will be the number 1 suspect, due to his cuts and bruises from the fight with Carl.

The Gennie/Nikhil scenes were great. They had some good character interaction during the birth, with Val wanting her to mess the carpet so she could claim it on the insurance, and Lizzie the blind woman, being the only one not to have had a drink and fit to drive her to the hospital. Sian Reece Williams did a great job in those scenes.

IA, too much Debbie. Her giving birth in this episode wasn't necessary, IMO.

I quite liked the Declan/Katie/Megan/Robbie scenes. Maybe it was b/c something was happening. Although, when Katie was recapping everything, she forgot to mention how Robbie attacked her, which is what started her and Declan's revenge on Megan. I guess Katie is the villain in the story.

The Live episode was produced well, and the acting was good, shame about the suck-y writing.

[Y&RWorldTurner]

http://www.digitalsp...hrills-88m.html

The ratings, though up, seem very anemic for the hype and interest associated with anniversary/live episodes.

Edited October 18, 2012 by Y&RWorldTurner

[DRW50]

I think people are kind of over live episodes. I guess this is about what you could expect for Emmerdale. They were on the road to stronger ratings a few years ago but sort of threw that away with Viv's and Terry's shameful exits and the Jackson story, among others.

I feel like Emmerdale and Corrie are lucky they haven't lost millions of viewers the last few years.