Aside from having the plastic surgery angle, I dont see the two stories, all that similar. Erica/Jane story has more in common with the Janet/Natalie one than Janet/Jane

Jane shows Erica what she looked like before the crash. I wanna see

Well that explains everything.

And I mean everything.

My feelings are not hurt, I could care less if you think they're cheesy, I just don't see the purpose of going out of your way to attack others for what they're saying, especially when it's a conversation between specific members that don't include you. There's a difference between a dialogue or argument about an topic and a blatant attack.

I didn't attack anybody. If you want me to attack, then this is what it will look like: I think you're an immature little boy who doesn't comprehend the fact that a critical opinion is NOT an attack. So go back to asking for your insipid little cast lists and whining about your fantasies of what the main title openings should look like -- all without having a clue as to how things actually work in television production. Now that's an attack.

Saying I find the Facebook statuses embarrassing is just my opinion. You're the one who got a bitchy attitude about my comment -- as if the daily thread is the place for Fan Fantasy Facebook statuses and I should just accept it. Go start another thread for that garbage and then I wouldn't have a leg to stand on. But coming in here, weeding through 1^1/2 pages of "clever" Facebook posts that have nothing to do with this particular episode is ridiculous... and I said something about it.

Edited July 23, 201114 yr by R Sinclair

JR was embarrasing to watch today! I thought JY did a riveting job though. I was shocked when JR stumbled over that chair and fell, that looked like it HURT. I rewinded 6 times and was astounded at how well choreographed that was. Also lol @ JR's "Woof! Woof! Woof!" at AJ.

the JR/Bianca scene outside the Chandler house was excellent

I can't believe the Erica/David confrontation was held at ConFusion. Really? REALLY? Pretty much killed it for me, I hated the music blasting in the background. Well I hope Erica doesn't instantly forgive Jack when he realizes it wasn't her the whole time I can't believe he's buying into David's crap.

at Jessie saying "I don't know what's going on, but I like it."

Well that explains everything.

And I mean everything.

It reeks of a storyline she'd concoct as well, so why not?

JR was embarrasing to watch today!

Did you say embarrassing? Shhhh... Don't attack JR like that! Shame on you!

It reeks of a storyline she'd concoct as well, so why not?

True. But I was thinking more in terms of certain things we know and have seen about Jane: plain, wishes to be like someone else, has no bio-kids, raises others as her own, bottomless pit for attention, difficulty socializing with others, insecure........

....still a virgin.

Edited July 23, 201114 yr by YurSoakinginit

True. But I was thinking more in terms of certain things we know and have seen about Jane: plain, wishes to be like someone else, has no bio-kids, raises others as her own, bottomless pit for attention, difficulty socializing with others, insecure........

....still a virgin.

No, I got where you were going... I've been VERY outspoken about Aunt Meg working her own personal issues out through the stories she's written for these shows. She's ashamed of her sexuality. She envies strong women. She has Daddy Issues. She wishes she were blonde and she dislikes the family she has and wishes the perfect, longlost family would come into her life and immediately love her in a way her real family didn't. I said all that five years ago.

This is such a ridiculous turn of thread. I only sometimes agree with what R Sinclair has to say, but how is his opinion worse than anyone else? At lease he points out why he's annoyed, unlike some who suggest writers are going in one direction and damn them for that...

I think Megan McTavish is a hack for the ages, but none of us know her like that.

Edited July 23, 201114 yr by Vee

Brilliant!

GREAT MINX/JR/AJ scenes!

David just admitted to fraud. If Erica is crazy PVH sale is null/void!

Brot is world's WORSE Police person!

Yes MINX is rushed but so are all the sl's.

Yeah, Minx was rushed, and I'm sure the Jane story was too, but at this point, I'm just glad Jane is gone and I don't mind not seeing Marissa struggle more before deciding she wanted Bianca. I did love the JR/Minx/AJ scenes; JR/Bianca was riveting and it was surprisingly nice that AJ didn't care that his mom was with another woman.

I might be the only one, but overall, I thought this was an excellent episode.

I loved Tad's memorial and it even brought tears to my eyes. Sure, Liza was out of place but as Tad said, everyone he invited was there because they helped him deal with Dixie's death.

Dixie herself hasn't spoken to anyone since her return, so I didn't expect her to open up to Angie. She doesn't seem to know who to trust.

Erica showing up at ConFusion was funny. Her explanation of how Jane & Ben were holding her does sound crazy!

Once again, we had some great Friday cliffhangers with Erica/David and Dixie/JR. For the second weekend in a row, I can't wait for Monday!

I loved Tad's memorial and it even brought tears to my eyes. Sure, Liza was out of place but as Tad said, everyone he invited was there because they helped him deal with Dixie's death.

How did Liza help him deal with Dixie's death? She didnt show up in town till 2 years later. He was already "over" her death by then

Okay, so let me get this straight: Ben and Jane just let Erica go, no questions asked and the first place Erica goes is home to shower and change? Not call her girls. Not call Jack. Just goes to change clothes? Then what, she wanted to party at Confusion? (It's possible that Jane was supposed to meet David there or something, but still) That's it, that's how this storyline ends? Really?

I still need to see Erica and Jane in the same room with someone other than David and/or Ben before I can believe that Jane actually existed and wasn't just Erica's split personality.

That said, I LOL'd at Real Erica biting David and then trying to choke his ass. Welcome home, honey, welcome home. They best hide the silverware at Confusion, La Kane is out for blood...David's. Hehe.

ETA and OT: Did I do something to my settings here, or is the font, etc. purposely smaller?

Edited July 23, 201114 yr by Kylie

Did anyone notice that Dixie was leaning against the park bench dedicated to Langley Wallingford?

It will be very interesting to see what happens with JR/Dixie. Since he's drunk, I'm guessing that he probably thinks he's hallucinating, gets angry about that, and storms off.

Did anyone notice that Dixie was leaning against the park bench dedicated to Langley Wallingford?

I did not, but I love that.

I wonder who was in charge of putting the names on the park benches (in the real world, not in the show's world). I'd be a very pleased fanboy if we randomly saw a Frank Grant bench or Mary Kennicott bench.